AI summary by TwinMind

China's 7nm Chips: SMIC N+2

Asianometry

13m 39s

SMIC's N+2 Node Technical Overview

  • Chinese semiconductor national champion SMIC started producing chips with 7nm process node (N+2)
  • N+2 node descendant of N+1 process first taped out October 2020
  • Uses DUV immersion lithography with multi-patterning (pre-EUV technology)
  • N+2 capable of using EUV but US export ban blocks ASML equipment access
  • Semi-analysis via Tech Insights: N+2 99% similar to TSMC's N7 node
  • Physical measurements of transistors (FinFETs) and placements nearly identical to TSMC N7

Process Node Context and Meaning

  • "Seven nanometers" is marketing term, not physical dimension
  • Indicates 70% improvement over previous generation (10nm → 7nm → 14nm progression)
  • TSMC calls their version "N7" to avoid controversy
  • Process node numbers are marketing devices for power/performance/area improvements

Competitive Positioning and Timeline

  • TSMC first shipped N7 chips high volume in 2018
  • N7 equivalent node puts SMIC 4-6 years behind leading edge
  • N+2 one of most advanced processes available by any foundry to customers
  • Without EUV, questionable if economically competitive in open market

Manufacturing Challenges and Capabilities

  • 193nm immersion + multi-patterning can fab even N5 equivalent chips (per Dr. Burn Lin, TSMC R&D director, January 2022)
  • Key issue: yield in meaningful quantities, not just making few wafers
  • Samsung struggles with advanced node yields despite having nodes
  • Intel famously struggled 10nm → 7nm equivalent transition without EUV
  • TSMC ramped N7 without reported trouble; N+2 expected to follow similar yield optimization curve

Market Dynamics and Limitations

  • Market changed since 2018 - competition rougher
  • Foundry with EUV has economic advantages over DUV-only
  • N7 equivalent with only multi-patterning has manufacturing limitations
  • Places serious design restrictions on chip designers
  • TSMC's N6 (N7 evolution with EUV) offers better performance

Trade Secret and Legal Concerns

  • N+2 close similarity to TSMC N7 likely intrudes on trade secrets
  • 2002 and 2006: TSMC successfully sued SMIC in US courts for product import bans
  • TSMC could attempt again, potentially removing N+2 export viability
  • Would limit N+2 to domestic Chinese products and friendly country exports
  • SMIC cares about export capability (highlighted in latest earnings call) but likely no longer depends on it

Chinese Market Opportunities

  • Chinese chip design industry much more sophisticated since mid-2000s TSMC lawsuit
  • Chinese electronics industry greatly matured
  • HiSilicon (Huawei's chip design arm) prime candidate for N+2 usage
    • Once China's biggest semiconductor company
    • Could use N+2 for high-performing mobile processors and server chips
    • Previously TSMC flagship customer alongside Apple
    • Fabbed Kirin 980, 985, 990 series chips on N7
  • HiSilicon + SMIC partnership could bring serious volume for foundry scaling
  • High production volumes essential for yield optimization

Leadership and Strategic Direction

  • SMIC co-CEO Liang Mong Song (TSMC alumni) joined 2017 from Samsung
  • Known for technical brilliance, difficult personality, dogged chase for leading edge
  • Brought 200-person R&D team of Taiwanese and Koreans
  • Reoriented SMIC from boring second-source manufacturer to leading edge monster
  • Company should continue pushing toward leading edge while Liang remains co-CEO

Export Control and Geopolitical Implications

  • US government pushing Netherlands (ASML) and Japan (Nikon) to prevent DUV immersion lithography exports to China
  • Timing of push and N+2 shipment likely not coincidental
  • US long blocked newest EUV machines to China
  • Expanding block to immersion lithography represents another step forward
  • Immersion machines use water/fluids to improve resolution of 193nm ARF laser technology
  • Only two suppliers: ASML and Nikon
  • Dry ARF machines can be modified to immersion (less than 5 years but substantial technical effort)
  • Western industry transitioned dry → immersion in 2-3 years
  • N7 equivalent requires more sophisticated immersion technologies

Technology Development Timeline and Impact

  • Japan and Netherlands haven't decided on ban as of writing
  • Chinese government responded with claims of unfairness and foul play
  • Export ban of 193nm immersion (without dry ARF ban) would add 4-6 years to SMIC's leading edge march
  • Ban likely to stimulate substantial investment in Chinese-made lithography
    • First: equipment to maintain existing immersion equipment
    • Second: facilitate dry-to-immersion transition
  • Gap with ASML/Nikon greater but not insurmountable (several years)

Strategic Assessment and Historical Context

  • Legitimate 7nm node at high volume/good yield is triumph for China's advanced manufacturing
  • Only three other companies achieved this level of scale and sophistication
  • Any successful immersion ban wouldn't be permanently damaging blow
  • Can only maintain and perhaps slightly expand Sino-American semiconductor gap
  • Administration values those few years highly
  • Reference to American response to Japanese semiconductor challenge 30+ years ago
  • Government intervention can only buy time - industry must build new markets, improve manufacturing, adopt innovative suppliers

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome