AI summary by TwinMind
Carbon Capture: All You Need To Know
Sabine Hossenfelder
11m 33s
Competition Overview
- Elon Musk announced carbon removal competition with $50M prize for winner
- Opens April 22nd, 2021
- Requirements: working prototype removing ≥1 ton CO2/day, carbon locked up ≥100 years
- Main metric: cost per tonne
Climate Change Context
- Fossil fuel burning released stored carbon dioxide suddenly into atmosphere
- CO2 stays in atmosphere for several thousand years naturally
- Climate reacts slowly - full impact not yet seen
- Even stopping all emissions today, climate would continue changing for decades/centuries
Current Emissions & Targets
- Global emissions: ~40 billion tons CO2/year currently
- Paris target: limit warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels
- Required reduction: down to 20 billion tons/year
- If continuing current emissions: need to remove 20 billion tons CO2/year
Natural Carbon Removal Methods
Tree Planting
- Trees natural carbon sink, release CO2 when die/rot/burn
- Need permanent increase in forest numbers
- To remove 20 billion tons/year: plant ~10 million km² new forests
- Area equivalent to entire United States
- More than entire remaining Amazon rainforest
- Cost: ~$100/tonne CO2
- Total cost for 20 billion tons: few trillion dollars/year
Ocean Fertilization
- Stimulate algae growth to absorb carbon
- Dead algae sink to ocean bottom, carbon stored for millions of years
- Efficiency unclear - no good data on algae sink rates vs consumption
- Unknown ecological effects
- Cost estimates: $2-450/tonne CO2
Human Carbon Storage
- Humans 18% carbon, natural carbon sink
- Single cremation releases ~250kg CO2
- Sea burials instead of cremations could save ~1 million tons CO2/year
- Not significant amount, likely expensive
Technological Carbon Removal Methods
Biochar Production
- Burn agricultural waste/wood without oxygen
- Produces biochar retaining ~50% carbon
- Stable for thousands of years, improves soil quality
- Limited by available agricultural waste
- Maximum potential: ~1.8 billion tons CO2/year
- Cost: $30-120/tonne CO2
Enhanced Weathering
- Create minerals that bind CO2 when contacting water
- Crush and distribute over large land areas
- Challenges: producing large mineral quantities, finding sufficient land
- American Weathering Project/Vesta claim: ~$10/tonne CO2
- Factor 10 less than tree planting
Direct Air Capture
- Push air through CO2-absorbing filters
- Companies exploring: Chevron, BHP, Occidental
- Carbon Engineering (backed by Bill Gates): pilot plant in British Columbia
- Each commercial plant equivalent to 40 million trees
- Remove 1 million tons CO2/year
- Cost estimate: $94-232/tonne CO2
- Total cost for 20 billion tons: $2-4 trillion/year (2.5-5% world GDP)
Seawater Carbon Extraction
- CO2 density in seawater ~125x higher than air
- Removed CO2 allows water to absorb new CO2 from air
- Current cost estimate: ~$50/tonne CO2 (half of air extraction)
- Challenge: requires heating water to ~70°C, high energy consumption
- Need more energy-efficient extraction methods
Carbon Capture and Storage
- Capture CO2 at production source before atmospheric release
- 26 commercial facilities operating, dozens more planned
- 2020 capture: ~40 million tons CO2
- Cost: $50-100/tonne CO2 (potentially down to $15/tonne in optimal cases)
- Challenge: requires huge amounts of water
Overall Assessment
- All methods expensive
- Competition opportunities:
- Make existing technologies cheaper/more efficient
- Develop entirely new approaches
- Plastic note: ~80% carbon, acts as carbon storage if not burned
- Great Pacific Garbage Patch = carbon storage (unpopular method)
