AI summary by TwinMind
Barry Nalebuff | Split The Pie: A Radical New Way to Negotiate | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
59m 59s
Introduction and Background
- Hal Varian (Google Chief Economist) introduces Barry Nalebuff (Milton Steinbach Professor at Yale School of Management)
- Nalebuff teaches negotiation, innovation strategy, game theory
- Author of "Thinking Strategically," "The Art of Strategy," and new book "Split the Pie"
- Co-founded Honest Tea company, wrote "Mission in a Bottle" (graphic novel)
- Varian and Nalebuff first co-authored paper in 1981 on risk sharing in non-classical environments
- Nalebuff's books sold 500,000 copies with Norton publisher introduction from Varian
Core Negotiation Theory - The Pie Concept
- Traditional view: Alice gets 4 slices, Bob gets 2 slices without agreement from 12-slice pizza
- World sees Alice as twice as strong, should get 8 slices vs Bob's 4
- Fair view: split 12 slices equally at 6-6
- Economist view: Focus on incremental value created
- Without agreement: Alice + Bob = 4 + 2 = 6 total slices
- With agreement: 12 slices total
- Negotiation is about dividing the 6 incremental slices (12-6)
- Equal power means 3-3 split of incremental value
- Final result: Alice gets 4+3=7, Bob gets 2+3=5
Domain Name Troll Case Study
- Nalebuff's friend (actually himself) filed trademark application without lawyer
- Troll named Edward bought associated URL same day application became public
- Edward demanded $2,500 for domain
- Friend discovered ICANN dispute resolution process costs $1,300, virtually guaranteed success
- Edward has history of losing every ICANN case
- Friend countered: would rather pay ICANN $1,300, Edward gets zero
- Edward reduced to $1,100
Pie Analysis of Domain Negotiation
- Friend values domain at $10,000-$20,000, Edward has zero use for it
- Negotiation not about who gets domain (friend gets it either way)
- Real negotiation: whether to save $1,300 ICANN fee
- Pie = $1,300 savings to split
- Edward's proposal: $1,100 for Edward, $200 savings for friend
- Friend's counter: $650-$650 split
- Edward's "compromise": $900 (claiming came down from $2,500)
- Friend's analysis: Edward only really moved from $1,100 to $900, friend moved from $0 to $650
- Friend didn't respond; Edward risked losing $900 vs friend's $400 risk
- Edward accepted $650 after one week
Key Negotiation Principles
- Principle beats arbitrary - having logical framework provides advantage
- Don't anchor at extreme positions - creates need for large movements showing no principle
- Revealing BATNA (Best Alternative to Negotiated Agreement) can be strategic
- Focus on creating value rather than just splitting existing value
- Logic-based approach appeals to rational negotiators
Multi-Party Negotiations and Standards
- More complex with 3+ parties due to unclear no-deal scenarios
- Example: Recent tech industry standardization deal for home device interoperability
- Google, Amazon, others agreed on standards allowing cross-device communication
- Larger firms act as bellwethers for smaller parties to join
Honest Tea and Coca-Cola Negotiations
- Honest Tea buying bottles at 19 cents, Coke could get same for 11 cents
- 8 cents savings × 100 million bottles = $8 million potential savings
- Proportional split by revenue (Coke $40B, Honest Tea $20M = 2000:1 ratio) would give Coke $7,996,000, Honest Tea $4,000
- Nalebuff argued for 50-50 split: both parties essential for deal
- Coke's purchasing power needs Honest Tea's customers to create value
Coca-Cola Acquisition Structure
- Honest Tea too small at $23M sales for Coke's system
- Agreed to 3-year partnership before acquisition
- Coke would help with purchasing (11-cent bottles), distribution, production
- Problem: Coke didn't want to pay more due to their help increasing company value
- Solution: Agreed on baseline sales projection X
- Coke pays full price for sales up to X
- Coke pays half price for sales above X (sharing incremental value)
- Turned negotiation into data exploration exercise about market multiples
- Coke had data on all 27 beverage industry acquisitions over previous decade
Publishing and Royalty Negotiations
- Standard publisher royalty: 15%
- Nalebuff proposed 30% royalty in exchange for covering $75,000 in publisher costs
- Co-author Avinash Dixit (never sold more than 1,200 copies previously) declined
- Book sold 500,000 copies - mistake cost Nalebuff over $1 million
- Michael Lewis now negotiates 50-50 splits with publishers
- New book "Split the Pie" uses improved royalty structure
Practical Applications and Advice
- Target audience: Anyone who negotiates (everyone)
- Students at Yale become empathetic until they start negotiating, then act like jerks
- Teaches to law firms, M&A lawyers, business schools
- Example: Student lawyer used pie theory to split $15M tax savings 50-50 in acquisition deal
Non-Monetary Negotiations
- Restaurant choice example: Give other side what they want, get compensation elsewhere
- Beets vs broccoli: Don't split evenly if preferences differ - give each person what they prefer most
- Answer questions to help other side understand your needs
- Reciprocity important but also strategic - they need to know what you want
Threat Points and Alternatives
- Coca-Cola approach: "You're our #1 choice, but we have mandate to buy a tea company"
- Contrast with tea bag company threat: "We'll crush you like tea leaves"
- Present alternatives nicely rather than as threats
- Reputation effects matter in repeated negotiations
Professional Help and Recommendations
- Recommends using professionals for high-stakes negotiations
- Prefers lawyers over investment bankers as counselors
- Establish relationship with lawyer before needing them
- Objective third parties can be more effective than self-negotiation
Book Format and Teaching Methods
- "Mission in a Bottle" written as graphic novel for unique approach
- Every word counts in comic format - forces conciseness
- Led to animation work and Coursera course development
- Meets audience where they are (generation raised on graphic presentations)
Advanced Concepts
- Irrational behavior strategy (Nixon-Kissinger example) problematic when discussed openly
- Partial information disclosure strategies
- Practice through case studies and simulations
- Focus on creating bigger pies rather than just splitting existing ones
