AI summary by TwinMind
Before the One Child Policy
Asianometry
12m 9s
General Narrative vs Reality
- Common narrative: China's birth rate high/out of control until 1979 one child policy announcement
- Policy attributed to Deng Xiaoping after Mao's death (1976)
- Mao supposedly encouraged reproduction
- Reality: Chinese Communist Party interested in birth/population policy from when assumed power
- Narrative characterized as simplification
Mao's Contradictory Statements on Population
- 1949 response to US Secretary Dean Anderson's overpopulation criticism:
- "Very good thing China has big population"
- "Even if population multiplies many times, fully capable of finding solution"
- "Solution is production"
- Refuted Malthusian theory
- Statement taken out of context - more communist response to Western criticism than policy declaration
- 1957 addressed 8th Central Committee CCP:
- "Birth control still necessary, not for encouraging more births"
- "Too late to wait until population reaches 800 million"
- "Need birth planning"
- 1958: Launched Great Leap Forward, set population control aside
- Caused famine killing millions
- After ended, fertility rebounded - birth rate soared to 6-7.5 total fertility rate
Mao's Later Population Control Focus
- 1960: Told General Montgomery "working to control population growth"
- 1965: Told health minister "include birth control in rural health programs"
- Implementation of stricter policies while still in charge
"Later, Longer, Fewer" Policy (1971)
- Marked shift in government mood toward population control
- Debuted in Shanghai:
- Later: women marry later in life
- Longer: couples wait longer between children (at least 4 years)
- Fewer: less children (2 urban families, 3 rural families)
- Previously voluntary policies became mandatory
- State Birth Planning Commission extended authority to villages/neighborhoods
- Kept records on women's births
- Gave factories quotas on allowed births
- Harassment for unauthorized pregnancy/abortion pressure
- Sterilization/IUD insertion after quota hit
1970s Population Control Results
- Abortions/IUD insertions skyrocketed throughout 1970s
- 1971-1973:
- IUDs doubled to 13 million
- Induced abortions up to 5.9 million
- Female sterilizations up over 70%
- Total fertility collapsed from 5.8 to 2.7 by 1978
- Unusual for poor agrarian society
- China's economy stagnant through 1970s (Cultural Revolution impact)
- Decline likely due to coercive policy, not economic growth/women's education
One Child Policy Launch Context
- Deng Xiaoping ascended after Mao's death (1976)
- Consistent supporter of population control throughout career
- Government moved toward economic reform/opening up
- 1979: Deng told Japanese PM Ohira Masayoshi intended to quadruple GDP per capita by century end
- China approaching 1 billion person mark
- Party saw population size as impediment to economic goals
- Less children = more concentrated wealth, fewer kids to make rich
Policy Development and Implementation
- Historical records unclear who first proposed one child numerical goal
- Chen Muhua (head National Family Commission) likely biggest advocate
- Strong support from Deng and Hua Guofeng
- Government encouraging one child limit in 1978, full policy 1979
- Song Jian (aerospace engineer) promoted neo-Malthusian theories post-announcement
- Attended 7th World Congress International Federation Automatic Control (Helsinki)
- Brought population control theories back to China
- Presented data: China's ideal population ~700 million (2/3 of contemporary 1 billion)
- Gained acceptance from high-level cadres including Chen Yun
- Convinced party one child policy only way to avert Malthusian disaster
International Context
- China's policy one of many population control policies worldwide
- India, Bangladesh, Indonesia had their own
- India's particularly vicious
- China's coercive birth control went further than all
Policy Statistics and Effectiveness
- 1983: China performed 14.4 million abortions, 20.7 million sterilizations, 17.8 million IUD insertions
- 1979-1995: decline from 2.8 to 1.8 fertility rate
- 1970s more successful suppressing births than 1980s when policy actually in effect
- Long-term effect relatively small:
- Much reproductive decline already absorbed decade earlier
- Implementation spotty for nearly 30 of 36 years policy existed
- Half of all parents allowed second child from 1979
- China's current birth rates align with Confucian North Asian neighbors (Taiwan, Hong Kong, South Korea, Singapore)
- All achieved same place without one child policy
- Policy hardly mattered in grand scheme of country's development
