AI summary by TwinMind

Corporate America's Desperate Race To Trademark... Everything

How Money Works

13m 39s

Introduction to Trademark Abuse

  • Desperate race to trademark everything currently happening
  • Common words trademarked: "superhero," "realtor," "face," "that's hot," "Bam"
  • Companies silently building IP vaults
  • Kylie Jenner failed to trademark "Kylie" (blocked by Kylie Minogue)
  • Facebook trademarked "face" (US Patent 5718632)

Types of Intellectual Property Protection

  • Patents: Protect inventions/discoveries for 20 years
    • Example: New battery giving 2,000 miles range for electric cars
    • Must be filed with patent/trademark office
    • "Patent pending" has no legal protection but warns competitors
  • Copyright: Automatically applies to creative works
    • Lasts 70 years after creator's death
    • No filing required but harder to prove in court
  • Trademarks: Best of both patent and copyright
    • Applications tripled in last 10 years (US Patent Office data)
    • Legally filed with patent/trademark office
    • Lasts forever with 10-year renewals
    • Only applies to business branding elements

Trademark Corruption and Business Advantages

  • Crafty businessmen claiming catchphrases, sounds, images, words as branding
  • Overworked trademark officers approving questionable claims
  • Creates untouchable business advantage lasting forever
  • Examples of successful trademarks:
    • Facebook: "face"
    • DC/Marvel: "superhero" (jointly owned)
    • Paris Hilton: "that's hot"
    • Usain Bolt: signature move
  • Successful trademarks add significant business value
  • Investment banker experience: Companies buying terrible businesses exclusively for trademarks

Trademark Warfare Among Tech Giants

  • Large tech companies buying competition with strong trademarks/patents
  • Building arsenals for "dumbest corporate war ever"
  • Companies file so many patents/trademarks competitors can't operate without violations
  • Apple patent USD 593872: Electronic device shaped like rectangle with rounded corners
    • Expired earlier this year
    • Covered virtually all smartphones from last 20 years
  • Companies don't enforce all patents due to mutually assured destruction
  • Google owns millions of trademarks/patents

Patent Trolls and Investment Strategies

  • Adam Newman (WeWork founder) trademarked "We"
    • Sold to own company for $6 million investor money
    • Had to return money after backlash
    • Used for WeWork, WeLive, WeGrow, Rise by We brands
  • Nathan Myhrvold (former Microsoft CTO) started Intellectual Ventures
    • Investment firm buying defunct companies for IP
    • Threatens lawsuits over broad trademark definitions
    • Large team filing as many patents as possible
    • Largest/best-funded patent troll example

Strategic Trademark Hoarding

  • Many trademarks specific to business use cases
  • Facebook trademarks: "face," "like," "wall" (social media only)
  • Can't stop drywalling companies or Apple's FaceTime
  • Social media: $0 to trillion-dollar market in 30 years
  • Strategy: Trademark everything when new technology emerges
  • If market grows: harder for competitors
  • If market fails: $250 registration fee negligible for billion-dollar companies
  • Can sell unused trademarks or license to slower companies

AI Market Trademark Rush

  • OpenAI and generative AI exciting investors/business leaders
  • Patenting spree for Bloomberg Intelligence projected trillion-dollar market (next decade)
  • Companies should be rewarded for R&D investment and risk
  • AI speeding up trademark race for more sinister reasons

AI-Powered Trademark Enforcement

  • Previously impossible to monitor all trademark infringement
  • Sites full of knockoffs: Alibaba, Temu, Wish.com, Etsy, eBay, Amazon
  • "Not illegal if we don't get caught" business model
  • Human monitors couldn't keep up with altered photos/descriptions
  • AI services now train models to detect trademark theft
  • Programs work 24/7, detect new listings immediately
  • Official trademark registration simplifies removal process
  • Host companies won't act without clear IP ownership

AI and Copyright Detection Evolution

  • YouTube copyright detection already exists for songs/videos
  • New AI tools extend to physical products
  • Previously difficult for computers to compare sneaker similarity
  • Advanced algorithms struggled to identify shoes as shoes
  • AI image detection now enables advanced comparisons across entire internet
  • Doesn't depend on site hosts like YouTube system

AI Training Data Trademark Issues

  • Book: "Artificial Intelligence and Intellectual Property" (three law professors)
  • AI can detect trademarks but trained on potentially trademarked data
  • GPT-4 trained on terabytes of scraped internet data
  • Includes works/branding valuable to creators
  • Companies claiming trademarks now to limit AI competition
  • Harvard Business Review: Popular AI use case is logo creation
  • Small businesses use AI for logos (lack skills/money for designers)
  • Every AI logo blends other trademarked logos from training data
  • Law hasn't caught up with technology
  • Debate: Human designers vs. AI inspiration/originality
  • Companies building "fortress of trademarks" for preparation

Historical Context and Future Implications

  • Comedians fought inspiration vs. stealing debate before trademark laws
  • Reference to "The Men Who Mock Kings" content
  • Author's investment banking experience with corporate trademark abuse
  • Compounded Daily newsletter for additional content

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome