AI summary by TwinMind
Connel Fullenkamp | What a Living Whale is Worth | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
42m 36s
Introduction & Background
- Host: Kavia Casturi Rangan interviewing Dr. Connell Fullenkamp
- Dr. Fullenkamp: Professor at Duke University, co-founder Blue Green Future
- Topic: New economic paradigm embedding ecology into economic choices
- Goal: Put market value on benefits from living intact nature
- Context: COP 28 ongoing in Dubai during interview
Blue Green Future Goals & Approach
- Primary goal: Connect financial markets (with money) to conservation restoration projects (needing money)
- Focus on nature-based solutions for carbon capture by living nature
- Science reveals animals and plants capture/sequester vast amounts of CO2
- Starting point: Carbon markets (existing market) with plans to expand to other ecosystem services
- Secondary goal: Restore voluntary carbon markets to working order after 2023 scandals
- Approach based on: verification, science, transparency
- Create quality investment opportunities benefiting nature and society
Carbon Sequestration Science
- Plants: Trees, seagrass (buries carbon in ocean floor sediments), mangroves
- Animals: Whales store tons of carbon in bodies + fertilize phytoplankton
- Whales increase phytoplankton populations → more carbon capture
- Current whale populations: 10-20% of pre-industrial whaling levels
- Target: Southern oceans around Antarctica for whale restoration
- Sequestration definition: Scientists use 1,000-year minimum standard
- Alternative approach: Increase steady-state populations permanently (equivalent to sequestration)
Whale Valuation Methodology
- Carbon on whale bodies: Few tons (smaller whales) to dozens of tons (fin/blue whales)
- Ecosystem services: Whale fertilization of phytoplankton throughout lifetime + reproduction
- Calculations:
- Humpback whale: ~$2 million
- Blue whale: ~$4 million (largest)
- Pricing prorated by whale biomass/size
- Global impact: Restored whales could add 1% to global phytoplankton mass
- Equivalent: 375 million tons CO2 equivalent/year
- Comparable to several large forests (not Amazon-scale but significant)
Current Carbon Markets Structure
- Compliance markets: Government-mandated cap-and-trade systems
- Europe: 80-100 euros/ton CO2
- California has cap-and-trade market
- Voluntary markets: Project-based transactions
- Current prices: Single digits to $20/ton
- Damaged by bad actors/scandals in 2023
- Mostly one-off transactions between specific parties
- Goal: Create unified global market with single baseline price
- Vision: Open market accessible to all investors, not just negotiated deals
Implementation Framework
- Science-based finance: Biology + economics modeling
- Population growth projections: Hundreds of years out for some species
- Standard financial valuation: Net present value calculations
- Verification systems: Blockchain, surveillance, electronic technologies
- Transparency mechanisms: Track money flow, prevent fraud
- Perpetual care funding: Portion of proceeds invested for long-term resource protection
- Local community involvement: Indigenous/local communities as primary caretakers
Real-World Projects
- New Zealand Maui Tribes: Hinana Halo initiative
- Terrestrial: Native forest restoration
- Marine: Seagrass, kelp forests, mangroves, fisheries
- Whale migration corridor protection (New Zealand to Tonga)
- Multi-year regional blue/green economy development
- Bahamas: Seagrass restoration projects
- Potentially immense Caribbean seagrass resources
- Could become major carbon sinks
- Middle East: Mangrove and coral reef projects in Red Sea region
Challenges & Considerations
- Animal emissions: Some species (elephants) produce methane
- Net calculation: Carbon sequestration benefits outweigh emissions
- Forest elephants contribute 7% carbon sequestration to late succession rainforest trees
- Government cooperation: Essential as natural capital owners/stewards
- Need financial benefits for governments to participate
- Various government branches have different receptiveness levels
- Funding scale: Biodiversity crisis requires hundreds of billions to trillions
- Philanthropy insufficient - need private sector/financial markets
- Market development: Currently lacks standardized pricing/investment vehicles
Legal & Rights Applications
- Rights of nature movement: Data could support lawsuits on behalf of nature
- Legal personhood: Colleague Ralph Shamy advocates whale personhood
- Enforcement mechanisms:
- Nations could impose $2-4 million fines for ship strikes on whales
- Insurance companies would require whale detection equipment
- Currently no penalties for striking whales
- Detection technology: Blue Boat initiative (Chile) developed sonar buoys
- Technology exists but enforcement lacking
Public Engagement & Support
- Investment opportunities: Not yet available - still building proper market structure
- How to help:
- Support scientific research on ecosystem services
- Spread awareness about nature's carbon sequestration value
- Advocate to governments about economic benefits
- Pension fund interest: Strong investor demand for nature-beneficial investments
- Government messaging: Frame as revenue opportunity, not just cost
2024 Outlook
- Primary goal: Rebuild voluntary carbon markets momentum
- Active projects: Maui tribes, Bahamas seagrass, Middle East mangroves/coral reefs
- Expansion: Talking with new groups, increasing organizational bandwidth
- Focus: Create conservation restoration programs good for nature and investors
