AI summary by TwinMind
Border Disputes: China, Korea and Gando
Asianometry
7m 16s
2004 Korean Legislative Challenge
- September 2004: South Korean lawmakers submitted bill calling for nullification of 95-year-old treaty between China and Japan
- Bill targeted 1909 Sino-Japanese Agreement (Gondo Convention)
- Bill went nowhere but served as significant salvo in China-Korea history wars
- Chinese Communist Party took notice of this challenge
The 1909 Gondo Convention Background
- Treaty concerned land now comprising China's Yanbian Korean Autonomous Prefecture
- Also affected part of Changbai Korean Autonomous County
- Only Autonomous Prefecture in Chinese northeast
- Hosts much of China's 2 million Korean minority population
- Chinese citizenship acquisition today is difficult, so current Korean population largely due to 1909 treaty
Historical Context Leading to Treaty
- 1858-1860: China lost large territory to Russian Empire during weak period
- Korean ethnic peasants, encouraged by Japanese, began illegally settling in current Yanbian area
- Terrible famine in 1860s + weak border controls pushed Korean migration into Chinese territory
- Qing Dynasty partially accepted educated, valuable agricultural settlers
- Realized illegal immigration needed control to prevent Russian/Japanese exploitation
Japanese Territorial Ambitions
- Japan's influence in Korea already obvious by early 1900s
- Japanese decided could unilaterally take land claiming to "protect its subjects"
- After Japan colonized Korea, sought to leverage Korean population for territorial claims
- Japanese aggressively questioned Chinese sovereignty, pointing to majority Korean ethnic population
- Japan briefly occupied region starting 1907
- Qing aggressively reasserted territorial claims in response
Treaty Resolution
- Agreement reached: Japan recognized Chinese sovereignty over Gondo territory
- In return: Japan received mining concessions and railway building rights in northeast China/Manchuria
- Korean population in China became Chinese subjects
- Japanese army retreated to previously defined borders
Modern Official Positions
- Both North and South Korea officially state Yanbian unequivocally belongs to China
- 2004 bill represented Korean nationalist viewpoint
- Nationalist argument: all treaties concerning Korea signed by Tokyo during Japanese rule should be null/void
- Korea lacked sovereignty during this time, making it "unequal treaty"
Korean Historical Claims
1712 Border Treaty Dispute
- 1712: Manchus and Korean Chosun Kingdom signed treaty drawing borders along Yalu and Tumen rivers
- Yalu River border easily determined
- Tumen River border ambiguous due to lack of 18th century satellite mapping
- Illegal settlers argued "Tumen River" in treaty used different character, didn't mean modern Tumen River
- Pointed to contemporary map showing second river
- Qing and Chosun officials met 1880 to discuss, but history intervened
Ancient Goguryeo Kingdom Claims
- Secondary claim stems from ancient Goguryeo kingdom
- Dominated area for ~700 years
- One of three kingdoms of Korea (along with Silla and Baekje)
- At peak controlled northern Korean Peninsula + parts of Manchuria, Russia, northeast China
- Despite giving Korea its name, vivid debate whether actually Korean
China's Northeast History Project Response
- Starting 2002: China launched Northeast History Project
- Reviewed histories of traditionally non-Han region
- China began claiming Goguryeo and its separate kingdoms as minority Chinese kingdoms
- Website deleted references to Goguryeo from Korea's history
- Issued stamps commemorating China's Goguryeo as UNESCO World Heritage site
Current Status and Resolution
- 1962: North Korea signed boundary treaty with PRC setting modern boundary unambiguously at Tumen River
- South Korea had no party in treaty but probably doesn't dispute it
- After 2004 legislation kerfuffle, South Korea quickly backed down after PRC's "strong negative reaction"
Analysis of Claims
Arguments for Korean Position
- 1909 Sino-Japanese Agreement arguably unequal treaty
- Goguryeo somewhat Korean (founded 600s)
Arguments for Chinese Position
- China controlled Yanbian territory since Yuan dynasty (12th-13th century)
- Manchus (eventual Qing dynasty heads) considered it part of origin lands
- Yanbian basically unpopulated until 1860s
- Manchus kept it sparsely populated for centuries as potential retreat beyond Great Wall
- Qing being lenient granting Korean illegal settlers Chinese subject status rather than ejecting them
- 18th century map's second Tumen River no longer exists, cannot serve as modern guide
- Other contemporary maps show border properly following modern Tumen River
Chinese Korean Population Reality
- Chinese Korean population historically extremely pro-CCP
- Played crucial role resisting Japanese during WWII
- Helped cement Kuomintang defeat in northeast China
- Partially for these reasons China granted region current autonomous status
- Population not interested in becoming "third Korea"
Conclusion and Future Implications
- Territory stays with China
- Korean nationalists made their point, China not excited about this
- Part of larger history wars between China and Korea
- Less publicized than China-Japan history wars
- Gondo territory settled for today but more tensions await between China and both Koreas
