AI summary by TwinMind
Climate scientists can't agree on how warm it is
Sabine Hossenfelder
9m 18s
Current Temperature Status and Confusion
- 2023 average temperature: 1.56°C above pre-industrial level
- Multiple conflicting reports about crossing 1.5°C threshold
- Climate scientists disagreeing publicly:
- Jim Hansen (November): called Paris goals "deader than a doornail"
- Michael Mann response: "I've got three degrees in physics and I can tell you that Jim is wrong"
- Headlines in February declared 1.5°C threshold crossed
- Nature comment in January said 1.5°C "approaching"
Baseline Confusion - Michael Mann's Explanation
- Mann's chart showed warming at 1.3-1.4°C relative to 1900-2000 baseline
- Initially used 1970 as baseline (incorrect for Paris Agreement)
- Corrected to show current warming: 1.3-1.4°C above late 19th century baseline
- By 1970s: already had >0.2°C warming above pre-industrial
- Basic math error highlighted: 1.3 + 0.2 = 1.5°C
Different Baseline Interpretations
- February Nature Climate Change paper used 18th century baseline
- Much earlier than standard 1850-1900 pre-industrial baseline
- Argued warming in 18th/early 19th century was partially human-caused
- Under this interpretation: threshold already crossed
- Paris Agreement doesn't specify exact baseline
- Standard practice: 1850-1900 baseline (recommended to stick with this)
Technical Measurement Issues
- Single year crossing insufficient evidence
- Earth has natural temperature fluctuations
- El Niño/La Niña Southern Oscillation cycles
- Duration: few years
- IPCC uses 20-year average methodology
- Requires 10 years future data for any given date
- If crossed in 2023, wouldn't know until 2034
Projected 20-Year Average Method
- Nature comment authors suggest "projected 20-year average"
- Method: 10 years past data + 10 years model projections
- Current projected average: ~1.3°C above pre-industrial
- Projected threshold crossing: 2030-2035
- Model predictions range: 2027-2037
Final Assessment
- 2023 temperature: >1.5°C above pre-industrial (single year)
- 20-year average: still only ~1.3°C
- Paris Agreement technically not yet breached (by 20-year standard)
- Hansen's assessment correct: will "blast right through" threshold
- Science communication described as "mess"
Planet Wild Sponsorship
- International environmental protection organization
- Restores ecosystems through membership contributions
- Monthly missions documented on YouTube
- Activities: tree planting, animal reintroduction, whale research
- Latest mission: finding lost frog species in Ecuador using advanced tech
- Membership: $6/month minimum
- Special offer: first 500 subscribers get first month covered
