AI summary by TwinMind

Can You Do 7nm Chips Without EUV?

Asianometry

16m 32s

EUV vs DUV Lithography Technology Overview

  • EUV (Extreme Ultraviolet) lithography machines cost $150 million each
  • Companies can achieve 7nm without EUV but with significant compromises in performance and cost
  • Prior to EUV, leading edge technology was DUV (Deep Ultraviolet) lithography
    • Uses argon fluoride (ArF) laser with 193nm wavelength
    • First introduced with ASML's PAS 5500 series around 2000
    • Could etch 90nm node generation initially
    • Improved to handle 65nm process node generation

Evolution of Lithography Technology

  • Industry progression over 30 years: G-line mercury lamps → I-line → excimer lasers
  • More powerful light sources improved resolutions and chip performance
  • Planned smooth transition from 193nm to 13.5nm EUV light
  • EUV missed delivery targets for 10 years, forcing industry to extend 193nm technology

Immersion Lithography Introduction

  • Industry introduced immersion lithography to extend 193nm capabilities
  • Shoots 193nm light through water to improve resolution
  • ArFi (Argon Fluoride immersion) entered industry ~2007 with ASML XT 1700i machine
  • Enabled 45nm process node

Node Naming Convention Changes

  • Originally node names corresponded to smallest half pitch or gate length
  • Moore's Law guides numbering: each generation 70% smaller than previous
  • Progression: 65nm → 45nm → 32nm (2009) → 28nm (2010-2011)
  • ArF lasers physically cannot achieve half pitch smaller than 40-45nm in single exposure
  • Industry kept shrinking headline numbers by 70% for marketing despite unchanged half pitches
  • TSMC terminology: N28, N10, N7, N5 (corporate communications standard)

FinFET Transistor Technology

  • N22 process node (2012): industry transitioned to FinFET transistors
  • FinFETs are 3D structures with multiple fins side-by-side covered by gate
  • Three-gate FinFET up to 2x as effective as planar gate using same space
  • Intel first to implement FinFET with N22 Ivy Bridge CPUs (2012)
  • Samsung and TSMC followed later
  • TSMC skipped from N22 to N16 when implementing FinFETs
  • 3D structure interfered with multiple patterning techniques

Multiple Patterning Techniques

Double Patterning (Litho-Etch-Litho-Etch)

  • Started at N22 node process generation
  • Uses two lower density layout masks
  • Two exposures superimposed to create single finer image
  • Pitch split technique for dense layouts
  • Calibre multi-patterning tool handles design splitting automatically
  • Worked fine for N20, N16, N14 nodes

Triple Patterning Challenges

  • Required for N10 node when EUV still unavailable
  • Three masks of lower density layouts superimposed
  • Introduces immense new complexities in EDA tools, foundry design rules, chip designs
  • Computational problem: finding optimal way to split design into three masks
  • Square with 4 nodes: 2 double patterning options vs 18 triple patterning variations
  • 5 node structure: 30 variations
  • NP-complete problem (not solvable in polynomial time)
  • Chip designers required retraining
  • Economic impact: double patterning increased lithography costs 50% from N28
  • Triple patterning makes lithography module 3.85x higher cost than N28

N7 Node Implementation

  • Final node achievable with 193i technology
  • 70% node shrink from N10
  • TSMC market leader by this point
  • EUV close to ready but TSMC needed more time for comfort
  • N7 hit high volume manufacturing 2018 (Apple A12, Huawei Kirin 980)
  • Two versions: N7 (multiple patterning) and N7+ (EUV)
  • Later transitioned to N6 node

Self-Aligned Quadruple Patterning (SAQP)

  • N7 requires triple patterning + self-aligned quadruple patterning
  • SAQP is double application of self-aligned double patterning (SADP)
  • Process: template layer → lithography → CVD spacers → strip template → etch
  • Density doubled, then process repeated (quadruple patterning)
  • Creates high density parallel lines
  • Extremely restrictive design constraints
  • Fixed width parallel lines only
  • Less efficient designs
  • Extremely tight error margins

Intel's N10 Struggles

  • Intel's N14 roughly equivalent to TSMC's N10 in transistor density
  • N14 broke Intel's tick-tock strategy
  • Launched 2014, remained flagship until N10 ramped 2019
  • Intel's N10 roughly equivalent to TSMC's N7
  • Attempted N10 without EUV using extreme multiple patterning
  • Required quad, penta, hexa patterning for select features
  • Up to 6 exposures needed to draw single feature
  • Yield issues led to delayed market entry

EUV Breakthrough and Impact

  • EUV became commercially viable 2014-2016
  • ASML's dual shot laser pulse technique drastically improved power output
  • N7 with EUV: 30% better cost efficiencies despite $150M machine cost
  • 2020: TSMC celebrated 1 billion N7 chips (rare blog post)

Design Technology Co-Optimization

  • Modern node processes worked alongside chip designs
  • Everything optimized and nuanced: fin sizes, pitches
  • Some features shrunk, others not
  • Carefully curated design choices with trade-offs
  • Node specifications fuzzy between generations and foundries
  • "7nm" achievements vary significantly between companies
  • Headlines don't reflect actual technical complexity

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome