AI summary by TwinMind
Can light stop the coronavirus? | David Brenner
TED
30m 15s
Introduction to Far UVC Light Technology
- Far UVC light = type of UV light with wavelengths around 220 nanometers
- Similar to visible light but different wavelengths make it invisible to human eyes
- UV light killing viruses/bacteria known for 100+ years
- Conventional germicidal UV light used in hospital operating rooms
- Problem: conventional UV light has potential hazards to eyes/skin when people directly exposed
- Greatly limits how/when conventional UV can be used
Far UVC Light Safety and Effectiveness
- Discovered 7-8 years ago: Far UVC light both kills viruses AND is safe for human exposure
- Physics reason for safety: Far UVC light cannot penetrate into living cells in human body
- Cannot penetrate skin or eyes due to physics limitations
- Surface of skin = layer of dead cells that Far UVC cannot penetrate through
- Cannot reach living cells in epidermis/dermis
- Eye surface has tear layer that Far UVC cannot penetrate
- Cannot reach living cells in cornea or deeper lens
- Bacteria/viruses are much smaller entities
- Far UV light has enough range to penetrate and kill them
- Multiple studies over 5-6 years by many groups worldwide
- Studies on human skin, mouse skin, mouse eyes in different situations/countries
- All point to safety confirmation
- Regulatory framework exists with limits for UV light exposure at any wavelength
- Key: stay within regulatory limits
Virus Killing Capability
- Confirmed: Far UVC light very efficient at killing coronaviruses
- Testing multiple human coronaviruses systematically
- Working up to SARS-CoV-2 virus
- Confirmed: very efficient at killing coronaviruses
- Broader applications: effective against influenza and future pandemic viruses
- Different from vaccines (specific to one strain) - works against multiple virus types
Practical Applications and Implementation
- Potential for overhead indoor Far UVC lights in occupied spaces
- Reduce person-to-person transmission risk
- Target locations: hospitals, nursing homes, buses, planes, trains, train stations, schools, restaurants, offices, shops, theaters, gyms
- Installation similar to visible lighting - ceiling-mounted
- Same electrical requirements as regular lights
- Some manufacturers building combined fixtures (visible light + Far UVC)
- Others making separate fixtures
- Room size determines number of lights needed (same as visible lighting)
Operational Considerations
- Lights should be on continuously or significant fraction of time
- Not useful to have lights on briefly (e.g., 5 minutes at 8am then off)
- Goal: continuously kill viruses as they're produced by people sneezing/coughing/talking
- Keeps virus levels in air as low as possible
- Want 99.99% killing in few minutes - achievable
- Lower virus levels = less transmission chance
Ozone Production and Safety
- Far UVC light does not produce significant ozone
- Wavelength doesn't produce much ozone
- Always measure/monitor ozone levels
- Ozone production is "minuscule" - way below EPA safety levels
- Not expected to be health issue
Current Market Status and Availability
- Manufacturers started ramping up production only when COVID-19 crisis hit
- Current capacity relatively limited
- Difficult for individuals to get lamps for home use currently
- Production ramping up rapidly
- Expected: many Far UVC products available by end of year
- Test projects ongoing in various locations including New York City
- Columbia University looking strongly at implementation
UV Light Types and Sun Comparison
- Three UV types: UVA, UVB, UVC (different wavelengths)
- UVC most efficient at killing viruses/bacteria
- Sun produces all three types but UVC entirely absorbed in upper atmosphere/ozone layer
- Only UVA/UVB reach ground level (cause suntan/sunburn)
- UVA/UVB not very efficient at killing viruses/bacteria
- No natural UVC occurs at ground level
NYC Subway Current UV Usage
- MTA using conventional germicidal UV light (not Far UVC)
- Can only use when humans not present due to safety concerns
- Sterilizing trains/buses overnight during 1am-5am closure
- Good starting point but effects wear off during day as people enter
- Need continuous disinfection during occupied hours
- Far UVC would allow continuous use with people present
Resistance and Evolution Concerns
- No evidence of UV-resistant viruses emerging despite decades of UVC use
- Different from drug resistance - UV acts like "sledgehammer" on viral RNA
- Cannot predict exactly where damage occurs within RNA
- Very hard for virus to evolve repair mechanisms for random RNA damage anywhere in genome
- No evidence of UV-resistant viruses appearing
Personal Journey and Research Background
- Original motivation: friend died from drug-resistant bacterial disease
- Initial focus: reducing surgical site infections in hospitals
- First few years focused entirely on bacteria
- 2-3 years later: realized applicability to viruses
- Pre-COVID focus: seasonal influenza epidemic reduction
- Influenza kills many people annually
- COVID-19 emergence: concepts developed for influenza applicable to coronavirus
- Both transmitted person-to-person primarily by airborne routes
- Recently published: Far UVC light kills coronaviruses in air
Manufacturing and Technology Challenges
- Biggest problem: building production capacity for lamps
- Industry only started building these lamps in spring 2020
- Capacity insufficient for millions of lamps in demand
- Need simpler, cheaper manufacturing technology
- Current lamps not particularly expensive/complicated but could be improved
- LED technology potential: replace current Far UVC light types
- Quicker, easier to make, probably cheaper, longer-lived
- Call for optics community to develop LED lights at Far UVC wavelengths
Microbiome Considerations
- Concern: creating overly sterile environment harmful to beneficial bacteria
- Most helpful microbiome inside body (gut) - Far UVC cannot reach internal areas
- Skin microbiome exists on surface
- Hand washing more damaging to skin microbiome than Far UVC exposure
- Skin microbiome resilient and regenerates quickly when removed
- Continue hand washing even with Far UVC lights available
