AI summary by TwinMind

China’s ASML is Years and Years Behind

Asianometry

18m 11s

Company Background & History

  • Shanghai Micro Electronics Equipment (SMEE) founded March 2002 as China's ambitious project to replace ASML
  • Received special focus due to recent export bans to China
  • Located in Shanghai Zhangjiang High Tech Park, Putong District
  • Neighbors include SMIC, Gray Semiconductor, Spreadtrum
  • Founding general manager/chairman: Ha Rong Ming
    • Worked 7am-10pm daily, guaranteed Saturdays no rest, Sundays not guaranteed for 10+ years

Early Chinese Lithography Development (1977-2002)

  • 1977: China's first lithography machine GK3 created
  • 1979: Evolved to JKG3 - first domestic machine for large-scale commercial production
  • 1980: GK4 prototype - contact lithography machine for 75mm wafers
    • Contact lithography: photo mask in direct contact with photoresist coated substrate
    • High defect rates, US invented/commercialized in 1950s
    • China 2 decades behind at this point
  • 1981: Institute of Semiconductors developed 2 proximity aligner prototypes
  • 1985: 45th Institute of Ministry of Mechanical & Electrical Engineering developed stepper
    • Inspired by 4800 DSW made by US-based GCA
    • Printed designs using 436 nanometer G line
  • 2000: China began research on argon fluoride lasers at 193 nanometer wavelength
    • West began shipping such devices in 1990
    • Large technology gap remained

Government Support & Strategic Positioning

  • China's 12th Five-Year Plan (2011-2015) included 16 major national special projects
  • Lithography ranked 2nd highest - called "Zero Two Special Project"
  • Goals:
    • Develop manufacturing equipment for 22-45 nanometer processed chips
    • Forward research on 14-22 nanometer processes
    • Work on 65-90 nanometer special processes
    • Capture at least 10% of domestic lithography market
    • Attempt to open international market
  • SMEE deemed national champion for achieving these goals

Ownership & Funding

  • Single biggest owner: Shanghai SASAC (32% shares) - commission overseeing city's corporate assets
  • Other private shareholders including VCs
  • Extensive support from Chinese local and central governments
  • As of 2019: Filed for 3,000+ patents, received 1,600
    • Nearly 700 patents in foreign countries

Strategic Market Approach

  • Faced import restrictions from start (high-level optics from Carl Zeiss Germany)
  • Targeted less competitive lithography market segments:
    • Advanced packaging processes
    • Back-end lithography (less intense competition, less strict requirements)
  • Advanced packaging: processes for placing chip in protective casing, connecting to outside world
  • Strategy: cut teeth in back-end lithography, work up to front-end where "big boys play"

Current Market Position & Products

  • Back-end lithography: 80% domestic market share, 40% global market share
  • 2019: Shipped 50+ units
  • Major back-end customers: Chiang Jang Electric Group, Taiwan-based ASE Group, Tongfu Microelectronics
  • Expanded into niche semiconductor products: power devices, MEMS, LEDs
  • Front-end development targeting Yangtze Memory and SMIC (more likely Yangtze since SMIC locked with ASML)

Technical Capabilities & Limitations

  • Built on ASML model: final system integrator for lithography tools
  • Core success factors: high precision optics, light source, high precision mechanics, software
  • Current systems (August 2021): 90nm, 110nm, 280nm processes
  • Specialized systems for back-end lithography, LED, MEMS, power devices
  • Most advanced: SSA 600-20 scanner for front-end manufacturing at 90nm node using argon fluoride laser
  • Prototype SSA 600-10 (2011): 22mm x 32mm field size, 50 wafers/hour
    • Comparable Canon/Nikon machines: up to 5x that throughput
  • Recent sales still in outdated I-line lithography machines

Supply Chain Dependencies

  • Light source supplier: Beijing RS Laser Opto Electronics Technology (underpowered vs ASML)
  • Optics suppliers: Chang Chun Optotech (no longer associated), Beijing Guo Wang Technology
  • Beijing Guo Wang building optics manufacturing factory
  • Critical imports still required:
    • Photo masks (Japanese companies: Topan Printing, Dai Nippon Printing)
    • Ball bearings from Sweden
    • Valves from France
    • Grading alignment systems from US
  • Chinese photo mask company: Jiangsu Nata Opto Electronic Material Company (successfully works in ASML immersion system)

Future Pipeline & Challenges

  • Argon fluoride immersion (ArFi) system prototype for 28nm process node
  • 28nm node first shipped ~2011, fits China's 10-year lag pattern
  • Goal: deliver commercial-ready 28nm ArFi machines 2021-2022
  • Likely to miss deadline due to:
    • Beijing Guowang foundry construction not completed until September
    • Integration lag suggests 2024 ship date might be ambitious
    • Product not expected to be commercially competitive

Misleading Headlines Example

  • November 2018: Institute of Opto Electronics Technology announced 22nm "super resolution" lithography tool
  • CCTV claimed multi-patterning could achieve sub-10nm processes
  • Reality: not commercially ready, low accuracy, few square millimeters field of view
  • Comparison: ASML TwinScan NXT 1970Ci (38nm node): 858 square millimeters field of view (26x33mm), 250+ wafers/hour

Human Resources & Compensation Gap

  • Entry-level college graduates: ~$45,000 USD/year
  • PhDs: ~$90,000 USD/year (twice college graduate salary)
  • SMEE's average PhD salary ≈ ASML's company-wide average salary
  • ASML higher-end staff software engineers: nearly $200,000 USD/year
  • Significant pay gap even considering Shanghai vs Netherlands cost differences
  • ASML benefits: share purchase plan, pension, commuting allowance, 40 days paid leave, 8% holiday allowance
  • SMEE adopted Huawei working practices:
    • Long working hours
    • Political intervention
    • Tough annual assessments
    • Jack Welch style bottom 5-10% layoffs annually

Industry Assessment & Reality Check

  • Chinese press calls photolithography "Mount Everest of intelligent manufacturing industry"
  • Common rhetoric: "As ancient civilization with 5,000 years history, nothing can't be done by Chinese"
  • Reality: SMEE at least 20 years behind ASML in commercial-ready upper-class lithography
  • Immersion lithography nascent, EUV even farther away
  • Chinese sources acknowledge this reality
  • Counterproductive rah-rah claims lead to pessimism when deadlines missed

Positive Developments

  • Progress in back-end lithography and LED lithography heartening
  • China gaining market share in display industry
  • Few Chinese companies built strong track record in certain semiconductor equipment areas
  • One company acquired TSMC as client

Future Prospects

  • Considering IPO at $5-10 billion valuation (no official confirmation)
  • Would release new information in prospectus
  • Semiconductor production equipment ecosystem not "dead on arrival"
  • Human capital critical in semiconductor manufacturing industry
  • Right person can bring immense value to competitive edge
  • High precision optics/mechanics PhDs don't "grow on trees"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome