AI summary by TwinMind
"Crash-Proof" Investments: How Safe Havens Performed in Our Recent Bear Market
The Plain Bagel
12m 36s
Introduction & Context
- Video sponsored by Skillshare - free 2 month premium trial at SK.SH/theplainbagel6
- Analysis of safe haven investments during COVID-19 market downturn
- Common belief: certain assets (Treasury bills, gold, Bitcoin) are uncorrelated to stocks and recession-proof
- Problem: during market crashes, correlation between investments tends to increase, dragging other assets down with stocks
Analysis Framework
- Time period: February 19th to March 23rd, 2020
- Benchmark: S&P 500 performance (34% drop in March)
- Correlation scale: -1 to +1
- Above 0.9: very strong correlation
- 0.7-0.9: strong correlation
- 0.5-0.7: moderate correlation
- 0.3-0.5: low correlation
- Below 0.3: no relationship
- Safe havens should show measures close to zero or negative
Treasury Bonds Performance
- US Treasury bonds considered risk-free (government can print money/tax to pay obligations)
- Vanguard Treasury bond ETF results:
- Short-term, intermediate, long-term bonds all increased during crash
- Longer-term bonds performed best (guaranteed income over longer periods)
- All three ETFs showed negative correlations to S&P 500
- Short-term ETF: strong negative correlation
- Longer-term ETF: fairly weak correlation
- Key considerations:
- Bond prices rise when interest rates fall
- Federal Reserve cut federal funds rate to effectively 0%
- Unclear how much price return due to market uncertainty vs rate cuts
- 13-week Treasury bills yield dipped into negative territory
- Existing bondholders benefit from rising prices, new investors unlikely to earn return above inflation
- Conclusion: Protected investor capital during crash, but long-term profitability currently poor
Defensive Stocks Performance
- Traditional safe haven sectors: healthcare, utilities, consumer staples
- Expected to maintain demand during recessions (essential nature of business)
- S&P 500 sector performance during March crash:
- Healthcare, utilities, consumer staples returns almost as bad as broader S&P 500
- Near-perfect correlations to S&P 500
- Event-specific factors: pandemic created logistical obstacles for these companies
- Conclusion: Buying sectors as whole for defensive properties doesn't protect from sharp declines
Gold Performance
- Traditional safe haven and inflation hedge
- Protects against currency deterioration when central banks implement expansionary monetary policy
- COVID-19 crash performance:
- Gold prices fell 2% over analyzed timeframe
- Correlation to stocks: 0.63 (moderate positive relationship)
- Recovered right after crash, jumped on record jobless claims
- Historical context: In 2008, gold appreciated as stock prices fell
- Conclusion: Less effective as safe haven during this particular downturn, but still preserved capital better than stocks
Bitcoin Performance
- Argued as safe haven due to finite supply (not subject to central bank interference)
- First real test during bear market
- COVID-19 crash results:
- Dropped 29.5% over timeframe
- Correlation to stocks: 0.91 (very strong correlation)
- Conclusion: Offers no downside protection, investors prone to same fears as stock investors, gold maintained superiority over "gold 2.0"
Key Takeaways
- No silver bullet for avoiding market crashes
- Treasuries only investment that performed better than holding cash
- Market crashes are part of investing - risk is counterpart to return
- Focus on controllable factors:
- Take appropriate risk for risk tolerance
- Consider near-future big purchases
- Diversify across asset classes
- Seek professional advice if needed
- Long-term: quality companies should recover as operations return to normal
- Be skeptical of "recession-proof" or "crash-proof" investment claims
