AI summary by TwinMind
Chinese Money Laundering and Global Real Estate
Asianometry
14m 15s
Money Laundering Definition and Chinese Context
- Money laundering: criminals making illegally gained funds appear legitimate (dirty to clean money)
- Associated with fraud, human trafficking, drug money where profit-making criminal activity exists
- 2008 People's Bank of China report: 44% of dirty money from management fraud or financial fraud
- Contrasts with other countries where dirty money largely from drugs/human trafficking
- Chinese government: largest source of laundered funds tied to "politically exposed persons" (PEPs)
- Senior politicians/officials entrusted with state-owned or private resources
- Moving assets out of China for personal gain
Case Studies of Chinese Money Laundering
- Deputy mayor example: took $30 million in bribes, used to purchase NY real estate through shell companies
- Only caught when trying to evict tenant
- High-level managers embezzling from companies
- Chinese beer company exec fled to US after stealing millions
- Some money went into $2 million Miami condo
- "Naked official" concept: officials resettle family outside China ostensibly for education
Detailed Case: Dio Changming (Bank of Communications)
- Regional president for China's Bank of Communications (BoCom), mainland's 5th largest bank
- Two businessmen fraudulently borrowed 9 billion RMB ($1.4 billion USD) from BoCom's Guangdong branch
- Loan documents appeared legitimate but receiving companies didn't exist
- Financial statements falsified
- Dio directed two underlings to make these loans
- Fled country in 2007 after catching wind of Ministry of Finance probe
- Remains at large as one of China's most wanted criminals
- Family background:
- Moved wife and two kids to US in 1998 while rising through China's financial industry
- Family lived well in US with real estate portfolio valued over $10 million
- Source of money unclear according to NY Times
- 2018 development: family (mother and two kids) visited China to see dying grandparent
- Found themselves unable to leave, held hostage to convince father to surrender
Global Real Estate Targeting
- Fraudsters/corporate criminals target countries without extradition agreements with China
- Common locales: Canada, Australia, UK, US
- China biggest international buyer of American real estate
- Preference for California, New York, Michigan
- Commonly targeted cities: San Francisco, NYC, London
Why Real Estate Ideal for Money Laundering
- Transactions absorb huge amounts of money yet remain extremely informal
- Real estate markets in US, UK, West highly decentralized
- Missing critical anti-money laundering features:
- Reporting thresholds
- Ownership requirements
- Process: Chinese naked official brings money to US → buys property → resells to another buyer → launders dirty money into clean economy
Financial Scale and Indicators
- 2016: average real estate purchase by Chinese nationals in US property was $936,000
- Price not necessarily indicator of money laundering
- AML investigators look for:
- Buyer as shell company with obscured final owners
- Unregistered proxies and real estate agents
- All-cash upfront payments
Shell Company Usage Statistics
- Global trend per Panama Papers
- US 2014: 50% of real estate transactions over $5 million purchased with shell companies
- UK 2015: authorities investigated £180 million of London real estate transactions
- Over 75% done with shell companies
Market Impact on Housing Prices
- Dirty money purchases have real consequences for ordinary people
- Buyers attempting to launder cash ASAP often willing to pay more than "healthy market price"
- Market distortion factors acknowledged:
- Private equity funds buying homes by thousands
- NIMBYs affecting Silicon Valley and NYC renters/buyers
- Need for residential rezoning
- Americans building huge McMansions with huge lawns
- Money laundering adds to overall mix like "potatoes in a soup"
- Clients offering/paying twice listed price in cash creates artificial market distortion
- Impact underreported due to goal of evading detection
Construction and Housing Supply Effects
- Money launderers are great clients → causes home builders to focus on luxury homes/apartment complexes rather than affordable housing
- Money launderers don't often live in homes they buy
- Result: empty luxury high rises dotting cities, traded on paper but never lived in
- Everyone else lives in 3-bedroom with 4 roommates
Public Perception and Political Implications
- Sydney Australia survey: only 30% believe Chinese real estate investments done above board
- 70% believe or unsure that illegalities happening
- Presents opportunity for future political exploitation
- Politicians can turn trends into racial/citizenship issues for political power
- Media jumped on these trends
Chinese Regulatory Response
- Chinese financial authorities getting better at closing traditional money exit routes
- Better relations between regulators and regulated resulting in better oversight
- Chinese banks now have robust AML departments targeting suspicious transactions
- New AML regulations coming online in Chinese securities, cryptocurrency, insurance sectors
- Insurance especially known for moving money out of China
Enforcement Statistics Comparison
- 2012 China: 29 million suspicious transaction reports → 5 convictions, 8 arrests
- 2012 US: 1.5 million transaction reports → 1,110 arrests
- Partly paperwork problem
Chinese AML System Issues
- China's AML systems run on "rules basis"
- Example: transaction larger than $1,000 → report it
- Biggest issue: once you know rule, easily evaded
- Generates lot of paperwork
- US and UK transitioning to "risk-based system"
- Rather than looking at every $10,000 transaction
- Look at who person is, what business conducting, what industry
- China hasn't moved to this style yet
Western Regulatory Challenges
- Financial regulatory authorities trying to expand oversight into real estate space
- Happening very slowly, literally state-to-state basis
- Real estate huge market in US
- Industry professionals (real estate agents, organizations) reluctant to accept complicated regulation
- Real benefits exist and should be implemented
International Cooperation Needs
- Countries must communicate and work together to shut down money laundering
- Money laundering happens when countries/bodies/regulatory agents don't communicate
- Problem: China's recent tensions with West made this harder
- Common ground should/can be found
- Both parties and peoples have lot to benefit from cooperation
