AI summary by TwinMind
China's 7nm Semiconductor Breakthrough
Asianometry
14m 10s
Huawei Mate 60 Pro Launch & Kirin 9000s Chip
- Late August 2023: Huawei quietly launched Mate 60 Pro in online store
- Features Kirin 9000s - 7nm class chip, most likely manufactured by SMIC
- 107 square millimeter die, 2% larger than previous Kirin 9000/9000e chips
- Previous chips briefly produced using TSMC's 5nm process until US sanctions ended association
- Current 7nm chip is 5-6 years behind leading edge (TSMC shipping 3nm throughout 2023)
Technical Specifications & Performance
- Supports 5G connectivity but Huawei hiding functionality
- Press releases don't mention 5G support
- Phone OS reports 4G on surface
- Speculation about Qualcomm patent concerns
- CPU core: customization on top of ARM IP
- GPU: new custom design by Huawei/HiSilicon
- Causes texture errors in games like Genshin Impact (fixable)
- Memory: SK Hynix (only non-Chinese component)
Manufacturing & Yield Analysis
- Dylan Patel (SemiAnalysis): SMIC's early yields likely higher than expected
- Yields start low but ramp up as fab improves
- TSMC scaled N7's yield enough for iPhone launch - same principle for SMIC
- More phones sold = faster yield improvement
- Node appears "really, really good"
SMIC N+2 Process Development Timeline
- First heard of SMIC N+2 process July 2022
- Initially used for Bitcoin miners (repetitive structures good for node improvement)
- Phone SOC much more complicated to produce
- Tremendous progress by CEO Liang Mong Song and SMIC in ~1 year
- Nikkei Asia mentioned SMIC-Huawei 5G chip collaboration early previous month
Future Roadmap & Capabilities
- Dr. Byrne Lin (legendary TSMC R&D director, father of 193nm immersion lithography) said January 2022:
- SMIC can fab 5nm class chips with only multi-patterning
- 193nm immersion lithography key technology
- 1-2 decades old but still best lithography machines
- Matter more than EUV
- US banned EUV exports but perhaps "red herring"
- 193nm immersion machines (TwinScan NXT 2000+) still do 70-80% litho work for Intel/TSMC/Samsung latest nodes
- Netherlands/Japan export restrictions joined US June 30, 2023
- ASML trying to sell all DUV immersion machines before year end
- SMIC has plenty machines to ramp 7nm production and move to 5nm
- Expect 5nm class Huawei chip in 1-2 years
Domestic Ecosystem Development
- Phone built within ecosystem of domestic Chinese suppliers
- Bloomberg noted many domestic suppliers:
- RF front-end module
- Satellite communications modem for satellite calls feature
- Exception: SK Hynix memory
- Complete self-contained PRC ecosystem for domestic electronics
- Can produce: smartphone SOCs, CPUs, Edge AI NPUs, GPUs, AI accelerators
Market Impact & Competition
- Ming-Chi Kuo: Qualcomm sells tens of millions chips for Huawei phones
- These sales likely replaced by Kirin 9000s
- Every non-Chinese semiconductor maker and Apple will lose business
- SMIC busy fulfilling Huawei orders next year
- Should immediately seek new N+2 customers in high-powered computing
- Expect Chinese 7nm AI accelerator in 1-2 years (Chinese version of Nvidia A100/Google TPU)
- Potential designers: ByteDance, Baidu, Alibaba Cloud, Tencent
Strategic Recommendations
For China/SMIC:
- Scale critical - distribute phone widely globally
- Target Europeans, Australians, Southeast Asians, Latin Americans
- Challenge: Huawei phones don't ship with Google products
- Huawei doing influencer marketing for Google products installation
- Every export sale strengthens SMIC (more chips = higher yield = faster profitability = quicker 5nm move)
- Review/replicate advanced packaging technology stack
- Phone chips emphasize thinness/heat (chip scale packaging)
- AI requires data bandwidth (chiplets, 2.5D die stacking)
- Shore up domestic semiconductor manufacturing equipment ecosystem
- Replace ASML, Applied Materials, Tokyo Electron, Lam Research, metrology companies
- Foreign equipment probably has kill switches
US Government Response Analysis (Jordan Schneider)
- October 7th restrictions defined advanced semiconductors as logic ICs at 16-14nm or below
- US government intelligence indicates Chinese advanced logic chip manufacturing has significant regional military balance implications
- Current trajectory suggests US might try harder to stop Chinese progress
- Need better understanding of semiconductor equipment still reaching SMIC
- SMIC depends on foreign equipment - domestic suppliers years behind
- Equipment companies (Applied, Lam, Tokyo Electron, KLA) can sell most tools
- Tools for 7nm/5nm can plausibly be used in 28nm
- Tools sold to SMIC ostensibly for lagging edge but repurposed for advanced chips
- Recommendations:
- Tighter export controls targeting repurposed tools
- Target argon fluoride immersion lithography, mask, CMP equipment
- Less liberal licensing for entity list firms like SMIC
- Cooperation with Japan, Netherlands, Germany allies
Historical Parallel & Implications
- 1986: Samsung shocked Japan with 1 megabit DRAM, closed Korean-Japanese gap from 5 years to 1 year
- 1988: Samsung 4 megabit chip achieved parity with Japanese
- Japan semiconductor dominance crumbled thereafter
- Kirin 9000s similar visible mark on technology history
- Shock ripples far beyond semiconductor neighborhood
- PRC taking Korean approach to semiconductor manufacturing
- Worked for South Korea, working for China
