AI summary by TwinMind
Cat Becomes Well-Cited Scholar With New Scam Method
Sabine Hossenfelder
8m 5s
Discovery of Citation Buying Services
- Nick Wine (fluid mechanics engineer, Cambridge) discovers Facebook ad: "we help you to boost your citations"
- Ad includes before/after Google Scholar screenshots showing citation increases of several hundred
- Marketed as "academic facelift" - don't miss opportunity
- Wine shares finding with Ree Rickards (PhD student in metascience)
Investigation into Citation Manipulation Sources
- Paper Mills: Industry producing nonsense papers, selling authorships for few thousand dollars each
- Papers placed in scam journals
- Academic gibberish indistinguishable from real content to most people
- Natural extension: selling citations alongside fake papers
- Research Gate Exploitation: Academic platform for paper sharing
- Users sign up with institutional emails, upload papers
- Circumvents copyright issues with academic publishers
- Papers indexed by Google Scholar due to institutional affiliations
- Citation boost method: upload nonsense papers with custom citations → Google Scholar indexes → instant well-cited researcher status
Fake Paper Characteristics
- Nonsense content with fake citations
- Authored by historical figures (Pythagoras, Kogo mentioned)
- Uploaded to Research Gate for Google Scholar indexing
Cat Citation Experiment
- Researchers create Google Scholar profile for "Larry Rickardsson" (a cat)
- Computer generates gibberish papers with cat as author
- Creates additional papers citing cat's work
- Results after 2 weeks:
- 12 papers
- 132 citations
- H-index of 11
Google Scholar's Broader Issues
- Counts citations from blog posts, conference posters
- Infamous case: lunch menus listed as scientific papers
- Authors: "CS Salad," "B Noodles," "R Beans"
- Some lunch menus have citations
Implications and Concerns
- Limited immediate impact: Won't fool hiring committees or grant reviewers
- Two major worries:
- Public unfamiliarity with citation system limitations - people may fall for fake credentials
- Tip of iceberg - more elaborate scams likely exist
Systemic Academic Problems
- Citation gaming as normal procedure: Particle physicists citing each other to boost counts (hundreds of points in months)
- Bulk citation groups exist across research areas
- Citations poor measure of academic achievement but still used
- Consequences: Scientific publishing flooded with low-quality work
- Increasingly difficult to find valuable research
Current Solutions and New Problems
- Personal references: Only reliable method for finding quality work
- Researchers share useful papers through personal networks
- New problem: Academic success depends on personal connections
- Great papers remain unknown due to lack of connections
- Future concern: Academia becoming more exclusive/elitist to combat publishing problems
- Risk of academia eventually killing itself
Brilliant.org Sponsorship
- Interactive visualizations and follow-up questions
- Covers science, computer science, mathematics
- Topics: scientific thinking to differential equations, large language models
- Free trial via brilliant.org/Saina
- 30-day trial, 20% off annual premium subscription
- Includes quantum mechanics course covering wave functions, superposition, entanglement, interference, uncertainty principle, Bell's theorem
