AI summary by TwinMind

Can light stop the coronavirus? | David Brenner

TED

30m 15s

Introduction to Far UVC Light Technology

  • Far UVC light = type of UV light with wavelengths around 220 nanometers
  • Similar to visible light but different wavelengths make it invisible to human eyes
  • UV light killing viruses/bacteria known for 100+ years
  • Conventional germicidal UV light used in hospital operating rooms
  • Problem: conventional UV light has potential hazards to eyes/skin when people directly exposed
  • Greatly limits how/when conventional UV can be used

Far UVC Light Safety and Effectiveness

  • Discovered 7-8 years ago: Far UVC light both kills viruses AND is safe for human exposure
  • Physics reason for safety: Far UVC light cannot penetrate into living cells in human body
    • Cannot penetrate skin or eyes due to physics limitations
    • Surface of skin = layer of dead cells that Far UVC cannot penetrate through
    • Cannot reach living cells in epidermis/dermis
    • Eye surface has tear layer that Far UVC cannot penetrate
    • Cannot reach living cells in cornea or deeper lens
  • Bacteria/viruses are much smaller entities
    • Far UV light has enough range to penetrate and kill them
  • Multiple studies over 5-6 years by many groups worldwide
    • Studies on human skin, mouse skin, mouse eyes in different situations/countries
    • All point to safety confirmation
  • Regulatory framework exists with limits for UV light exposure at any wavelength
  • Key: stay within regulatory limits

Virus Killing Capability

  • Confirmed: Far UVC light very efficient at killing coronaviruses
  • Testing multiple human coronaviruses systematically
  • Working up to SARS-CoV-2 virus
  • Confirmed: very efficient at killing coronaviruses
  • Broader applications: effective against influenza and future pandemic viruses
  • Different from vaccines (specific to one strain) - works against multiple virus types

Practical Applications and Implementation

  • Potential for overhead indoor Far UVC lights in occupied spaces
  • Reduce person-to-person transmission risk
  • Target locations: hospitals, nursing homes, buses, planes, trains, train stations, schools, restaurants, offices, shops, theaters, gyms
  • Installation similar to visible lighting - ceiling-mounted
  • Same electrical requirements as regular lights
  • Some manufacturers building combined fixtures (visible light + Far UVC)
  • Others making separate fixtures
  • Room size determines number of lights needed (same as visible lighting)

Operational Considerations

  • Lights should be on continuously or significant fraction of time
  • Not useful to have lights on briefly (e.g., 5 minutes at 8am then off)
  • Goal: continuously kill viruses as they're produced by people sneezing/coughing/talking
  • Keeps virus levels in air as low as possible
  • Want 99.99% killing in few minutes - achievable
  • Lower virus levels = less transmission chance

Ozone Production and Safety

  • Far UVC light does not produce significant ozone
  • Wavelength doesn't produce much ozone
  • Always measure/monitor ozone levels
  • Ozone production is "minuscule" - way below EPA safety levels
  • Not expected to be health issue

Current Market Status and Availability

  • Manufacturers started ramping up production only when COVID-19 crisis hit
  • Current capacity relatively limited
  • Difficult for individuals to get lamps for home use currently
  • Production ramping up rapidly
  • Expected: many Far UVC products available by end of year
  • Test projects ongoing in various locations including New York City
  • Columbia University looking strongly at implementation

UV Light Types and Sun Comparison

  • Three UV types: UVA, UVB, UVC (different wavelengths)
  • UVC most efficient at killing viruses/bacteria
  • Sun produces all three types but UVC entirely absorbed in upper atmosphere/ozone layer
  • Only UVA/UVB reach ground level (cause suntan/sunburn)
  • UVA/UVB not very efficient at killing viruses/bacteria
  • No natural UVC occurs at ground level

NYC Subway Current UV Usage

  • MTA using conventional germicidal UV light (not Far UVC)
  • Can only use when humans not present due to safety concerns
  • Sterilizing trains/buses overnight during 1am-5am closure
  • Good starting point but effects wear off during day as people enter
  • Need continuous disinfection during occupied hours
  • Far UVC would allow continuous use with people present

Resistance and Evolution Concerns

  • No evidence of UV-resistant viruses emerging despite decades of UVC use
  • Different from drug resistance - UV acts like "sledgehammer" on viral RNA
  • Cannot predict exactly where damage occurs within RNA
  • Very hard for virus to evolve repair mechanisms for random RNA damage anywhere in genome
  • No evidence of UV-resistant viruses appearing

Personal Journey and Research Background

  • Original motivation: friend died from drug-resistant bacterial disease
  • Initial focus: reducing surgical site infections in hospitals
  • First few years focused entirely on bacteria
  • 2-3 years later: realized applicability to viruses
  • Pre-COVID focus: seasonal influenza epidemic reduction
  • Influenza kills many people annually
  • COVID-19 emergence: concepts developed for influenza applicable to coronavirus
  • Both transmitted person-to-person primarily by airborne routes
  • Recently published: Far UVC light kills coronaviruses in air

Manufacturing and Technology Challenges

  • Biggest problem: building production capacity for lamps
  • Industry only started building these lamps in spring 2020
  • Capacity insufficient for millions of lamps in demand
  • Need simpler, cheaper manufacturing technology
  • Current lamps not particularly expensive/complicated but could be improved
  • LED technology potential: replace current Far UVC light types
    • Quicker, easier to make, probably cheaper, longer-lived
  • Call for optics community to develop LED lights at Far UVC wavelengths

Microbiome Considerations

  • Concern: creating overly sterile environment harmful to beneficial bacteria
  • Most helpful microbiome inside body (gut) - Far UVC cannot reach internal areas
  • Skin microbiome exists on surface
  • Hand washing more damaging to skin microbiome than Far UVC exposure
  • Skin microbiome resilient and regenerates quickly when removed
  • Continue hand washing even with Far UVC lights available

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome