AI summary by TwinMind
Comma.ai Drive and Tour with George Hotz and Lex Fridman
Lex Fridman
17m 35s
Comma Two System Demo
- George Hotz provided demo of Comma Two system during ride from Comma AI offices in San Diego
- System currently lacks red lights and stop signs detection
- Won't ship until holistic end-to-end (E2E) solution includes longitudinal control
- Currently only has lateral (steering) control via E2E
- Activation via cruise control knobs integrated into car
- Successfully demonstrated on curvy roads where only Comma and Tesla Autopilot can perform
- SuperCruise cannot handle due to insufficient roll control
- San Diego road quality described as "pretty mediocre like rest of California"
System Performance & Capabilities
- Best use case: long trips (2+ hours LA to San Diego without disengagement)
- Can perform lane changes on roads without lane markings due to E2E approach
- Smooth operation result of 5 years engineering work
- Lane lines detected but used more as guidance rather than primary input
- Lower torque limit than Tesla for safety
- Injection testing performed with joystick to ensure safety
Technical Architecture
- Lateral control: End-to-end neural network (E2E lateral)
- Longitudinal control: Currently uses Hyundai's ACC system
- Hyundai has "quite competent ACC, probably the best one"
- Plan to switch to E2E longitudinal once developed
- Lateral control more complex than longitudinal due to subtleties
- Lane splitting decisions, positioning, smoothness requirements
- City streets functionality available but not primary value proposition without E2E longitudinal
Usage Statistics & Global Reach
- Approaching 30 million OpenPilot miles
- Daily active users: ~1,500-2,000
- Weekly active users: almost 2,500
- Monthly active users: little over 3,000
- Global presence: US (200 users in last 30 days), Korea, Canada, Taiwan, Japan
- 50% of miles driven with system engaged
- 30% of time engaged
- Disengagements split evenly between cancel, gas, and brake
- Most segments now from Comma Two devices (described as "big breakout for company")
Office Tour & Operations
- Manufacturing facility includes:
- Stress testing area for 24-hour Comma Two testing (heat, temperature, light sensors, cosmetic checks)
- Retrofit operation converting ~100 phones simultaneously
- Assembly line: boarding → soldering → heat sink/fan installation → case assembly
- 3D printing facility with ~20 printers from worldwide sources (Poland, Germany, Peru)
- Compute cluster (not "data center" for legal reasons):
- Three CPU machine racks
- Two petabytes spinning disk storage
- RTX 3080s in desktop computers for non-business use
- V100 GPU machines for ML training
- Hand-assembled developer harnesses
- Company profitable with Comma Two
OpenPilot 1.0 Development
- Vision board includes moving everything to PyTorch
- Will be delivered to Comma Two via OTA updates
- Timeline: "not going to happen for a while" but getting close on many components
- Mission statement: "Solve self-driving cars while delivering shippable intermediaries"
