AI summary by TwinMind

Copyright Lawyer Explains Drake AI Song and More | WSJ

The Wall Street Journal

8m 17s

AI-Generated Art Copyright Protection Issues

  • Thaler v. Perlmutter case (2018)
    • Dr. Steven Thaler applied for copyright protection for AI-generated artwork
    • Copyright office rejected application - creative works must have human authors
    • Thaler sued over rejection and lost, appealed ruling
    • Decision expected by end of year
    • Copyright office declined to comment
  • Copyright requirements for protection
    • Work must be original, fixed to tangible medium, have human authorship
    • Human authorship element rarely disputed/litigated previously
    • Naruto monkey selfie case (2011) - wildlife photographer David Slater's camera used by monkey named Naruto
      • PETA argued Naruto should own copyright, not Slater
      • Federal court ruled photograph lacks human authorship because Naruto is monkey
  • Castanova case - first to address copyright conundrum
    • Artist/computer scientist Chris Castanova used MidJourney for graphic novel artwork
    • Personally edited some artwork using Photoshop
    • Copyright office said edits too minor for copyright entitlement
    • Copyright office stated sufficient original human authorship could warrant protection
    • Castanova's attorney called decision incorrect and unsustainable
  • Implications of copyright denial
    • Without copyright registration, creators cannot meaningfully commercialize AI-assisted work
    • Federal appellate court may expand human authorship definition
    • Congress may be lobbied to redefine human authorship for contemporary society

AI and Right of Publicity Violations

  • Technology impact on name/image/likeness rights
    • AI makes it exceedingly easy to co-opt/repurpose someone's name, image, likeness commercially
  • Ghost Writer Drake/Weeknd deepfake case
    • Anonymous producer used generative AI to fake Drake and Weeknd voices
    • Song "Heart on My Sleeve" had 600,000 Spotify plays before removal
    • Pulled following copyright infringement complaint from Universal Music Group
  • Kyland Young v. Neocortex (Reface app) lawsuit
    • Former CBS Big Brother contestant sued over face in app's library
    • Face available for paying users to edit without consent
    • Violates right of publicity - commercial use of image without permission
    • Samsung/Vanna White precedent (1992) - robot in print ad resembled Wheel of Fortune host
      • White sued Samsung for right of publicity violation and won
    • Neocortex defenses:
      • Young's images no longer available in app
      • App output is derivative, Copyright Act preempts right of publicity claim
    • Legal expert believes Neocortex will have difficulty defeating Young's claim

Training Data Copyright Infringement Cases

  • Artist group lawsuit (2023) against AI companies
    • Artists claim copyrighted works scraped online to train large language models
    • Defendants include MidJourney, Stability AI
    • Artists never licensed work to defendants
    • Argue AI artwork constitutes copyright infringement due to similarity to originals
  • Substantial similarity legal standard
    • Courts focus on similarities, not differences
    • Examine similarities of protectable elements (subjects, camera angles)
    • Getty Images example - similar subjects and camera angles in AI output
    • Stability AI didn't respond to comment requests
  • Legal precedent for data scraping
    • HiQ v. LinkedIn case - recruiting software scraped publicly available LinkedIn data
    • Court ruled scraping publicly available information is acceptable
    • Training data use alone probably legally acceptable
    • Platforms must ensure output doesn't constitute copyright infringement
  • Future concerns with OpenAI's Sora text-to-video tool
    • Public release may create more copyright issues
    • Cityscapes of Tokyo, New York, Paris might create recognizable versions of famous trademarks
    • OpenAI declined to comment

Legal System Adaptation to AI Technology

  • Law beginning to catch up to fast AI advancement
  • Technology tests bounds of existing laws
  • Technological shifts force rethinking, reapplying, or rewriting law

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome