AI summary by TwinMind
Can 5G Replace Your Home Internet? | WSJ
The Wall Street Journal
6m 36s
5G RV Setup and Motivation
- Tech journalist moved into motorhome for 24 hours to test 5G powering home devices
- Setup: Verizon 5G small cell pole outside RV, Verizon OnePlus 8 5G smartphone inside
- Phone getting 10x faster speeds than home WiFi, hotspot powering 15 other gadgets
- Located in Jersey City where 5G being deployed by major carriers
- Real home not near 5G pole yet, millimeter wave requires few hundred feet proximity for top speeds
5G Technology Overview
- Millimeter Wave 5G: High frequency, insanely fast (6x faster than 4G, 10x faster than home WiFi)
- Very limited coverage, few hundred feet from cell site
- Doesn't penetrate walls/obstacles well
- Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile deploying throughout country
- Test speeds: 1,300 Mbps download vs 100 Mbps home WiFi
- Sub-6 5G: Frequencies below 6 GHz
- Not as fast as millimeter wave but faster than 4G LTE
- More practical: works inside buildings, wider coverage
- Only AT&T and T-Mobile have sub-6 in Jersey City
- Verizon plans sub-6 rollout before end of year
- Test speeds: AT&T sub-6 averaged [unclear] Mbps, T-Mobile sub-6 got 120 Mbps
- All carriers require new 5G phone for these speeds
Challenge 1: Video Streaming
- Simultaneous activities: Frozen 2 on TV, 2 4K laptop streams, FaceTime call to mom, connected doorbell
- Added second video call to dad and colleagues call
- Results: Hit or miss performance
- Issues unclear if network or phone hotspot related
- Phone hotspots not designed for 10+ simultaneous devices
- Carrier plans have data caps on hotspot usage with speed throttling after exceeding
Challenge 2: Gaming
- Producer Kenny tested Apex Legends gaming
- Verizon millimeter wave: Impressive performance, better than wired home broadband
- No rubber banding (lag warping)
- No lag icons
- Oculus Quest VR: Fast menu loading, large games downloaded in minutes, attended live VR event
- T-Mobile 5G: Similar strong performance to Verizon
- AT&T: Shaky performance, laggy gameplay even with location changes
Challenge 3: File Uploading
- 1 GB folder upload to Google Drive: 6-7 minutes on each 5G network
- Home WiFi: 4.5 minutes for same upload
- Maximum upload speed achieved: ~60 Mbps on Verizon
- Home network upload: 100 Mbps
Key Findings and Future Outlook
- 5G very fast and more useful connecting multiple gadgets vs single phone
- Current setup not intended 5G use yet
- Carriers need time to improve coverage, release home routers/hotspots
- Verizon already has 5G home offering in some markets
- T-Mobile gearing up for similar service
- Higher costs expected for consumers
- Current practical use: RV family vacations near 5G poles
