AI summary by TwinMind

Carbon Capture: All You Need To Know

Sabine Hossenfelder

11m 33s

Competition Overview

  • Elon Musk announced carbon removal competition with $50M prize for winner
  • Opens April 22nd, 2021
  • Requirements: working prototype removing ≥1 ton CO2/day, carbon locked up ≥100 years
  • Main metric: cost per tonne

Climate Change Context

  • Fossil fuel burning released stored carbon dioxide suddenly into atmosphere
  • CO2 stays in atmosphere for several thousand years naturally
  • Climate reacts slowly - full impact not yet seen
  • Even stopping all emissions today, climate would continue changing for decades/centuries

Current Emissions & Targets

  • Global emissions: ~40 billion tons CO2/year currently
  • Paris target: limit warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels
  • Required reduction: down to 20 billion tons/year
  • If continuing current emissions: need to remove 20 billion tons CO2/year

Natural Carbon Removal Methods

Tree Planting

  • Trees natural carbon sink, release CO2 when die/rot/burn
  • Need permanent increase in forest numbers
  • To remove 20 billion tons/year: plant ~10 million km² new forests
    • Area equivalent to entire United States
    • More than entire remaining Amazon rainforest
  • Cost: ~$100/tonne CO2
  • Total cost for 20 billion tons: few trillion dollars/year

Ocean Fertilization

  • Stimulate algae growth to absorb carbon
  • Dead algae sink to ocean bottom, carbon stored for millions of years
  • Efficiency unclear - no good data on algae sink rates vs consumption
  • Unknown ecological effects
  • Cost estimates: $2-450/tonne CO2

Human Carbon Storage

  • Humans 18% carbon, natural carbon sink
  • Single cremation releases ~250kg CO2
  • Sea burials instead of cremations could save ~1 million tons CO2/year
  • Not significant amount, likely expensive

Technological Carbon Removal Methods

Biochar Production

  • Burn agricultural waste/wood without oxygen
  • Produces biochar retaining ~50% carbon
  • Stable for thousands of years, improves soil quality
  • Limited by available agricultural waste
  • Maximum potential: ~1.8 billion tons CO2/year
  • Cost: $30-120/tonne CO2

Enhanced Weathering

  • Create minerals that bind CO2 when contacting water
  • Crush and distribute over large land areas
  • Challenges: producing large mineral quantities, finding sufficient land
  • American Weathering Project/Vesta claim: ~$10/tonne CO2
  • Factor 10 less than tree planting

Direct Air Capture

  • Push air through CO2-absorbing filters
  • Companies exploring: Chevron, BHP, Occidental
  • Carbon Engineering (backed by Bill Gates): pilot plant in British Columbia
    • Each commercial plant equivalent to 40 million trees
    • Remove 1 million tons CO2/year
    • Cost estimate: $94-232/tonne CO2
  • Total cost for 20 billion tons: $2-4 trillion/year (2.5-5% world GDP)

Seawater Carbon Extraction

  • CO2 density in seawater ~125x higher than air
  • Removed CO2 allows water to absorb new CO2 from air
  • Current cost estimate: ~$50/tonne CO2 (half of air extraction)
  • Challenge: requires heating water to ~70°C, high energy consumption
  • Need more energy-efficient extraction methods

Carbon Capture and Storage

  • Capture CO2 at production source before atmospheric release
  • 26 commercial facilities operating, dozens more planned
  • 2020 capture: ~40 million tons CO2
  • Cost: $50-100/tonne CO2 (potentially down to $15/tonne in optimal cases)
  • Challenge: requires huge amounts of water

Overall Assessment

  • All methods expensive
  • Competition opportunities:
    • Make existing technologies cheaper/more efficient
    • Develop entirely new approaches
  • Plastic note: ~80% carbon, acts as carbon storage if not burned
    • Great Pacific Garbage Patch = carbon storage (unpopular method)

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome