AI summary by TwinMind
CERN Looks for Origins of Quantum Randomness
Sabine Hossenfelder
6m 47s
ATLAS Collaboration Quantum Entanglement Test at LHC
- ATLAS collaboration at CERN tested quantum entanglement using particle collision data
- Tested pairs of top quark and anti-top quark created in proton collisions
- Top quarks chosen as candidates because:
- Heavy and short-lived particles
- Short lifetime prevents correlations from being washed out
- Correlations passed to decay products
- Measured spin correlations between top quark pairs
- Reconstructed original particle spin values from decay products detected
- Quantified correlation using parameter D
- D < -1/3 indicates true quantum entanglement
- Results confirmed quantum entanglement as expected
Paradox: Nonsense vs Not Nonsense
- Test appears "nonsense" because:
- Quantum entanglement tested thousands of times before
- Nobel Prize already awarded for confirming entanglement reality
- Results predictably confirmed quantum physics
- Test is "not nonsense" because:
- No previous experiments conducted at such high energies
- High-energy tests could reveal origin of quantum randomness
- Large Hadron Collider reaches unprecedented energy levels
Gerard 't Hooft's Hidden Variable Theory
- Gerard 't Hooft: Nobel Prize winner (1999) with Martinus Veltman
- Awarded for contributions to development of Standard Model
- Proposes explanation for quantum mechanical randomness:
- Randomness originates from information hidden at very short distances
- Hidden variables exist in quantum systems
- High energies needed to probe short distances where hidden variables operate
- Theory belongs to "super deterministic" framework
Scientific Community Reception
- Particle physicists generally not excited about testing quantum foundations
- Most consider 't Hooft's ideas "crazy"
- Problem stems from disciplinary boundaries:
- 't Hooft is particle physicist, not quantum foundations specialist
- Doesn't speak quantum foundations "language"
- Quantum foundations people don't understand particle physics approach
- Particle physicists dismiss quantum foundations as irrelevant
- Current theories assume "decoupling of scales"
- Short-distance phenomena don't affect long-distance behavior
- Contradicts chaotic systems behavior (butterfly effect)
Potential Breakthrough Concerns
- Possibility CERN sitting on breakthrough discovery without knowing
- Risk of missing hidden variable evidence due to:
- Wrong data analysis approaches
- Potentially discarded relevant data
- High-energy experiments offer better chances to find hidden variables
- Short distances accessible only through high-energy collisions
