AI summary by TwinMind
Are You an Ethical True Crime Fan? 4 Questions To Ask | Lindsey A. Sherrill | TED
TED
12m 30s
Personal Journey into True Crime
- Speaker discovered Serial podcast after initial release, became obsessed with exploding True Crime world
- Wrote dissertation, articles, book on topic after countless hours consuming True Crime content
- Research attempt to quantify True Crime podcasts: identified nearly 5,000 as of April 2022 (number keeps growing)
Historical Context of True Crime Media
- Public obsession with True Crime not new phenomenon
- Scholars credit Truman Capote's 1966 "In Cold Blood" as birth of True Crime media
- Earlier examples pre-date Capote by decades:
- Transatlantic Terror from Jack the Ripper and H.H. Holmes (1880s-90s)
- Elizabeth Short's 1947 murder inspired lurid media frenzy (Black Dahlia lore)
- Public executions in Middle Ages, Witch Trials, Inquisition as early True Crime entertainment
- Common thread: spectators fascinated/horrified by intersections of good/evil, justice/injustice
Evolution of True Crime Purpose
- Initial focus on entertainment
- New pattern emerging: creators focused on Criminal Justice Reform, wrongful convictions, bringing attention to long cold unsolved cases
- Speaker found this development "elating," changed entire research stream to focus on this type of True Crime entertainment
Criticism and Ethical Concerns
- Common questions from people outside True Crime fandom:
- "Is this okay?"
- "Doesn't this feel icky?"
- "Are they laughing about murders?"
- Speaker's initial response: point toward "good stuff" (creators solving cases, finding leads, drawing attention to injustices)
- Acknowledgment of "ugly side" of True Crime being "really really ugly"
Research Methodology
- 2018: began interviewing storytellers, journalists, advocates involved in True Crime storytelling
- Asked participants to define True Crime and discuss its reputation
- Participants described negative aspects: exploitative, salacious, print, murder porn
- Like traditional pornography quote: couldn't define bad True Crime but "knew it when they saw it"
Four Questions for Ethical Consumption
Question 1: Why Am I Interested in This?
- No right answer to this question
- Multiple studies show True Crime fans (particularly women) drawn to sense of community
- Many survivors/victims of assault, harassment, murder find healing in others' stories
- Can feel empowered to fight back, feel less alone
- Problematic motivations: driven solely by horror, titillation, morbid curiosity
- Natural/valid feelings, but if only reason for interest, time to find something new
Question 2: How Does This Make Me Feel?
- True Crime rarely feel-good story, yet fans still seek content
- Excitement/motivation in learning new topics
- Eudaimonic motivation (beyond pleasure/hedonic motivation)
- Speaker's example: finishing victim's story not because well-told/interesting, but felt owed attention to tragedy
- Especially important for victims less likely to receive mainstream press coverage (black men, indigenous girls)
- Hedonic motivations (exciting, thrilling, well-produced, fascinating characters) not inherently problematic
- Problem when that's only reason for interest
Question 3: How Might People Involved Feel?
- Complicated question using Serial case example
- Adnan Syed advocates (believing wrongful conviction) produced books, documentaries, hours of podcasts
- Framed arguments as searching justice for Adnan and Hae Min Lee
- Hae's family famously absent from narratives, issued statements about deep wounds story remediation opens
- Doesn't make telling story inherently unethical
- True Crime storytelling like traditional journalism: delves into painful subjects, private citizens' lives become public, wounds reopened
- Elizabeth Yardley's ethics of crime storytelling
- Hae Min Lee's brother's Reddit post criticism: "to us it's real life"
- "To you it's another murder mystery, crime drama, episode of CSI"
- "You weren't there to see your mom crying every night"
- "Shame on you, hope what happens to us never happens to you and you have to have your story blasted to 5 million listeners"
- Key questions: Are people in story being hurt? Is there justifiable reason to inflict harm? Can good come from retelling?
Question 4: Am I Motivated to Act?
- Speaker's favorites ("really good stuff"): In the Dark, Truth and Justice, Undisclosed podcast
- Leave listeners with mission: donate, contact Congress member, work in communities for healing
- Questionable True Crime leaves feeling helpless/afraid
- Focuses too much on horrors/injustices, not enough on healing/solutions
- Difference between creators:
- Playing 911 call to horrify audience with anguish/screams
- Playing call hoping someone hears clue (passing truck, rushing water) to help find missing victim
- Ethical creators draw lines around motivations
- Remind listeners: looking through court transcripts helpful, harassing victims' family members/suspects online is not
Call to Action
- Four questions alone cannot create less exploitative, more ethical True Crime world
- Individual consumption has impacts
- Hope: directing attention to people doing good stuff
- Turn time, dollars, resources toward ethical creators
- Use fan status as "murderinos" to amplify potential for good in True Crime obsession
