AI summary by TwinMind
Can We Prevent Hurricanes?
Sabine Hossenfelder
13m 5s
Hurricane Characteristics and Scale
- Hurricanes among most devastating natural disasters
- Medium-sized hurricane extends over area larger than Texas
- Cover 6-12 degrees latitude on globe
- Leave destruction from strong winds, rain, storm surges
- Damages regularly exceed billions USD
- Hurricane = typhoon = tropical cyclone (different regional terms)
- Generic meteorological term: tropical cyclone
- Rotating organized system of clouds/thunderstorms
- Originates over tropical/sub-tropical waters
- Called hurricanes/typhoons when large enough
Nuclear Bomb Proposals - Historical Context
- Donald Trump reportedly asked repeatedly about dropping nuclear bombs on hurricanes
- Proposal swiftly dismissed by scientists/media
- Trump denied making statements
- Idea not new - emerged right after nuclear weapons first deployed Japan August 1945
- Miami Beach mayor Herbert Frink asked President Harry Truman about using nuclear weapons against hurricanes
- Americans investigated but quickly realized inadequate energy scale
Energy Scale Comparison
- Atomic bombs dropped on Japan: ~20 kilotons each
- Typical hurricane generates 100x more energy per hour (kinetic energy only)
- Total hurricane energy: 10,000x atomic bomb energy
- Hurricane total power comparable to entire global power consumption
- Hurricanes enormous in scale
Jack W. Reed's 1956 Proposal
- Air Force meteorologist proposed launching megaton nuclear bomb (50x power of Japan bombs) into hurricane
- Argued "complete theory for hurricane dynamics probably not derived by meteorologists for several years"
- Claimed only full-scale test could prove results
- Radiation hazard claimed negligible - "air burst would cause no intense fallout"
- Proposal dismissed by military and scientific community
- Test never took place
Hurricane Formation Process
- Form over ocean when water temperature ≥26°C (80°F)
- Warm water evaporates and rises
- Rising air cools, creates clouds
- Water-heavy cloud tower begins spinning due to Coriolis force from Earth's rotation
- Stronger winds extract more heat from ocean, driving cycle
- Spinning accelerates, center clears out
- Eye of hurricane: calm region, few dozen miles diameter, very low barometric pressure
Reed's Nuclear Strategy Theory
- Detonate megaton weapon directly in hurricane eye
- Would blast away warm air feeding the cycle
- Increase barometric pressure
- Prevent storm from gathering strength
- Problems:
- Deposits radioactive debris in clouds blasted globally
- Hurricanes enormous - nuclear bomb power exceeded by 2+ orders of magnitude
- Explosions don't move air from place to place effectively
- Blast creates shock wave but little barometric pressure change after shock passes
Cloud Seeding Attempts
- Project Storm Fury (1962) - first director Robert Homer Simpson
- Goal: weaken hurricanes through glaciogenic seeding
- Sprayed hurricane with silver iodide
- Hurricane weakened afterward
- Further research showed hurricane clouds contain very little supercooled water droplets
- Method couldn't work in theory
- Hurricanes frequently undergo similar changes without intervention
- Observation likely coincidence
- Project cancelled 1983
Hydroscopic Cloud Seeding
- Works by spraying clouds with water-absorbing particles
- Computer simulations show could work (2007 Rosenfeld study)
- Problem: hurricanes enormous
- Would need army of airplanes to spray clouds
- Would likely only weaken hurricanes, not eliminate them
Other Hurricane Modification Ideas
- Spray upper hurricane layers with sunlight-absorbing particles
- Warm air, reduce updraft
- Problem: need to spray Texas-sized area
- Prevent ocean evaporation with oil films
- Oil cover breaks up
- Where intact, can aid water warming (opposite of desired effect)
- Drag icebergs from poles to tropics to cool water
- Logistical challenges enormous
Ocean Cooling Systems
- Bill Gates 2009 patent: pump system floating in ocean
- Pump cool water from deep ocean to surface
- 2017 Norwegian company Syntov similar proposal
- Would need to work in hurricane eye to break feedback cycle
- Fair chance of working
- Problems:
- Get pumps in right place at right time
- Pump water over 20-40 mile diameter area
- Hurricanes enormous scale
Nuclear Redirection Strategy
- Detonate nuclear bomb strategically to change hurricane direction
- Problem: no one wants multiple nations playing "nuclear billiard" on oceans
Prevention vs Intervention
- Most promising approach: intervene before hurricanes get large
- Hurricanes don't suddenly appear - take several days to form
- Usually arise from tropical storms (also don't appear suddenly)
- Problem: meteorologists can't predict well enough/long enough in advance which regions will form hurricanes
- Some interference methods with feedback cycle may actually work
- Need better prediction of when/where to interfere
Conclusion
- Don't need larger bombs - need better weather forecasts
- Investment in forecasting technology more promising than destructive intervention
