AI summary by TwinMind
Banned Weapons Too Brutal for Modern Warfare
The Infographics Show
15m 55s
Introduction to CCW
- UN Convention on Prohibitions/Restrictions on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW)
- Restricts weapons deemed excessively injurious or having indiscriminate effects
- Using banned weapons constitutes war crimes
- Five protocols categorize banned weapons
Protocol 1: Non-Detectable Fragments
- Bans explosives/ammunition with fragments undetectable by magnets/x-rays
- Frag grenades legal - metal fragments detectable for surgical removal
- Plastic/glass fragments equally deadly but impossible to detect/remove
- Principle: weapons should kill, not maim/mutilate survivors
- Frangible bullets banned
- Designed to disintegrate on impact into countless tiny projectiles
- Inflict significantly more tissue damage than non-deformable bullets
- No military advantage but cause excessive wounding/unnecessary suffering
- RIP (Radically Invasive Projectile) ammunition example
- Legal for domestic use in most countries including US
Protocol 2: Mines, Booby Traps, Other Devices
- Landmines regulated, not banned outright
- Countries must deactivate/collect mines after conflict ends
- Reduce civilian casualties during peacetime
- Anti-personnel mines must kill, not wound/disfigure
- Booby trap prohibitions (implying all have been used):
- Cannot attach to internationally recognized protective emblems (Red Cross)
- Cannot attach to sick/wounded/dead people
- Cannot booby trap burial/grave/cremation sites
- Cannot booby trap medical facilities/equipment/supplies/transportation
- Cannot booby trap children's toys/objects for feeding/health/hygiene/clothing/education
- Cannot booby trap food/drink/kitchen utensils (except military establishments)
- Cannot booby trap religious objects/historic monuments/works of art/places of worship
- Cannot booby trap animals/carcasses
Protocol 3: Incendiary Weapons
- Prohibits/restricts fire/heat-based weapons
- Historical progression: fire arrows → Greek Fire → M2 flamethrower → Napalm (Vietnam)
- Problems with incendiary weapons:
- Horrible death by burning
- Survivors live with horrific burns/pain/psychological stress
- Fire spreads indiscriminately between soldiers/civilians
- Scorched Earth policy against civilians banned by Geneva Convention 1977
- Illegal to use against civilian populations/areas/objects
- Cannot air-deliver against military targets in concentrated civilian areas
- Thermobaric/vacuum bombs regulatory blind spot
- Contain large amounts of incendiary fuel
- Create fiery explosion sucking oxygen from air
- Cause obliteration while suffocating
- Not regulated under CCW
Protocol 4: Blinding Laser Weapons
- Prohibits laser weapons specifically designed to cause permanent blindness
- Cannot target unenhanced vision (naked eye or corrective eyesight devices)
- Doesn't prohibit use against optical equipment (binoculars, periscopes, telescopes)
- Cannot penalize accidental blinding
- Personnel Halting and Stimulation Response rifle (PHASER) example
- Designed for temporary blindness
- Can become permanent if power cranked up or mishandled
Protocol 5: Explosive Remnants of War
- Addresses unexploded ordnance danger post-conflict
- Cluster bombs major concern
- Invented during WWII
- Contains smaller bombs (submunitions)
- Fall indiscriminately over target area
- Carpet vast areas with deadly fire
- Equally likely to massacre civilians as troops
- Not all submunitions explode immediately
- Undetonated ones remain embedded, risk exploding/injuring civilians
Other Banned Weapons Beyond CCW
- Poisoned bullets
- First invented by Leonardo da Vinci (sulfur and arsenic ballistic shells)
- Banned by Strasbourg Agreement 1675 (Rome and France)
- US experimented with ricin-laced bullets in WWI
- Chemical weapons under Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC)
- Nerve agent Novichok
- Poison ricin
- Sarin gas (Syria sanctioned for using on own people during Syrian Civil War despite signing CWC 2013)
- Biological weapons under 1972 Biological Weapons Convention
- Historical use: Mongols used corpses to spread disease
- Middle Ages: catapulted dead animal corpses into fortresses
- Europeans used smallpox-infected blankets against Native Americans
- Vietnam: Viet Cong coated punji sticks with human feces
- Dirty bombs
- Conventional bomb laced with nuclear material
- Distribution system for radiation
- Sicken/kill indiscriminately over wide area
- Potentially irradiate area for decades/centuries/millennia
- Easier to make than standard nuclear weapon
- Major terrorist concern
Future Protocol 6: Lethal Autonomous Weapons
- Potential future protocol for "Skynet-style killer robots"
- UN expecting weapons companies to invest in autonomous weapon systems
- Hoping to get ahead of curve before atrocities occur
