AI summary by TwinMind
Crack Down On New Climate Denial! Nonprofit tells YouTube | Science News
Sabine Hossenfelder
5m 51s
Center for Countering Digital Hate Report Overview
- American-British NGO nonprofit released new report on climate misinformation on YouTube
- Used AI to crawl YouTube videos and classify climate misinformation types
- Calls for YouTube to take more action against climate misinformation
Shift from Old to New Climate Denial
- Outright climate change denial (claims climate isn't changing or humans not responsible) has strongly declined
- "New denial" now dominates: acknowledges climate change and human causation but claims:
- Nothing to worry about
- Actually good for us
- Can't do anything about it anyway
- General dismissal of climate science/scientists as unreliable
- New denial comprises 70% of all climate denial claims on YouTube
- Up from 35% six years ago
- Examples include claims like "carbon dioxide is good for plants therefore good for all"
Revenue and Monetization Impact
- YouTube makes over $13 million revenue annually from new climate denial content
- YouTube doesn't allow monetization of old denial type videos
- New denial type can still be monetized
- Same shift observed on Twitter (previously non-monetizable platform)
Current vs Recommended Policy Changes
- Current YouTube policy: "We do not allow content that contradicts authoritative scientific consensus on climate change"
- Recommended policy: "We do not allow content that contradicts authoritative scientific consensus on the causes, impacts and solutions to climate change"
- Center also recommends more demonetization across social media platforms
Critique of Proposed Policy Changes
- Policy change crosses line from limiting scientific misinformation to controlling opinions
- Distinction between facts vs opinions:
- Scientific misinformation: Claims plants benefit from sudden climate zone changes
- Personal opinion: Being more worried about energy shortages than climate change
- Author notes they could be classified as "new denier" for making video about Net Zero plans likely to fail
Alternative Approaches and Market Forces
- Problem isn't content producers but audience demand for misinformation
- People want misinformation to justify pre-held conclusions
- Bans/demonetization unlikely to make significant difference - "if there's demand, there will be supply"
- Market forces won't fix issue because ads target viewers, not creators
- Brands don't worry about association since viewers click content they like
Information vs Misinformation Solutions
- Author advocates combating misinformation with information (old school approach)
- Skeptical of psychological studies showing people rarely change minds with new information
- Evidence that old climate denial declined proves people do change minds when confronted with facts
- Scientific misinformation problem will worsen as AI tools become more available
- No clear solution identified
