AI summary by TwinMind

Can We Use Bacteria to Refine Rare Earths?

Asianometry

14m 17s

China's Rare Earth Monopoly Structure

  • China's strategic dominance based on extraction and purification, not mining
  • Provides economic leverage and first-line access to future breakthroughs
  • Chinese researchers have plentiful supply for R&D
  • Current refinement process is dirty, damaging, difficult to scale

Rare Earth Elements Overview

  • 15-17 valuable rare earth elements (REEs)
  • Applications: magnets for green energy/EV, flat screens, fiber optics, MRI machines
  • Small quantities needed but critical for functionality
  • Paradox: found everywhere (even in fertilizers in China), accumulating in plants/animals/people
  • Challenge: finding economically viable concentrations

Traditional Refinement Process

  • Source minerals: basanite, monazite, xenotime
  • Similar chemical properties make separation challenging
  • Multi-step process:
    • Roasting at 300°C+ with acids to remove moisture, decompose minerals
    • Gravitation/flotation for concentration
      • Flotation: chemicals added to ore/water slurry, desired materials rise as froth
      • Gravitation: centrifuges separate by weight
    • Hydrometallurgical steps:
      • Leaching: acids (hydrochloric/sulfuric) dissolve elements from ores
      • Ion exchange or solvent extraction for separation
      • Solvent extraction more commercially scalable
      • Achieves 99% purity
  • China's ecosystem: 100+ companies involved
  • Energy intensive, environmentally damaging
  • Formidable capital-intensive foundation

Bacterial Solutions - Industrial Context

  • Precedent: hyaluronic acid production
    • Traditional: extracted from rooster combs
    • 1990s breakthrough: streptococcus bacteria gene identification
  • Bacteria used for heavy metal pollution cleanup in mine sewage runoff
  • Overlap with rare earth refinement applications

Biosorption Mechanism

  • Subcategory of adsorption process
  • Ions attach to solid biological surface (like hair to balloon)
  • Passive chemical/physical interaction between REE and cell membrane biosorbent
  • Bacteria can be dead (advantageous since REEs toxic at higher concentrations)
  • Advantages over other biological materials (algae, fungi, bamboo charcoal, leaf powder):
    • Pre-treatment for element selectivity
    • High cell membrane surface area to weight ratio
    • Bioabsorption occurs on cell wall

Bioaccumulation Alternative

  • Chemicals/metals accumulate within organism over time (like mercury in tuna)
  • Requires living bacteria actively taking in REEs
  • More difficult to study, scale, predict due to cell metabolism complexities
  • 2019 South Africa study: bacteria from hot vents cultivated with europium
    • Bacteria thrived in low europium levels
    • Electron microscope revealed europium carbonate granules stored inside bacteria
    • Europium used for X-ray scintillators, blue LED phosphors
  • Economic challenges: sourcing special bacteria, keeping them alive during accumulation

Idaho National Laboratory 2017 Study

  • Built airlift bioreactor for bacteria cultivation
  • Bacteria used: Caulobacter crescentus, E. coli
  • Bioengineered with cell wall tags for lanthanide attachment
  • Other studied bacteria: Arthrobacter nicotianae (soil bacteria in cheese), Bacillus subtilis
  • Lanthanides: 15 rare earths from lanthanum to lutetium, includes neodymium
  • Feed stock candidates tested:
    • Traditional ores
    • Coal ash
    • Rare earth clays (acid-leached)
    • Fracking wastewater
  • Process:
    • Bacteria secured in biofilms on high-density polyethylene discs
    • Later studies used beads for higher absorption capacity
    • Air bubbled through chamber for gentle circulation
    • 90% absorption capacity reached
    • Citrate solution strips rare earths
    • Biofilm discs reusable ~10 cycles
    • Solidification and roasting for higher purities

Economic Analysis Results

  • Rare earth ores: cheapest production cost, low market prices
  • Coal fly ash from 22 US coal-fired plants: most profitable
    • Higher value REEs: scandium, cerium
  • Major caveat: 90% of 2017 coal fly ash proceeds from scandium
    • Scandium applications: ceramics, glass, steel alloys
    • Volatile market price
    • Global market: 10-25 tons/year (minuscule)
    • Compare to neodymium: 16,000 tons in 2022 for permanent magnets alone
    • Scandium not monopolized by China

Alternative Feed Stocks

  • Low-grade lignite coal from North Dakota: small neodymium amounts
  • Mining waste and electronic waste potential
  • Far less concentration than China's Bayan Obo mine

Technology Challenges and Limitations

  • Biosorption studied 60+ years, 13,000+ published papers
  • Still not widely implemented industrially
  • Feasibility studies show costs exceed revenues (especially low scandium prices)
  • Cost factors:
    • Acid leaching of feed stocks before bioreactor
    • Sourcing/preparing immobilizing biofilm matrix
    • 2019 Idaho study: silica nanoparticle gel beads cost savings over polyethylene
    • Process optimization needed: microbead reuse cycles critical for profitability
  • Obstacles appear surmountable with targeted policy

Strategic Rationale

  • Even if can't challenge Chinese dominance, worth pursuing for:
    • Local supply chain independence for valuable REEs
    • Threat mitigation for other technology areas
    • Greener, cheaper processing method
    • Safety: REEs toxic/carcinogenic, biosorption removes from wastewater for reuse
  • Built from wastewater treatment technologies
  • Win-win for environmental and economic benefits

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome