AI summary by TwinMind

Can We Prevent Hurricanes?

Sabine Hossenfelder

13m 5s

Hurricane Characteristics and Scale

  • Hurricanes among most devastating natural disasters
  • Medium-sized hurricane extends over area larger than Texas
  • Cover 6-12 degrees latitude on globe
  • Leave destruction from strong winds, rain, storm surges
  • Damages regularly exceed billions USD
  • Hurricane = typhoon = tropical cyclone (different regional terms)
  • Generic meteorological term: tropical cyclone
    • Rotating organized system of clouds/thunderstorms
    • Originates over tropical/sub-tropical waters
    • Called hurricanes/typhoons when large enough

Nuclear Bomb Proposals - Historical Context

  • Donald Trump reportedly asked repeatedly about dropping nuclear bombs on hurricanes
  • Proposal swiftly dismissed by scientists/media
  • Trump denied making statements
  • Idea not new - emerged right after nuclear weapons first deployed Japan August 1945
  • Miami Beach mayor Herbert Frink asked President Harry Truman about using nuclear weapons against hurricanes
  • Americans investigated but quickly realized inadequate energy scale

Energy Scale Comparison

  • Atomic bombs dropped on Japan: ~20 kilotons each
  • Typical hurricane generates 100x more energy per hour (kinetic energy only)
  • Total hurricane energy: 10,000x atomic bomb energy
  • Hurricane total power comparable to entire global power consumption
  • Hurricanes enormous in scale

Jack W. Reed's 1956 Proposal

  • Air Force meteorologist proposed launching megaton nuclear bomb (50x power of Japan bombs) into hurricane
  • Argued "complete theory for hurricane dynamics probably not derived by meteorologists for several years"
  • Claimed only full-scale test could prove results
  • Radiation hazard claimed negligible - "air burst would cause no intense fallout"
  • Proposal dismissed by military and scientific community
  • Test never took place

Hurricane Formation Process

  • Form over ocean when water temperature ≥26°C (80°F)
  • Warm water evaporates and rises
  • Rising air cools, creates clouds
  • Water-heavy cloud tower begins spinning due to Coriolis force from Earth's rotation
  • Stronger winds extract more heat from ocean, driving cycle
  • Spinning accelerates, center clears out
  • Eye of hurricane: calm region, few dozen miles diameter, very low barometric pressure

Reed's Nuclear Strategy Theory

  • Detonate megaton weapon directly in hurricane eye
  • Would blast away warm air feeding the cycle
  • Increase barometric pressure
  • Prevent storm from gathering strength
  • Problems:
    • Deposits radioactive debris in clouds blasted globally
    • Hurricanes enormous - nuclear bomb power exceeded by 2+ orders of magnitude
    • Explosions don't move air from place to place effectively
    • Blast creates shock wave but little barometric pressure change after shock passes

Cloud Seeding Attempts

  • Project Storm Fury (1962) - first director Robert Homer Simpson
  • Goal: weaken hurricanes through glaciogenic seeding
  • Sprayed hurricane with silver iodide
  • Hurricane weakened afterward
  • Further research showed hurricane clouds contain very little supercooled water droplets
  • Method couldn't work in theory
  • Hurricanes frequently undergo similar changes without intervention
  • Observation likely coincidence
  • Project cancelled 1983

Hydroscopic Cloud Seeding

  • Works by spraying clouds with water-absorbing particles
  • Computer simulations show could work (2007 Rosenfeld study)
  • Problem: hurricanes enormous
  • Would need army of airplanes to spray clouds
  • Would likely only weaken hurricanes, not eliminate them

Other Hurricane Modification Ideas

  • Spray upper hurricane layers with sunlight-absorbing particles
    • Warm air, reduce updraft
    • Problem: need to spray Texas-sized area
  • Prevent ocean evaporation with oil films
    • Oil cover breaks up
    • Where intact, can aid water warming (opposite of desired effect)
  • Drag icebergs from poles to tropics to cool water
    • Logistical challenges enormous

Ocean Cooling Systems

  • Bill Gates 2009 patent: pump system floating in ocean
    • Pump cool water from deep ocean to surface
  • 2017 Norwegian company Syntov similar proposal
  • Would need to work in hurricane eye to break feedback cycle
  • Fair chance of working
  • Problems:
    • Get pumps in right place at right time
    • Pump water over 20-40 mile diameter area
    • Hurricanes enormous scale

Nuclear Redirection Strategy

  • Detonate nuclear bomb strategically to change hurricane direction
  • Problem: no one wants multiple nations playing "nuclear billiard" on oceans

Prevention vs Intervention

  • Most promising approach: intervene before hurricanes get large
  • Hurricanes don't suddenly appear - take several days to form
  • Usually arise from tropical storms (also don't appear suddenly)
  • Problem: meteorologists can't predict well enough/long enough in advance which regions will form hurricanes
  • Some interference methods with feedback cycle may actually work
  • Need better prediction of when/where to interfere

Conclusion

  • Don't need larger bombs - need better weather forecasts
  • Investment in forecasting technology more promising than destructive intervention

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome