AI summary by TwinMind
China’s ASML is Years and Years Behind
Asianometry
18m 11s
Company Background & History
- Shanghai Micro Electronics Equipment (SMEE) founded March 2002 as China's ambitious project to replace ASML
- Received special focus due to recent export bans to China
- Located in Shanghai Zhangjiang High Tech Park, Putong District
- Neighbors include SMIC, Gray Semiconductor, Spreadtrum
- Founding general manager/chairman: Ha Rong Ming
- Worked 7am-10pm daily, guaranteed Saturdays no rest, Sundays not guaranteed for 10+ years
Early Chinese Lithography Development (1977-2002)
- 1977: China's first lithography machine GK3 created
- 1979: Evolved to JKG3 - first domestic machine for large-scale commercial production
- 1980: GK4 prototype - contact lithography machine for 75mm wafers
- Contact lithography: photo mask in direct contact with photoresist coated substrate
- High defect rates, US invented/commercialized in 1950s
- China 2 decades behind at this point
- 1981: Institute of Semiconductors developed 2 proximity aligner prototypes
- 1985: 45th Institute of Ministry of Mechanical & Electrical Engineering developed stepper
- Inspired by 4800 DSW made by US-based GCA
- Printed designs using 436 nanometer G line
- 2000: China began research on argon fluoride lasers at 193 nanometer wavelength
- West began shipping such devices in 1990
- Large technology gap remained
Government Support & Strategic Positioning
- China's 12th Five-Year Plan (2011-2015) included 16 major national special projects
- Lithography ranked 2nd highest - called "Zero Two Special Project"
- Goals:
- Develop manufacturing equipment for 22-45 nanometer processed chips
- Forward research on 14-22 nanometer processes
- Work on 65-90 nanometer special processes
- Capture at least 10% of domestic lithography market
- Attempt to open international market
- SMEE deemed national champion for achieving these goals
Ownership & Funding
- Single biggest owner: Shanghai SASAC (32% shares) - commission overseeing city's corporate assets
- Other private shareholders including VCs
- Extensive support from Chinese local and central governments
- As of 2019: Filed for 3,000+ patents, received 1,600
- Nearly 700 patents in foreign countries
Strategic Market Approach
- Faced import restrictions from start (high-level optics from Carl Zeiss Germany)
- Targeted less competitive lithography market segments:
- Advanced packaging processes
- Back-end lithography (less intense competition, less strict requirements)
- Advanced packaging: processes for placing chip in protective casing, connecting to outside world
- Strategy: cut teeth in back-end lithography, work up to front-end where "big boys play"
Current Market Position & Products
- Back-end lithography: 80% domestic market share, 40% global market share
- 2019: Shipped 50+ units
- Major back-end customers: Chiang Jang Electric Group, Taiwan-based ASE Group, Tongfu Microelectronics
- Expanded into niche semiconductor products: power devices, MEMS, LEDs
- Front-end development targeting Yangtze Memory and SMIC (more likely Yangtze since SMIC locked with ASML)
Technical Capabilities & Limitations
- Built on ASML model: final system integrator for lithography tools
- Core success factors: high precision optics, light source, high precision mechanics, software
- Current systems (August 2021): 90nm, 110nm, 280nm processes
- Specialized systems for back-end lithography, LED, MEMS, power devices
- Most advanced: SSA 600-20 scanner for front-end manufacturing at 90nm node using argon fluoride laser
- Prototype SSA 600-10 (2011): 22mm x 32mm field size, 50 wafers/hour
- Comparable Canon/Nikon machines: up to 5x that throughput
- Recent sales still in outdated I-line lithography machines
Supply Chain Dependencies
- Light source supplier: Beijing RS Laser Opto Electronics Technology (underpowered vs ASML)
- Optics suppliers: Chang Chun Optotech (no longer associated), Beijing Guo Wang Technology
- Beijing Guo Wang building optics manufacturing factory
- Critical imports still required:
- Photo masks (Japanese companies: Topan Printing, Dai Nippon Printing)
- Ball bearings from Sweden
- Valves from France
- Grading alignment systems from US
- Chinese photo mask company: Jiangsu Nata Opto Electronic Material Company (successfully works in ASML immersion system)
Future Pipeline & Challenges
- Argon fluoride immersion (ArFi) system prototype for 28nm process node
- 28nm node first shipped ~2011, fits China's 10-year lag pattern
- Goal: deliver commercial-ready 28nm ArFi machines 2021-2022
- Likely to miss deadline due to:
- Beijing Guowang foundry construction not completed until September
- Integration lag suggests 2024 ship date might be ambitious
- Product not expected to be commercially competitive
Misleading Headlines Example
- November 2018: Institute of Opto Electronics Technology announced 22nm "super resolution" lithography tool
- CCTV claimed multi-patterning could achieve sub-10nm processes
- Reality: not commercially ready, low accuracy, few square millimeters field of view
- Comparison: ASML TwinScan NXT 1970Ci (38nm node): 858 square millimeters field of view (26x33mm), 250+ wafers/hour
Human Resources & Compensation Gap
- Entry-level college graduates: ~$45,000 USD/year
- PhDs: ~$90,000 USD/year (twice college graduate salary)
- SMEE's average PhD salary ≈ ASML's company-wide average salary
- ASML higher-end staff software engineers: nearly $200,000 USD/year
- Significant pay gap even considering Shanghai vs Netherlands cost differences
- ASML benefits: share purchase plan, pension, commuting allowance, 40 days paid leave, 8% holiday allowance
- SMEE adopted Huawei working practices:
- Long working hours
- Political intervention
- Tough annual assessments
- Jack Welch style bottom 5-10% layoffs annually
Industry Assessment & Reality Check
- Chinese press calls photolithography "Mount Everest of intelligent manufacturing industry"
- Common rhetoric: "As ancient civilization with 5,000 years history, nothing can't be done by Chinese"
- Reality: SMEE at least 20 years behind ASML in commercial-ready upper-class lithography
- Immersion lithography nascent, EUV even farther away
- Chinese sources acknowledge this reality
- Counterproductive rah-rah claims lead to pessimism when deadlines missed
Positive Developments
- Progress in back-end lithography and LED lithography heartening
- China gaining market share in display industry
- Few Chinese companies built strong track record in certain semiconductor equipment areas
- One company acquired TSMC as client
Future Prospects
- Considering IPO at $5-10 billion valuation (no official confirmation)
- Would release new information in prospectus
- Semiconductor production equipment ecosystem not "dead on arrival"
- Human capital critical in semiconductor manufacturing industry
- Right person can bring immense value to competitive edge
- High precision optics/mechanics PhDs don't "grow on trees"
