Summary by TwinMind · 15m 57s
Summary by TwinMind · 15m 57s
Ancient Pompeii’s Hidden Messages, Preserved in Graffiti | Jacqueline DiBiasie-Sammons | TED
Ancient Pompeii’s Hidden Messages, Preserved in Graffiti | Jacqueline DiBiasie-Sammons | TED
TED
TED
Introduction - Speaker's Connection to Pompeii
- Speaker shares birth date with Mount Vesuvius eruption (August 24th)
- Started learning Latin in high school, couldn't connect with Julius Caesar or Ovid's poetry
- Wanted to understand ordinary Romans' daily lives and thoughts
- Discovered Latin graffiti in college - first time hearing ordinary Romans' voices
- Visiting Pompeii allowed standing next to columns, imagining ancient conversations
Ancient vs Modern Graffiti Differences
- Modern graffiti: typically illegal/taboo, spray painted or scratched into surfaces like bathroom stalls
- Ancient graffiti: welcome/permitted, appeared everywhere (temples, tombs, bars, public spaces, homes)
- Creation method: Ancient graffiti scratched into wall plaster using stylus or nail
- Etymology: English "graffiti" from Italian word meaning "scratched" (coined by 19th century archaeologists)
- Authors: Written by wide variety including marginalized people (women, enslaved) - best evidence for those excluded from literary record
- Reason for prevalence: No access to inexpensive writing tools like paper, used walls like modern scrap paper/phones/social media
Famous Pompeii Graffiti Examples
- Birth announcement: "On Saturday August 2nd at around 9:30 PM you vanilla was born" with drawing of baby
- Written by proud parent nearly 2,000 years ago
- Volcanic eruption in 79 A.D. preserved thousands of graffiti
- Labyrinth graffito: "This is the Labyrinth the Minotaur lives here" with mythological drawing
- Written inside private home (no taboo about writing in personal space)
- Wall commentary: "Oh whoa I'm amazed you haven't fallen down holding up so many scribblings"
- Repeated several times throughout Pompeii
- Shows Pompeians' awareness of graffiti abundance
- This example from amphitheater where gladiators fought
Charcoal and Chalk Graffiti Research
- Current research focus: Graffiti written with perishable materials (charcoal, chalk)
- Scholarly neglect: Almost totally ignored by modern scholars, very few survived
- Characteristics: More flourishing, inventive, elegant than inscribed counterparts
- Technique: Easier to draw on wall plaster than inscribe into it
- Example: "Victor with fellow Terrace everywhere" written at city gate
- Made with chalk or clot of earth
- Elegant Roman cursive with large flourishes on V, Y, R letters
- Playful branch included to complete message
- Charcoal graffito above showing "Victor" with flourishing V and portrait
Aesthetics and Playfulness
- Research interest: Ancient aesthetics - what writing style reveals about author and motivations
- Upside-down alphabet example: Found in bath house
- Latin alphabet interspersed forwards and backwards (A, X, B, U, C, T, etc.)
- Written upside down (unknown if author stood upside down or twisted body)
- Shows playfulness of Roman graffiti
- Even utilitarian messages written with elegant writing (C and D letter tails cross)
- Pompeian priority: Not enough to write on walls - wanted to write beautifully
Virtual Tour of Vicolo Dominandro
- Location: Small street in residential district, one block off main avenue
- Position: Between theater and amphitheater
- Graffiti patterns: Many names, mostly male (more men literate than women)
- Female literacy: Used to assume very few women literate, but Pompeii graffiti complicated this picture
Prima and Secundus Message Exchange
- Prima's greeting: "Prima sends many greetings to secundus"
- Prima/Secundus = first/second in Latin (names or nicknames)
- Written on facade wall plaster (equivalent of tweet/Snapchat - wall posts existed 2,000+ years)
- Roman cursive with economical letter forms (E's become two vertical marks)
- Included interpunct (horizontal dot) between words showing elegant writing
- Drawings below: Four boars, three birds, gladiator, ship, partridge
- Scholar Catherine Huntley used developmental psychology suggesting some by children
- Others by adults replicating seen/heard images
- Shows urge to doodle as feature of human spirit
Secundus's Reply Messages
- First message: "Secundus two greets his Prima everywhere I ask mistress that you love me"
- Written in capital letters (not cursive like Prima) so wouldn't be missed
- Accentuated with box surrounding for highlighting/official appearance
- Left off M's on words (not pronounced - like saying "gonna" instead of "going to")
- Two additional greetings: "Secundus greets us Prima" and "Secundus greets his Prima"
- Written by same person with same instrument
- Consistently left off 'a' in Prima's name (pronunciation issue)
- Shows Romans made spelling mistakes too
Motivations for Wall Writing
- Primary purpose: Get message to other person
- Secondary motivation: Thrill of discovery - leaving something for someone to find later
- Modern parallel: Sticky notes, lunchbox notes, social media posts
- Universal human behavior: Taking part in discovery experience
Additional Graffiti Examples
- Farewell greeting: "Wineria goodbye" with letter ends made to look like branches
- Puzzling graffito: Below farewell, doesn't make sense in Latin
- Possibly first attempt at graffito above or simpler replication attempt
- Shows range from elegant to ineffective attempts
- Enslaved person's message: "Amiantos slave of Qualius Caldis a clothes washer"
- Represents group almost completely left out of literary record
- Clothes washing notoriously dirty (used urine as cleaning material)
- Preserves name of enslaved person lost to history
Final Message and Universal Themes
- Satora's graffito: "On September 3rd Satora was here"
- Modern equivalent seen at train stations, restrooms
- Satora couldn't know 79 A.D. eruption would preserve her memory
- Universal human urge: Writing on walls to leave name behind in space and time "as old as time"
- Speaker's conclusion: Consider what messages we're leaving behind and what we hope will last for next generation
