AI summary by TwinMind

Co-Founder Equity Mistakes to Avoid | Startup School

Y Combinator

19m 35s

Core Philosophy: Be Generous with Co-founder Equity

  • Primary advice: be generous with co-founder Equity splits
  • Goal: motivate founding team to work extremely hard during first couple years when things appear not working
  • Biggest mistake: being stingy on equity during delicate early startup phase, causing departures
  • Target audience: tech software startups expecting VC funding, pre-product market fit companies
  • Jedi founder vs midwit founder: both generous with equity vs overthinking skill sets/contributions/time commitments

Equity Distribution Strategy

  • Focus on motivating co-founders today AND tomorrow (years 2-4)
  • Equity vests over 4 years - prevent resentment thinking in later years
  • Typical advice: go for close to equal equity splits (don't have to be exactly equal)
  • More generous = expect stronger founder to stay motivated longer
  • Remember: most work in company hasn't been completed yet when giving co-founder equity
  • Equity motivates future work vs rewarding past work

Vesting and Cliffs Structure

  • All founder equity should vest over time period
  • Standard: 4-year vesting schedule
  • One-year cliff: no stock earned until completing one year at company
  • Applies to ALL founders without exception
  • Protection against life circumstances: family changes, illness, non-performance
  • Enables founders to let others go or leave without destroying cap table
  • Best practice - don't innovate on this structure

Essential Co-founder Criteria

  • Co-founders must be essential to founding team
  • Smallest number of people who can: build MVP, get it to customers, start learning
  • Being generous with equity helps remove non-essential "co-founders"
  • Co-founder title shouldn't be given out casually
  • Teams with 5-7 co-founders indicate missing conversations - 7 people not essential for initial product

CEO Authority and Accountability

  • CEO should retain ability to fire non-performing founders regardless of equity split
  • Must be "captain of ship" - someone ultimately accountable
  • CEO needs responsibility to let people go who aren't performing
  • If unwilling to join under these circumstances, consider starting own company as CEO

Co-founder Breakup Guidelines (Pre-Product Market Fit)

Before One-Year Cliff

  • Extremely typical: departing founder gets token amount (2-5% equity)
  • Remember: pre-product market fit = no evidence company will work
  • Vast majority of work still needs completion

After One-Year Cliff (Pre-Product Market Fit)

  • Departing founder should retain no more than 5% of company
  • Often means giving back some equity
  • Rationale: so much work left to be done, motivate remaining team
  • Departing founder can't help increase company value anymore
  • Holding large equity reduces company success chances

Severance and Transition

  • If founder fired: reasonable to give 1-3 months severance
  • If founder leaves voluntarily: severance not typical
  • All departing founders must:
    • Resign from board
    • Sign release
    • Often give proxy voting rights to remaining founders

CEO Departures

  • Sometimes CEO leaves/gets fired due to life circumstances
  • New CEO arranges breakup accordingly
  • Previous CEO should understand same expectations
  • Same rules apply even to departing CEOs

Bad Reasons for Unequal Equity Splits

"My Co-founder Agreed" (90%/10% split)

  • Perfect example of optimizing for today vs tomorrow
  • Think about year 3 motivation when everything difficult
  • CEO must think about tomorrow regardless of co-founder's perspective
  • Be more generous to compensate for future difficult times

"I Came Up with the Idea"

  • YC sees ~30,000 applications every 6 months - ideas are "dime a dozen"
  • Execution is the actual game
  • Co-founder essential for execution, otherwise shouldn't be co-founder
  • Coming up with idea not great reason for 90/10 split

"I Started 6 Months Before Co-founders"

  • Ask: how much work left to be done?
  • Traditional tech software startup = 99% of work remaining
  • Could be 10-30 year journey if successful
  • 6-month head start not significant in long-term context

"My Co-founder Needs Salary, I Don't"

  • Think about salary and equity differently
  • Salary = money needed to live (rent, food, basic survival)
  • Equity = motivation to work extremely hard and accept below-market salary
  • Never reduce equity because someone needs more salary
  • Give everyone salary they need to live + equity needed for motivation

"I'm Older/More Experienced"

  • Experience can contribute (fundraising, other capabilities)
  • But if making them co-founder = key contributor you couldn't do without
  • Be careful about their long-term motivation
  • Should be generous with equity as result

"I Hired Co-founder After Raising Money"

  • Fundraising doesn't massively change success chances
  • Lots of startups raise money, very few generate $1B+ revenue
  • Even with $100K-$500K investment, 99% of work still remains
  • First launch/MVP just beginning of journey

Common Bad Advice to Avoid

Performance-Based Equity

  • Unclear how to set goals at beginning of tech startup journey
  • Goals change frequently, companies pivot
  • Measuring things precisely at start is fallacy
  • Don't innovate on equity distribution - use best practices
  • This is not area for innovation (focus innovation on product/customers)

Part-Time Founders

  • Part-time founder isn't really a founder
  • Shouldn't be considered in equity equation
  • Most viable companies don't have part-time founders
  • If want to be founder, should work full-time

Dynamic Equity Agreements

  • Too fancy and ill-advised
  • People more motivated knowing what they have upfront vs uncertain rules
  • Often created by people who don't understand value of vesting/cliffs
  • Protection comes from vesting/cliffs, not fancy formulas
  • If can't ask co-founder to leave when not performing, shouldn't be doing startups
  • Must respect how hard this is and how much work co-founders contribute

Long-term Perspective on Successful Companies

  • Over 10-15 years, often one founder sticks around much longer
  • Examples: Jeff Bezos (Amazon), Mark Zuckerberg (Facebook)
  • Might think this means they deserve vastly more equity
  • But beginning extremely important - first 4-6 years where most value created
  • First 4-6 years when most companies die
  • Even if you're the one who stays longest, be generous with co-founder equity
  • Co-founders provided activation energy needed to get in the game
  • Without them, might not be in game at all
  • Early years and co-founder motivation crucial for successful products
  • Use co-founder equity to give best chance of building something people want
  • After success, you're doing better than 99% of startups and rules change

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome