AI summary by TwinMind
Are Humans Good or Evil? (Ben Goertzel) | AI Podcast Clips with Lex Fridman
Lex Fridman
10m 17s
Evolutionary Drivers of Human Behavior
- Human behavior driven by "unholy mix" - no single pure objective function
- Two key evolutionary forces shape humanity:
- Individual selection: selfish DNA propagation (speaker has 4 kids, likely more)
- Group/tribal selection: persistence of tribe's collective DNA
- Comparison to other species:
- Ant colonies/bee hives: heavy group selection bias
- Big cats/solitary animals: individual selection bias
- Humans: interesting balance between both forces
Good vs Evil Framework
- Good/evil concepts described as "ambiguous, complicated, somewhat silly"
- Individual selection manifests as selfishness (perceived as evil)
- Group selection manifests as altruism (perceived as good)
- Both objective functions "baked into" human brain makeup
- Exceptions exist: psychopaths/sociopaths who derive gratification from others' suffering
- Core nature: neither purely selfish nor purely altruistic - mixed
Human Value System Complexity
- Complex constellation of values specific to evolutionary history
- Examples of innate preferences:
- Love waterways and mountains
- Ideal house placement: mountain overlooking water
- Graduated care: intense for own children, less for cousins, even less for fifth cousins
- Value judgments depend on perspective
Personal Ethics Example - Ethiopia Experience
- Speaker's SingularityNet AI development office in Addis Ababa
- Witnessed people dying on roadsides from curable diseases, lack of food/medicine
- Personal response: feels terrible, gives money when present
- Back in developed world: donates some but also spends on "frivolous" enjoyment
- Self-assessment: "somewhat selfish and somewhat altruistic"
- Questions whether this makes him "evil"
Nature vs Nurture in Human Values
- Answer typically "both" plus self-organization
- Evolutionary roots provide foundation for selfishness/altruism mix
- Different cultures manifest same biology differently
- Examples of cultural variation:
- Yanomamö tribe (Venezuela): culture focused on killing other tribes
- Other Stone Age tribes: mostly peaceable, strong anti-violence taboos
- Biology sets limits but culture significantly influences expression
Marxist Philosophy Debate
- Speaker's great-grandparents were Marxists
- Marxist belief: progression capitalism → socialism → communism leads to "withering away of state"
- Theory: people become more social-minded, eliminating need for governmental structure
- Speaker's teenage skepticism: humans inherently problematic, state structure necessary
- Current evolved view: culture more significant than previously thought
Potential for Social Transformation
- Believes human society could be "dialed dramatically further toward self-awareness, other awareness, compassion and sharing"
- Material abundance helps but is subjective perception
- Stone Age cultures often perceived themselves as living in "great material abundance"
- Had food, water, beautiful environment, fulfilling sex lives, children
- Achieved abundance "without factories"
- Assessment: humanity capable of "fundamentally more positive and joy-filled mode of social existence"
- Marx "didn't quite have the right idea" - missed key aspects of human society evolution
- Current challenge: "powerful forces pushing people in different directions than positive joyous compassionate existence"
