AI summary by TwinMind

Barry Nalebuff | Split The Pie: A Radical New Way to Negotiate | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

59m 59s

Introduction and Background

  • Hal Varian (Google Chief Economist) introduces Barry Nalebuff (Milton Steinbach Professor at Yale School of Management)
  • Nalebuff teaches negotiation, innovation strategy, game theory
  • Author of "Thinking Strategically," "The Art of Strategy," and new book "Split the Pie"
  • Co-founded Honest Tea company, wrote "Mission in a Bottle" (graphic novel)
  • Varian and Nalebuff first co-authored paper in 1981 on risk sharing in non-classical environments
  • Nalebuff's books sold 500,000 copies with Norton publisher introduction from Varian

Core Negotiation Theory - The Pie Concept

  • Traditional view: Alice gets 4 slices, Bob gets 2 slices without agreement from 12-slice pizza
    • World sees Alice as twice as strong, should get 8 slices vs Bob's 4
    • Fair view: split 12 slices equally at 6-6
  • Economist view: Focus on incremental value created
    • Without agreement: Alice + Bob = 4 + 2 = 6 total slices
    • With agreement: 12 slices total
    • Negotiation is about dividing the 6 incremental slices (12-6)
    • Equal power means 3-3 split of incremental value
    • Final result: Alice gets 4+3=7, Bob gets 2+3=5

Domain Name Troll Case Study

  • Nalebuff's friend (actually himself) filed trademark application without lawyer
  • Troll named Edward bought associated URL same day application became public
  • Edward demanded $2,500 for domain
  • Friend discovered ICANN dispute resolution process costs $1,300, virtually guaranteed success
  • Edward has history of losing every ICANN case
  • Friend countered: would rather pay ICANN $1,300, Edward gets zero
  • Edward reduced to $1,100

Pie Analysis of Domain Negotiation

  • Friend values domain at $10,000-$20,000, Edward has zero use for it
  • Negotiation not about who gets domain (friend gets it either way)
  • Real negotiation: whether to save $1,300 ICANN fee
  • Pie = $1,300 savings to split
  • Edward's proposal: $1,100 for Edward, $200 savings for friend
  • Friend's counter: $650-$650 split
  • Edward's "compromise": $900 (claiming came down from $2,500)
  • Friend's analysis: Edward only really moved from $1,100 to $900, friend moved from $0 to $650
  • Friend didn't respond; Edward risked losing $900 vs friend's $400 risk
  • Edward accepted $650 after one week

Key Negotiation Principles

  • Principle beats arbitrary - having logical framework provides advantage
  • Don't anchor at extreme positions - creates need for large movements showing no principle
  • Revealing BATNA (Best Alternative to Negotiated Agreement) can be strategic
  • Focus on creating value rather than just splitting existing value
  • Logic-based approach appeals to rational negotiators

Multi-Party Negotiations and Standards

  • More complex with 3+ parties due to unclear no-deal scenarios
  • Example: Recent tech industry standardization deal for home device interoperability
  • Google, Amazon, others agreed on standards allowing cross-device communication
  • Larger firms act as bellwethers for smaller parties to join

Honest Tea and Coca-Cola Negotiations

  • Honest Tea buying bottles at 19 cents, Coke could get same for 11 cents
  • 8 cents savings × 100 million bottles = $8 million potential savings
  • Proportional split by revenue (Coke $40B, Honest Tea $20M = 2000:1 ratio) would give Coke $7,996,000, Honest Tea $4,000
  • Nalebuff argued for 50-50 split: both parties essential for deal
  • Coke's purchasing power needs Honest Tea's customers to create value

Coca-Cola Acquisition Structure

  • Honest Tea too small at $23M sales for Coke's system
  • Agreed to 3-year partnership before acquisition
  • Coke would help with purchasing (11-cent bottles), distribution, production
  • Problem: Coke didn't want to pay more due to their help increasing company value
  • Solution: Agreed on baseline sales projection X
    • Coke pays full price for sales up to X
    • Coke pays half price for sales above X (sharing incremental value)
  • Turned negotiation into data exploration exercise about market multiples
  • Coke had data on all 27 beverage industry acquisitions over previous decade

Publishing and Royalty Negotiations

  • Standard publisher royalty: 15%
  • Nalebuff proposed 30% royalty in exchange for covering $75,000 in publisher costs
  • Co-author Avinash Dixit (never sold more than 1,200 copies previously) declined
  • Book sold 500,000 copies - mistake cost Nalebuff over $1 million
  • Michael Lewis now negotiates 50-50 splits with publishers
  • New book "Split the Pie" uses improved royalty structure

Practical Applications and Advice

  • Target audience: Anyone who negotiates (everyone)
  • Students at Yale become empathetic until they start negotiating, then act like jerks
  • Teaches to law firms, M&A lawyers, business schools
  • Example: Student lawyer used pie theory to split $15M tax savings 50-50 in acquisition deal

Non-Monetary Negotiations

  • Restaurant choice example: Give other side what they want, get compensation elsewhere
  • Beets vs broccoli: Don't split evenly if preferences differ - give each person what they prefer most
  • Answer questions to help other side understand your needs
  • Reciprocity important but also strategic - they need to know what you want

Threat Points and Alternatives

  • Coca-Cola approach: "You're our #1 choice, but we have mandate to buy a tea company"
  • Contrast with tea bag company threat: "We'll crush you like tea leaves"
  • Present alternatives nicely rather than as threats
  • Reputation effects matter in repeated negotiations

Professional Help and Recommendations

  • Recommends using professionals for high-stakes negotiations
  • Prefers lawyers over investment bankers as counselors
  • Establish relationship with lawyer before needing them
  • Objective third parties can be more effective than self-negotiation

Book Format and Teaching Methods

  • "Mission in a Bottle" written as graphic novel for unique approach
  • Every word counts in comic format - forces conciseness
  • Led to animation work and Coursera course development
  • Meets audience where they are (generation raised on graphic presentations)

Advanced Concepts

  • Irrational behavior strategy (Nixon-Kissinger example) problematic when discussed openly
  • Partial information disclosure strategies
  • Practice through case studies and simulations
  • Focus on creating bigger pies rather than just splitting existing ones

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome