AI summary by TwinMind

China's Gallium & Germanium Export Controls

Asianometry

14m 33s

China's Export Control Announcement

  • China announced unspecified export controls on 36 metals and minerals
  • Response to Netherlands placing export curbs on chip production technologies (lithography)
  • Two minerals making headlines: gallium and germanium
  • Not rare earths but play vital roles in world technology

Germanium Overview and Properties

  • Metalloid with metalish properties (like boron, arsenic, silicon)
  • China Daily claims germanium rarer than gold - disputed
  • Germanium exists 1.8-1.4 parts per million in Earth's crust
  • Gold exists 0.0011-0.0031 parts per million
  • Pure germanium metal: ~$1,500/kg
  • Germanium oxides: ~$700/kg
  • Gold: ~$61,700/kg

Germanium Supply Chain and Production

  • Not economically viable when mined alone
  • Found in trace amounts in zinc, copper, lead ores
  • 60% of world supply from zinc refineries
  • 20% from coal fly ash from power plants
  • 60% of US germanium production is recycled
  • Recycling sources include decommissioned tanks

Global Production (2012-2016)

  • China: 80% of world supply
  • Finland: 10%
  • Russia: 5%
  • US and Japan: 2% each
  • US imports >50% of germanium supply, majority from China
  • Canada has 2 refinement factories in British Columbia (Teck)

Germanium Applications

End User Markets Distribution

  • Infrared systems: 30%
  • Fiber optics: 20%
  • Polymer catalysts: 20%
  • Solar panels and smaller applications: remaining 30%

Specific Use Cases

  • Infrared systems: optical window and lens material
    • Substitutes: zinc selenide, zinc sulfide, germanium glass (less effective)
  • Fiber optics: germanium oxides essential (largest US use case - 40% demand)
    • Added to silicon glass as dopants to minimize signal loss
    • 5G rollout driving demand (Verizon bought 12.4 million miles fiber 2018-2020)
    • No industrially competitive replacements
  • Polymer catalysts: PET plastic bottle production
    • Prevents discoloration
    • Globally largest use case for germanium
  • Solar panels: germanium alloy substrate in high-efficiency panels
    • More expensive than silicon-based panels
    • Suited for satellites
  • Electronics: small applications including PET scanner scintillator crystals (bismuth germanium oxide/BGO)

Germanium Market Dynamics

  • 2018 explosion at Teck refinery caused 35% price rise ($1,250 to $1,800/kg)
  • Market considered oversupplied despite shortage
  • Total US germanium consumption value (2022): $39 million
  • Germanium <2% of Teck's revenue despite being world leading supplier
  • Market very small globally

Gallium Overview and Properties

  • Post-transition metal (related to indium, tin, aluminum)
  • Silvery blue, soft metal
  • Liquid at room temperature (melts in hand)
  • 18-19 parts per million in Earth's crust
  • Rarer than copper, cerium, lithium
  • More common than germanium, lead, uranium, mercury
  • Not toxic but causes throat irritation, vomiting

Gallium Supply Chain

  • Found in trace amounts in bauxite, zinc ores, coals
  • Not commercially viable alone - obtained as byproduct
  • 90% from Bayer liquor (aluminum extraction from bauxite)
  • Processing methods: solvent extraction, ion exchange, fractional precipitation
  • Also extracted from burnt coal ash

Market Segments

  • Low quality: 99.99% pure, ~$100/kg
  • High quality wafers: 6-7 nines purity, ~$500/kg

Global Production

  • China: 90% market share (93% low quality market)
  • China produces 750,000 kg low quality gallium annually
  • High quality wafers produced in China, Japan, Canada, US
  • US imports all gallium (mostly from China, also France/Japan)
  • Japan biggest consumer: 40% of world production
  • Japanese companies: Mitsubishi Chemical, Psyox, Sumitomo Electric
  • 75% of Japan's raw gallium from China

Gallium Applications

US Market Distribution (2018)

  • Integrated circuits: 73% (10,800 kg of 15,000 kg total)
  • Optoelectronics (LEDs, solar panels): distant second

Key Compounds and Applications

  • Gallium arsenide: radiation resistant
    • Radio frequency applications
    • Power amplifiers for mobile phones
    • Telecom communication units
    • $9 billion market consuming 33-35% of gallium arsenide
  • Gallium nitride: wide bandgap semiconductor
    • Power electronics/chargers
    • Higher temperature and voltage tolerance than silicon
    • Better for small/medium items vs large-scale systems
    • Medical equipment, consumer electronics

Optoelectronics Applications

  • LEDs in screens (notebooks, smartphones, TVs)
  • Compounds used: aluminum gallium indium phosphide, indium gallium nitride, gallium arsenide, gallium arsenide phosphide, gallium nitride
  • Gallium nitride critical for blue LEDs
  • Laser diodes for commercial lidar systems
  • 3D sensing diodes (gallium arsenide) in iPhone 10+ for Face ID
  • Potential substitute: indium phosphide (but indium also rare)

Substitution Challenges

  • No good substitutes for gallium in LED applications
  • OLEDs can do similar jobs (organic compounds) but not always feasible
  • Export controls expected to significantly impact optoelectronic supply chain

Market Assessment and Strategic Implications

  • Export controls more PR move than economically impactful
  • Controls may not become outright export bans
  • If bans occur: delayed shipments, higher but not crazy prices
  • Gallium/germanium different from rare earths - other production sources exist
  • Production can restart when prices rise sufficiently
  • Supply diversified wherever aluminum made or coal burned
  • China's statement: raw materials as important to US silicon industry as lithography machines
  • Full ban on all controlled minerals simultaneously could have unpredictable outcomes

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome