AI summary by TwinMind

Banned Weapons Too Brutal for Modern Warfare

The Infographics Show

15m 55s

Introduction to CCW

  • UN Convention on Prohibitions/Restrictions on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW)
  • Restricts weapons deemed excessively injurious or having indiscriminate effects
  • Using banned weapons constitutes war crimes
  • Five protocols categorize banned weapons

Protocol 1: Non-Detectable Fragments

  • Bans explosives/ammunition with fragments undetectable by magnets/x-rays
  • Frag grenades legal - metal fragments detectable for surgical removal
  • Plastic/glass fragments equally deadly but impossible to detect/remove
  • Principle: weapons should kill, not maim/mutilate survivors
  • Frangible bullets banned
    • Designed to disintegrate on impact into countless tiny projectiles
    • Inflict significantly more tissue damage than non-deformable bullets
    • No military advantage but cause excessive wounding/unnecessary suffering
    • RIP (Radically Invasive Projectile) ammunition example
  • Legal for domestic use in most countries including US

Protocol 2: Mines, Booby Traps, Other Devices

  • Landmines regulated, not banned outright
    • Countries must deactivate/collect mines after conflict ends
    • Reduce civilian casualties during peacetime
    • Anti-personnel mines must kill, not wound/disfigure
  • Booby trap prohibitions (implying all have been used):
    • Cannot attach to internationally recognized protective emblems (Red Cross)
    • Cannot attach to sick/wounded/dead people
    • Cannot booby trap burial/grave/cremation sites
    • Cannot booby trap medical facilities/equipment/supplies/transportation
    • Cannot booby trap children's toys/objects for feeding/health/hygiene/clothing/education
    • Cannot booby trap food/drink/kitchen utensils (except military establishments)
    • Cannot booby trap religious objects/historic monuments/works of art/places of worship
    • Cannot booby trap animals/carcasses

Protocol 3: Incendiary Weapons

  • Prohibits/restricts fire/heat-based weapons
  • Historical progression: fire arrows → Greek Fire → M2 flamethrower → Napalm (Vietnam)
  • Problems with incendiary weapons:
    • Horrible death by burning
    • Survivors live with horrific burns/pain/psychological stress
    • Fire spreads indiscriminately between soldiers/civilians
    • Scorched Earth policy against civilians banned by Geneva Convention 1977
  • Illegal to use against civilian populations/areas/objects
  • Cannot air-deliver against military targets in concentrated civilian areas
  • Thermobaric/vacuum bombs regulatory blind spot
    • Contain large amounts of incendiary fuel
    • Create fiery explosion sucking oxygen from air
    • Cause obliteration while suffocating
    • Not regulated under CCW

Protocol 4: Blinding Laser Weapons

  • Prohibits laser weapons specifically designed to cause permanent blindness
  • Cannot target unenhanced vision (naked eye or corrective eyesight devices)
  • Doesn't prohibit use against optical equipment (binoculars, periscopes, telescopes)
  • Cannot penalize accidental blinding
  • Personnel Halting and Stimulation Response rifle (PHASER) example
    • Designed for temporary blindness
    • Can become permanent if power cranked up or mishandled

Protocol 5: Explosive Remnants of War

  • Addresses unexploded ordnance danger post-conflict
  • Cluster bombs major concern
    • Invented during WWII
    • Contains smaller bombs (submunitions)
    • Fall indiscriminately over target area
    • Carpet vast areas with deadly fire
    • Equally likely to massacre civilians as troops
    • Not all submunitions explode immediately
    • Undetonated ones remain embedded, risk exploding/injuring civilians

Other Banned Weapons Beyond CCW

  • Poisoned bullets
    • First invented by Leonardo da Vinci (sulfur and arsenic ballistic shells)
    • Banned by Strasbourg Agreement 1675 (Rome and France)
    • US experimented with ricin-laced bullets in WWI
  • Chemical weapons under Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC)
    • Nerve agent Novichok
    • Poison ricin
    • Sarin gas (Syria sanctioned for using on own people during Syrian Civil War despite signing CWC 2013)
  • Biological weapons under 1972 Biological Weapons Convention
    • Historical use: Mongols used corpses to spread disease
    • Middle Ages: catapulted dead animal corpses into fortresses
    • Europeans used smallpox-infected blankets against Native Americans
    • Vietnam: Viet Cong coated punji sticks with human feces
  • Dirty bombs
    • Conventional bomb laced with nuclear material
    • Distribution system for radiation
    • Sicken/kill indiscriminately over wide area
    • Potentially irradiate area for decades/centuries/millennia
    • Easier to make than standard nuclear weapon
    • Major terrorist concern

Future Protocol 6: Lethal Autonomous Weapons

  • Potential future protocol for "Skynet-style killer robots"
  • UN expecting weapons companies to invest in autonomous weapon systems
  • Hoping to get ahead of curve before atrocities occur

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome