AI summary by TwinMind
Brazil Tried to Protect Its Computer Industry
Asianometry
23m 24s
Early Brazilian Computing History (1957-1970s)
- First computer: 1957 Sao Paulo imported Sperry Univac 120 for water distribution tracking
- 4,500 vacuum tubes, 12,000 addition/subtraction operations per minute
- First domestic computer: 1961 Zazinho by 4 ITA students
- Teaching tool/graduation project, 1,500 transistors, looked like doorless fridge
- Cannibalized for parts by 1963, team dispersed
- Military coup impact: 1964 military dictatorship
- ITA became oppressively run, lost academic reputation
- Staff went abroad, research progress halted
- Foreign market dominance: Post-1964 multinationals entered
- IBM, Burroughs, Digital Equipment, Honeywell
- Market grew 30-40% annually, Brazil became 12th largest computer market
- Only low-level assembly operations, no R&D
Push for Domestic Industry (Late 1960s-1970s)
- Motivations for domestic industry:
- Engineering professors wanted robust job market for students
- Preserve foreign exchange reserves
- National security concerns with military equipment
- Navy catalyst: Late 1960s purchased 6 British Vosper frigates
- Fitted with Ferranti mini computers for navigation/firing
- Concern about maintenance/repair capabilities
- Gorenis Project: 1971 Navy + National Economic Development Bank
- $4 million tender for domestic computer within 4 years
- University competition initiated
University Competition & Early Development
- University of Campinas: Sisna Bronco (White Swan) project
- Mini computer like IBM 1130 with 24-bit processor
- Media attention due to American-trained returnees
- University of Sao Paulo: LSD lab (July 1972)
- "Ugly Duckling" project competing with White Swan
- 1 meter x 1 meter box, 450 chips
- 4 kilobyte magnetic core memory (Philips)
- Less memory than White Swan but more practical
- LSD victory: After 3 years, presented working computer
- Won despite photographer tripping wire during demo
- LSD handled hardware, Catholic University Rio handled software
Cobra Formation & Early Products (1974-1976)
- Company creation: 1974 BNDE 3-way joint venture
- Partners: BNDE, EE Electronica, Ferranti
- Named Computadores e Sistemas Brasileiros (Cobra)
- Product line development:
- Cobra 700 series: Brazilian-assembled Ferranti designs
- Cobra 400 series: Technology transfer from Sitecore Inc (after Data General declined)
- Cobra 530: First domestically designed/built mini computer (from Ugly Duckling/G10)
- Financial struggles: Unable to meet Navy goals
- EE Electronica and Ferranti sold stakes
- Required regular cash infusions from Brazilian Development Bank
Government Intervention & Market Reserve Policy (1972-1977)
- Capra formation: April 1972 Coordinating Committee for Electronic Processing Activities
- Initially managed computer imports
- Evolved to develop domestic industry
- Oil crisis impact: 1970s Brazil imported 80% of oil
- Capra gained political power as crisis worsened
- Resolution 104: December 1975 new powers for Capra
- All computer/component imports required Capra approval
- Import limits: $110 million (1976), $130 million (1978)
- Market segmentation: July 1976 Capra split market
- High-end computers: IBM, Burroughs allowed
- Mini/microcomputers: Reserved for domestic firms
- Similar to India's ECIL strategy
- Cobra recapitalization: Consortium of 11 Brazilian banks
- BNDE + government organizations added millions
- 1977 final selection: Cobra + 4 new domestic firms chosen
- Sid, Labo, Edisa, Cisco for mini computers
- IBM/Americans locked out of nascent mini computer market
Military Takeover & SEI Era (1979-1984)
- Military intervention: 1979 co-opted Capra with SEI
- Military felt Capra had too much political independence
- IT too important for civilians
- SEI characteristics:
- Authoritarian, acted arbitrarily
- Monitored/punished people not repudiating leftist ideologies
- Continued Capra's market reserve policies
- Balanced approach: 1980 allowed IBM model 4331 manufacture under conditions
- Industry growth: First half 1980s rapid expansion
- Brazilian firms: 80% market share in 4 years after 1978
- Cobra: 70% market share of mini computers (1980)
- Cobra 530: 6,000+ units sold at European-comparable prices
Domestic Industry Peak (1980-1984)
- Industry scale: By 1983
- 100 Brazilian computer companies
- 18,000 employees (1,200 high-paying R&D jobs)
- Major players: Cobra (largest), Itau Tech, Sid
- PC Revolution impact: Brazilian 8-bit PCs competitive with mini computers
- Reverse-engineered clones of Sinclair, Apple, TRS
- Cheap imported microprocessors enabled easy entry
- Companies like Scopus entered market
- Domestic PC designs: Pro Logica CP500 comparable to TRS microcomputers
- Export success: 1983 Brazil exported $26 million worth of IBM PC-compatible PCs
- Company limitations: None internationally competitive or large
- Cobra total capital: $15 million (1983)
- 1984 Informatics Law: Renewed market reserve policy
Semiconductor Attempts (1970s-1980s)
- Early failure: 1972 Transit Semiconductor
- Government-funded, collaborated with University of Sao Paulo
- Fab in Montes Claros for diodes, then integrated circuits
- Failed to produce quality diodes, closed 1980
- Import growth: Sophisticated semiconductors
- $63.3 million (1978) to $95.6 million (1981)
- 1984 landscape: 18 semiconductor firms
- Only 1 Brazilian-owned doing more than assembly: Sid
- Total market demand: $180 million (1984)
- 1983 SEI strategy: Market reserve for semiconductors
- Selected 3 companies: Sid, Itau Tech, Elibra
- Start with back-end processes, move upwards
- Some success: car radios exported with Brazilian chips
- Ended in 1990s due to bad financials/changing conditions
Technology Gap & Decline (1980s-1990s)
- Mini computer crisis: Traditional makers hit by PC revolution
- Needed migration to 32-bit super mini computers
- Cobra: 1983 indigenous 32-bit workstation (Motorola 68000)
- Others licensed older designs (VAX 750 from DEC)
- Foreigners wouldn't license best designs
- IBM resurgence: Medium-sized 4331 computer
- Market share doubled 1982-1984
- Brazilian mini makers caught between IBM above, PCs below
- 1983: Selling fewer systems than 4 years earlier
- PC maker performance lag: Late 1980s
- Technical performance: 3-5 years behind foreign competitors
- Cost: 70-100% more than US (15-25% more than West Germany)
- Higher raw goods costs (copper, chemicals for PCBs)
- Non-semiconductor components: 2-5x more expensive than world
- Scale disadvantage: 1989 production comparison
- Leading Brazilian PC makers: 20,000 PCs
- Taiwan's Acer alone: 400,000 PCs
- Lack of automation, particularly PCB manufacturing
Market Distortions & Black Market (1980s-1990s)
- Import alternatives: Large buyers dealt with bureaucracy for foreign computers
- Black market growth: Small buyers resorted to smuggling
- 1991: 65% of Brazil's PCs from black market
- Subsidy cost: Economist calculations
- 20-33% of computer market price
- Economic context: General malaise made subsidy harder to justify
- 1987: 25% unemployment, 366% inflation
- Computer industry growth: 30% to 10% annually
- Competitiveness concerns: Brazilian manufacturers worried about technology gap
- Impeded competitiveness abroad, especially computer-controlled manufacturing
External Pressure & Trade Disputes (1980s-1990s)
- US pressure: Brazil's largest trading partner
- 23% of total export sales, 16% of non-oil exports
- High foreign debt made trade disruption problematic
- 1984 renewal protests: Loud protests from multinationals
- Reagan Administration: 1985 filed investigation
- Trade talks on software/hardware aspects
- No serious sanctions imposed
- 1987 Reagan threats spurred continued negotiations
Liberalization & Industry Transformation (1990s)
- Political change: 1990 Fernando Collor de Mello
- First democratically elected president post-dictatorship
- Ran on IT market liberalization platform
- Market opening: Within 5 years
- Compaq, IBM became top 3 PC makers in Brazil
- Production/import surged to meet domestic demand
- Dell, Gateway entered, took over local firms, opened factories
- Survivor strategies: Brazilian companies in specific niches
- Banking, military applications
- Cobra: Now owned by Bank of Brazil, renamed BB Technologies and Services
Policy Assessment & Legacy
- Achievements: 15-year domestic manufacturing industry
- National security, technological independence, domestic employment goals met
- Done without foreign technology transfer (multinationals declined)
- Shortcomings: Efficiency and directional focus
- Government approval based on national origins vs efficiency/scale/market size
- Companies stayed in protected domestic market
- Little chance of survival once protections lifted
- Tragedy: Companies unprepared for global competition when protections ended
