AI summary by TwinMind
Clue(do): Third Best Board Game Ever | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
49m 3s
Podcast Introduction and Host Banter
- Josh and Chuck host "Stuff You Should Know" podcast (iHeart Radio production)
- Jerry mentioned as producer who "carries lead pipe," nicknamed Miss Scarlet
- Chuck initially expected this to be Josh's topic pick, but Josh chose it
- Both hosts express love for Clue game historically
- Josh went on eBay seeking complete 1972 edition of Clue (nostalgic version for their age bracket)
- Josh disappointed by fake Medium article about 1972 Clue cover photo shoot (spoof by unknown author)
- Game called "Clue" in North America, "Cluedo" elsewhere
- Translated into multiple languages including Spanish and Swiss
Anthony Pratt: Clue's Inventor
- Anthony E. Pratt born Birmingham, England 1903
- High school dropout, professional piano player
- During WWI as teen, played "stupid game called Murder" with friends
- Guests crept up on each other in corridors, victims would shriek and fall
- Post-high school: traveling piano player at ritzy country hotels
- Hotels hosted Murder Mystery nights (still popular today)
- Didn't like teenage murder game but enjoyed hotel versions
- Surprisingly didn't like Agatha Christie despite game's similarity to her books
- 1943: Working as law clerk and munitions factory worker during WWII
- Blackouts prevented evening activities, stayed home with family
- Collaborated with wife Elva to create board game during blackouts
- Originally called "Murder!" with exclamation point
- Elva designed artwork and worked on gameplay
- Friend Jeffrey Bull had sold game to Waddington's Games, proving market existed
Original Game Development
- Initial version had 10 characters (one randomly chosen as victim)
- Featured 9 weapons including:
- Bomb (classic cartoon round fused bomb)
- Hypodermic syringe
- Poison bottle
- Irish shillelagh (stick fighting weapon, looks like cane with ball end)
- Standard weapons that remained
- Bulls accompanied Pratts to Waddington's meeting
- All sat down and played Murder together
- Waddington's immediately agreed to produce (1945)
- Anthony Pratt received patent 1947
- Production delayed due to WWII material shortages
- Full production began around 1949
Game Naming and Regional Differences
- UK version named "Cluedo" (Latin "cludo" = "I play")
- Also reference to existing British game "Ludo" (like Parcheesi)
- Parker Brothers (US partner) renamed it "Clue"
- Character differences: UK's "Reverend Green" became US "Mr. Green"
- House inspirations:
- UK: Tudor Close mansion in Sussex (renovated 1937 with billiard room and ballroom)
- US: George Parker's New Hampshire estate (bought 1925)
- Hosts agree 1972 American board game cover shows the definitive Clue house
Pratt's Financial Situation
- 1953: Sold overseas sales rights for £5,000 (£116,000+ today)
- Complained Waddington's didn't inform him of overseas sales success
- Money allowed him to quit job and play piano full-time
- Received domestic UK royalty checks until 1961 (possibly extended to 1965)
- Lived until 1994, had to return to work after royalties ended
- Should have received lifetime royalties
- Daughter Marsha Davies confirmed family rarely discussed Cluedo
- Mother would occasionally "grouse" about inadequate compensation
Pratt's Death and Legacy
- Died April 9, 1994 in obscurity
- Gravestone reads: "Anthony E. Pratt, inventor of Cluedo, sadly missed"
- Waddington's unaware of death for 3 years
- Discovered only when searching for him to celebrate 150 millionth sale
- Press release titled "Wanted: For Murder Most Enjoyable"
- Cemetery manager informed Waddington's of Pratt's death
- Clue ranks as 5th most popular board game of all time (including chess/checkers)
- Hosts argue it's 3rd most popular branded game after Monopoly and Scrabble
How to Play Clue - Basic Rules
- 3-6 players, ages 8 and up
- Six characters: Colonel Mustard, Miss Peacock, Professor Plum, Mrs. White, Mr. Green, Miss Scarlet
- Six weapons: knife, revolver, wrench, rope, candlestick, lead pipe
- Nine rooms: hall, lounge, dining room, kitchen, ballroom, conservatory, billiard room, library, study
- 1972 edition featured beautiful textured artwork for each room
- Three cards sealed in envelope reveal: murderer, weapon, location
- Approximately 324 possible solutions
- Players distributed remaining cards
- Roll dice to move through hallways between rooms
- Can only make suggestions when inside a room
- Suggestions bring suspected character and weapon into current room
Gameplay Strategy and Mechanics
- Suggestions work as "soft accusations" for process of elimination
- Players show cards to disprove suggestions (starting with player to left)
- If player has multiple matching cards, only shows one
- Strategic note-taking essential for tracking information
- Can make official accusation if no one shows cards
- Wrong accusation eliminates player from game
- Game continues to be entertaining even after elimination
- Advanced strategies include:
- Tracking which cards other players have shown
- Using suggestions to move other players strategically
- Mixing up suggestions to avoid revealing your knowledge
- Reading other players' tells and patterns
Advanced Strategy and AI Applications
- Dutch computer scientist Hans Van Ditmarsch created AI formalization of Cluedo
- Translated game into AI instructions focusing on information changes
- AI determines optimal path through player interactions
- Duke University developed algorithm for playing Clue
- Can be applied to problems like robotic mine sweeping
- Casual players should focus on basic note-taking and observation
- Avoid overly complex strategies in friendly games
Game Variations and International Versions
- Character name variations by country:
- Switzerland: Señor Lemon (victim)
- Spain: Señor Lemon
- France: Dr. Olive (Mr. Green equivalent)
- Brazil: Professor Black (Professor Plum equivalent)
- Norway/Switzerland: Baroness Von Blau (Mrs. Peacock equivalent)
- Switzerland: Madame Curry (Colonel Mustard equivalent)
- Original 1949 materials: actual rope piece, lead pipe made of lead
- 2008 "Discover the Secrets" edition major changes:
- Colonel Mustard became soccer star Jack Mustard
- Professor Plum became video game designer Victor Plum
- Added home theater room
- Mrs. White replaced by adopted daughter Dr. Orchid
- 2023 edition returned to classic format:
- Mrs. White returned as Chef White
- Victim now "Mr. Boddy Black" (combining UK/US names)
- Colonel Mustard back to military
- Mrs. Peacock now lawyer/solicitor
- Mr. Green now mayor
- More diverse character representation
Licensed Versions and Spin-offs
- Alfred Hitchcock Clue: characters from Hitchcock films, Bates Motel as room
- Scooby-Doo version: monsters as weapons
- Golden Girls version: mystery is "who ate the last slice of cheesecake"
- Star Wars and other franchise versions exist
- UK game show 1990-1993
- Young adult mystery book series
- 1980s VCR game (beloved and more difficult than board game)
- Upcoming animated series by Dwayne Perkins from "The Blackening"
1985 Clue Movie
- Classic comedy starring Tim Curry as Wadsworth the butler
- Written/directed by Jonathan Lynn, co-written with John Landis
- Lynn also directed "My Cousin Vinny" and "The Whole Nine Yards"
- Initially box office flop due to studio mistake
- Three different endings sent to different theaters
- Studio hoped people would see movie three times
- Strategy backfired commercially
- VHS release included all three endings sequentially
- Now considered comedy classic
- Cast included:
- Tim Curry (Wadsworth/butler)
- Madeline Kahn (Mrs. White) - "flames on the side of my face"
- Christopher Lloyd (Professor Plum)
- Martin Mull (Colonel Mustard)
- Michael McKean (Mr. Green)
- Eileen Brennan (Mrs. Peacock)
- Lesley Ann Warren (Miss Scarlet)
- Jane Wiedlin from Go-Go's (singing telegram girl)
- Lee Ving from punk band Fear (Mr. Boddy)
- Colleen Camp (Yvette)
- Kellye Nakahara from MAS*H (cook)
- Originally fourth ending planned
- Carrie Fisher originally considered for Miss Scarlet
- Featured on Movie Crush podcast with Casey Wilson
Listener Mail Correction
- Correction about JD Salinger episode
- Michiko Kakutani incorrectly referred to as male
- Actually female Pulitzer Prize-winning literary critic
- Listener Julianne Bear from White Salmon, Washington provided correction
- Josh acknowledges error and thanks for correction
