AI summary by TwinMind
Can quantum entanglement make money on the stock market?
Sabine Hossenfelder
9m 29s
Quantum Tech Hype and Stock Market Claims
- ~10 years ago: wave of articles claiming entangled particles communicate faster than light
- Claims suggested using "Einstein's spooky action at a distance" to beat high-speed traders in stock market
- Recent New Scientist article about quantum tech revolutionizing stock markets prompted analysis
High-Speed Trading Reality
- Stock trades operate close to speed of light limit
- Speed advantage critical: faster information collection/trading = better profit chances
- When algorithms predict same outcome, microseconds matter for sending information to nearest stock exchange
- Described as "high stakes game of musical chairs but with retirement savings"
- Anecdote: friend uses fiber optic cables for golf booking advantage
Einstein's "Spooky Action at a Distance" Explanation
- Einstein used phrase in letter to Bohr referring to wave function collapse
- Quantum superposition: particles can be in multiple places simultaneously
- Bohr's interpretation: measurement causes superposition collapse, particle suddenly in one place
- Einstein's objection: collapse would be faster than light - finding particle in one place means instantaneous knowledge it's not elsewhere
- Einstein's view: particles really only in one place, wave function update just means learning particle isn't elsewhere
- Key point: even if spooky action existed, couldn't transfer information
- John Bell's analogy: Queen dies in London, Prince becomes king instantaneously, but royal mail doesn't go faster than light
Entanglement vs Spooky Action Confusion
- Entanglement frequently confused with Einstein's spooky action
- Entanglement = type of superposition where particles are correlated
- Example: two particles with identical spins (direction unknown)
- Creating entangled pair: send one left, one right - spins correlated but particles can't interact
- Critical misconception: manipulating one entangled particle does NOT affect the other
- Reality: measurement on one particle reveals information about other due to correlation
- Measurement outcomes are random and unpredictable
- Person measuring one end cannot tell if measurement was done on other end
- Conclusion: can't send information faster than light with entanglement
New Paper Analysis
- Initial assumption: paper about sending information faster than light (impossible)
- Actual content: correlating actions in two places using entangled particles
- Proposed method:
- Two traders at different exchanges
- Each receives one entangled particle
- Base buy/sell decisions on measurement outcomes
- Correlated particles create correlated trading actions
- Authors claim "quantum advantage in trading"
Critique of Quantum Trading Approach
- Strong doubt about quantum advantage claim
- Alternative methods for creating correlations:
- Send signals from middle location (doesn't need to be fast)
- Use synchronized atomic clocks (no signal needed)
- If correlated trading decisions provide advantage, traders likely already doing it for decades
- Won't make anyone rich with quantum approach
Key Lesson
- Adding "quantum" to something doesn't automatically make it better
- Otherwise would have quantum toothbrushes by now
- Cannot trade stocks faster than light
Book Recommendation
- "Faster Than Light" by Robert Nemiroff
- Professor of physics at Michigan Technological University
- Covers everything physicists know about faster-than-light motion
- Topics include:
- Why shadows can move faster than light
- Special relativity and FTL travel
- How quantum mechanics seems to beat speed limit but doesn't
- Nemiroff: creator/editor of NASA's Astronomy Picture of the Day
- Written multiple astrophysics papers
- Book suitable for non-physicists, engagingly written
