AI summary by TwinMind
Are Ad Agencies, PR Firms and Lobbyists Destroying the Climate? | Solitaire Townsend | TED Countdown
TED
9m 40s
Introduction to the X Industry
- Professional services sector worth over $2 trillion annually
- Includes advertising/PR firms, management consultancies, corporate lawyers, lobbyists
- Called "X industry" where X = influence
- Makes nothing, has no stock/factories, powered by brains/spreadsheets
- Individual firms have carbon footprint no bigger than average kindergarten
- "Brainprint" felt everywhere as grease in wheel of all other businesses
X Industry's Role in Climate Destruction
- Acts as village of advisers for oil rig construction
- Financial modeling by big consultancies for oil exploration proposals
- Lobbying firms push regulatory approval (years/decades ahead of oil pumping)
- PR agencies work to get local communities onside
- Legal firms squash legal objections
- Creative agencies craft influence campaigns to sell oil industry image/products
- Oil companies outsource almost everything except drilling to publicists, consultants, lawyers, lobbyists
BP Deepwater Horizon Case Study
- 2010 disaster polluted Gulf of Mexico with 4+ million barrels of oil
- BP spent 3x more on promotional advertising year after disaster vs year before
- X industry arguably better at cleaning BP's image than BP cleaning Gulf of Mexico
Carbon Accounting and Scope X Proposal
- Current three scopes of carbon emissions:
- Scope 1 & 2: Direct emissions from fleets/factories and purchased power
- Scope 3: Indirect emissions from product use/supply chain
- UK ad industry ($20+ billion annually) has only 1.1 million tonnes carbon footprint
- X industry barely moves dial on existing scopes
- Proposes new "Scope X" to account for emissions of influence
Audi Campaign Analysis
- Purpose Disruptors network analyzed single Audi advertising campaign
- Campaign won major effectiveness award
- Generated $1.78 billion incremental revenue for Audi
- Also generated 5.1 million tonnes additional carbon for Audi
- 1:5 ratio between entire UK ad industry impact vs single campaign
Industry Transparency Initiative
- Speaker's firm produced first client disclosure report in 2015
- Simple revenue disclosure by client industries served
- 170 other ad agencies, consultancies, PR companies promised to follow
- Major consultancies/advertising agencies have not yet joined
- Industry dominated by handful of big firms
Call to Action for X Industry
- X industry hires most inventive, creative, knowledgeable, influential minds
- Same skills needed to change course of climate change
- Need talent to stop serving destruction, start serving solutions
- Questions for X industry workers:
- Selling talent to right people?
- Serving climate change causes or solutions?
- Using influence ability on clients or just their critics?
Solutions Decade Requirements
- Nearly 2 years into window to change systems toward:
- Climate justice
- Clean energy
- Circular systems
- Sustainable/equitable lifestyles
- Needs: financial modeling, legal framework, research, public support, regulatory rules, creative storytelling
- X industry could deliver these requirements
Personal Transformation
- Speaker changed job title to "Chief Solutionist"
- Constant reminder of job that needs doing
- X industry leaders either serve solutions daily or serve destruction by default
- No middle ground, no carefully worded rationales
- X industry can no longer remain neutral
- Vision: League of solutionists shifting creativity/influence toward fixing climate change
