AI summary by TwinMind
Apple HomePod 2 Review: I'm Confused
Marques Brownlee
10m 3s
Product Introduction & Context
- New HomePod (2nd generation) recently released - described as "most confusing new Apple product in a long time"
- Original HomePod launched 2018 at $350, later reduced to $300
- Peak market share: ~6% of smart speaker market
- Discontinued in 2021 after HomePod mini ($99) proved more successful
- Now relaunched with improvements but same fundamental issues
Physical Design Changes
- Slightly different proportions - new model more "stout"
- New "Midnight" color (black with hint of blue) vs original Space Gray
- Touch surface inset with full-circle display (vs small portion in middle)
- Removable power cable (major improvement from non-removable original)
- Redesigned base with spread-out surface area
- Still stains wooden tables - takes longer but leaves different pattern (confirmed testing)
New Features & Sensors
- Temperature sensor built-in
- Can report indoor temperature (71°F in office example)
- Enables smart home automation triggers
- Humidity sensor for smart home integration
- Sound recognition feature
- Detects smoke alarms, security alarms
- Sends phone notifications when away from home
- Thread radio for Matter hub functionality
- HomePod mini also getting same sensors via software update
Audio Hardware Changes
Original HomePod:
- 1 woofer on top
- 7 tweeters around outside
- 6 far-field microphones
New HomePod:
- Same woofer
- 5 tweeters (removed 2)
- 4 far-field microphones (removed 2)
- $50 price reduction to $300
Audio Performance
- Sounds "every bit as good" as original despite fewer components
- Crisp, balanced, non-distorted across volumes/environments
- Strong bass/sub-bass even at lower volumes
- Computational audio adjusts based on wall proximity/room shape
- Stereo pair capability for larger sound
- Dolby Atmos support for TV setup
- Can work as TV speakers (though reviewer questions practicality of $600 speakers with $300 TV)
Smart Speaker Limitations (Unchanged)
- Cannot set Spotify as default music app
- No pairing with non-iPhone/non-AirPlay devices
- No Bluetooth speaker functionality
- No audio jack
- No informational display for timers/background info
- Siri remains "very limited and pretty bad"
Market Position Analysis
- Same proposition that "flopped on its face before"
- People don't pay huge premium just for sound quality
- HomePod mini sold better due to lower price despite worse sound
- Minor improvements (removable cable, better display, $50 discount) unlikely to change market reception
Final Assessment
- Good product for: Apple ecosystem users prioritizing sound quality over smart features
- Bad product for: General smart speaker market
- Alternatives recommended: HomePod mini for Apple users, Google/Amazon options for better smart speakers
- Samsung Bixby speaker "never came out"
