AI summary by TwinMind
Blocking People in Real Life: Tom Scott at An Evening of Unnecessary Detail
Tom Scott
8m 47s
Opening Anecdote and Motivation
- Speaker (Tom Scott) shares harsh message sent in past: "I've blocked you everywhere else and now I'm going to block you here too, my only regret is that I can't block you in real life"
- Problem: couldn't block person in real life due to shared social circles, events, awkward encounters
- Proposes using technology to solve this social problem
Current Technology Limitations
- Science fiction blocking (Black Mirror reference) uses messy pixel fuzz
- Problem: blocked person can still see you, you can still see them, physical interaction still possible
- Not practical solution
Content Aware Fill as Foundation
- Photoshop's content aware fill algorithm already exists
- Demonstrates photo editing where speaker was removed from original photograph
- Shows how seamless object removal creates undetectable edits
- Facebook already has facial recognition technology
- Current attempts at person removal can look "Cronenberg-esque"
Brain-Computer Interface Development
- Deep brain stimulation used for Parkinson's patients since 2006
- People already controlling robot arms with brain implants
- Exoskeletons controlled with EEG caps
- Elon Musk working on neural lace (referencing Iain M. Banks)
- Prediction: deeper brain connections will develop over next few decades
Virtual vs Augmented Reality Prediction
- Humanity won't regress into virtual worlds
- Virtual worlds good for gimmicky games but lack real human interaction
- Uncanny Valley mostly solved for visual effects (Johnny Depp in Pirates movie example)
- Same uncanny valley effect exists for human conversation simulation
- Unethical to simulate humans even if possible
Vision Center Hijacking Concept
- Could hijack brain's vision center using evolutionary tricks
- Brain already uses these tricks (walking around obstacles without conscious notice)
- Could tell vision center to remove or add objects
- Teleportation concept: paint remote office vision, paint yourself into others' vision there
Gradual Implementation Rollout
- Initial use on annoyances: crying babies on planes, jerks at bus stops
- Eventually expand to full person blocking
- Mutual blocking: neither person appears in other's perceptions
- People without implants increasingly marginalized (like landline vs Twitter customer service)
Workaround Attempts
- People will try to circumvent blocking (expensive skywriting photo example)
- Generally people would accept this technology
Facebook Unfriending Analogy
- No one can remember last person who unfriended them on Facebook
- Can't remember all friends, don't check daily, no notifications
- Not particularly offensive when happens - people just disappear
- Technology will improve incrementally
Advanced Blocking Capabilities
- Block objects, concepts, ideas
- Automatically detect what brain flinches from
- Automatic blocking of uncomfortable topics
- Shared block lists among friend groups
- Social pressure to conform to group blocking norms
- Awkwardness of being only one who sees/discusses blocked topics
Societal Scale Implementation
- Shops, homes, offices, entire cities could be erased
- Crowds sliding past each other on streets
- Unknown mutual consensus removing each other
- Reference to China Miéville's "The City and the City"
- Difference: no tradition, etiquette, or violent retribution needed
Geopolitical Applications
- Feuding nations could block each other instead of war
- Citizens' implants legally mandated to edit out other countries
- Children kept unaware of other world's existence until adulthood
- Other world becomes rumor, ghost stories, bumps in the night
- At 18/21, brief look at other world confirms it's "terrible"
Extreme Isolation Scenarios
- People who block everyone
- Speaker could be looking at full house but not know if eyes gliding over people from another world
- Possibility of someone else on stage that speaker walks around unconsciously
- Implant determines what speaker can perceive
Final Philosophical Question
- What happens when you edit idea of implants from people who have implants?
- People who hate the idea but were fitted from birth or required for work
- Hate that what enters through eyes into brain isn't reality
- Parallel to audience dismissing this talk as science fiction
- Closing instruction: "ignore that itch behind your ear, it's probably nothing"
