AI summary by TwinMind

Are You an Ethical True Crime Fan? 4 Questions To Ask | Lindsey A. Sherrill | TED

TED

12m 30s

Personal Journey into True Crime

  • Speaker discovered Serial podcast after initial release, became obsessed with exploding True Crime world
  • Wrote dissertation, articles, book on topic after countless hours consuming True Crime content
  • Research attempt to quantify True Crime podcasts: identified nearly 5,000 as of April 2022 (number keeps growing)

Historical Context of True Crime Media

  • Public obsession with True Crime not new phenomenon
  • Scholars credit Truman Capote's 1966 "In Cold Blood" as birth of True Crime media
  • Earlier examples pre-date Capote by decades:
    • Transatlantic Terror from Jack the Ripper and H.H. Holmes (1880s-90s)
    • Elizabeth Short's 1947 murder inspired lurid media frenzy (Black Dahlia lore)
    • Public executions in Middle Ages, Witch Trials, Inquisition as early True Crime entertainment
  • Common thread: spectators fascinated/horrified by intersections of good/evil, justice/injustice

Evolution of True Crime Purpose

  • Initial focus on entertainment
  • New pattern emerging: creators focused on Criminal Justice Reform, wrongful convictions, bringing attention to long cold unsolved cases
  • Speaker found this development "elating," changed entire research stream to focus on this type of True Crime entertainment

Criticism and Ethical Concerns

  • Common questions from people outside True Crime fandom:
    • "Is this okay?"
    • "Doesn't this feel icky?"
    • "Are they laughing about murders?"
  • Speaker's initial response: point toward "good stuff" (creators solving cases, finding leads, drawing attention to injustices)
  • Acknowledgment of "ugly side" of True Crime being "really really ugly"

Research Methodology

  • 2018: began interviewing storytellers, journalists, advocates involved in True Crime storytelling
  • Asked participants to define True Crime and discuss its reputation
  • Participants described negative aspects: exploitative, salacious, print, murder porn
  • Like traditional pornography quote: couldn't define bad True Crime but "knew it when they saw it"

Four Questions for Ethical Consumption

Question 1: Why Am I Interested in This?

  • No right answer to this question
  • Multiple studies show True Crime fans (particularly women) drawn to sense of community
  • Many survivors/victims of assault, harassment, murder find healing in others' stories
  • Can feel empowered to fight back, feel less alone
  • Problematic motivations: driven solely by horror, titillation, morbid curiosity
  • Natural/valid feelings, but if only reason for interest, time to find something new

Question 2: How Does This Make Me Feel?

  • True Crime rarely feel-good story, yet fans still seek content
  • Excitement/motivation in learning new topics
  • Eudaimonic motivation (beyond pleasure/hedonic motivation)
  • Speaker's example: finishing victim's story not because well-told/interesting, but felt owed attention to tragedy
  • Especially important for victims less likely to receive mainstream press coverage (black men, indigenous girls)
  • Hedonic motivations (exciting, thrilling, well-produced, fascinating characters) not inherently problematic
  • Problem when that's only reason for interest

Question 3: How Might People Involved Feel?

  • Complicated question using Serial case example
  • Adnan Syed advocates (believing wrongful conviction) produced books, documentaries, hours of podcasts
  • Framed arguments as searching justice for Adnan and Hae Min Lee
  • Hae's family famously absent from narratives, issued statements about deep wounds story remediation opens
  • Doesn't make telling story inherently unethical
  • True Crime storytelling like traditional journalism: delves into painful subjects, private citizens' lives become public, wounds reopened
  • Elizabeth Yardley's ethics of crime storytelling
  • Hae Min Lee's brother's Reddit post criticism: "to us it's real life"
    • "To you it's another murder mystery, crime drama, episode of CSI"
    • "You weren't there to see your mom crying every night"
    • "Shame on you, hope what happens to us never happens to you and you have to have your story blasted to 5 million listeners"
  • Key questions: Are people in story being hurt? Is there justifiable reason to inflict harm? Can good come from retelling?

Question 4: Am I Motivated to Act?

  • Speaker's favorites ("really good stuff"): In the Dark, Truth and Justice, Undisclosed podcast
  • Leave listeners with mission: donate, contact Congress member, work in communities for healing
  • Questionable True Crime leaves feeling helpless/afraid
  • Focuses too much on horrors/injustices, not enough on healing/solutions
  • Difference between creators:
    • Playing 911 call to horrify audience with anguish/screams
    • Playing call hoping someone hears clue (passing truck, rushing water) to help find missing victim
  • Ethical creators draw lines around motivations
  • Remind listeners: looking through court transcripts helpful, harassing victims' family members/suspects online is not

Call to Action

  • Four questions alone cannot create less exploitative, more ethical True Crime world
  • Individual consumption has impacts
  • Hope: directing attention to people doing good stuff
  • Turn time, dollars, resources toward ethical creators
  • Use fan status as "murderinos" to amplify potential for good in True Crime obsession

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome