AI summary by TwinMind

Cursor Is Beating VS Code (...by forking it)

Theo - t3․gg

18m 0s

Disclosure and Background

  • Speaker is investor in Cursor AI code editor
  • Previously churned from product twice, preferred SuperMaven (also invested in)
  • SuperMaven is faster co-pilot alternative in VS Code
  • Video not sponsored by Cursor, no input from company
  • Decided to give Cursor honest evaluation

Sponsor Segment

  • Frontend Masters course promotion
  • $400/year for 200+ courses from industry veterans
  • $100 off promotion until Wednesday ($300 total)
  • Course mentioned: Primagen's Git course

Initial Conversion Experience

  • Working with premium vs non-premium viewership data analysis
  • Cursor autocompleted mathematical calculations correctly
    • Premium watch hours: 36% viewership, 30% revenue
    • Non-premium watch hours: 63% viewership, 70% ad revenue
  • AI correctly performed math operations through autocomplete
  • Command+Shift+K feature allowed natural language edits
  • Breakthrough moment: realizing AI could handle math and specific integrations

Cost Analysis Demo

  • Comparing Worker KV vs R2 storage solutions
  • Variables: average image value, cost per image for each service
  • Changed image size from original to 4MB
  • Cursor automatically updated all dependent calculations correctly
  • No incorrect numbers encountered so far
  • Occasional mistakes: referencing wrong source numbers, but usually visible

Cloudflare Workers Integration

  • Created new project: cursor-cf-demo
  • Major pain point: CORS handling
  • Cursor generated complete CORS solution code
    • Handles OPTIONS requests manually
    • Appends headers to every response
  • Eliminated need to research Cloudflare-specific CORS implementation
  • Significant time savings on "busy work" tasks

Performance Comparison

  • Autocomplete not as fast as SuperMaven
  • Misses SuperMaven's speed but appreciates other features
  • Unique UI capabilities vs code extensions can't replicate

Advanced Features Demo

  • Tab autocomplete across multiple file locations
  • Changed "files" tab references, AI suggested related changes
  • Smart contextual suggestions that move around editor
  • Not always consistent but frequently helpful
  • Multi-select editing integration

Code Quality Concerns

  • Easy to commit code without fully understanding it
  • Credits Primagen for highlighting this issue
  • Problem with AI code generation tools generally
  • Preference for seeing/approving every line in editor
  • Uses git add -p to manually review each change
  • Comparison to Rails/Laravel code generation concerns

Database Query Generation

  • Working with paginated image retrieval
  • Attempted server-side pagination check - partially failed
  • Successful simpler query: get single image with tags
  • Uses Drizzle ORM (less popular but AI handles correctly)
  • Smart about using existing schema definitions
  • Generates proper joins, error handling, return logic

Laravel/PHP Success Story

  • File upload issues in Laravel project
  • Chat suggestions didn't work
  • Simple command: "file uploads aren't working please fix"
  • AI fixed issue on first try
  • Demonstrates practical problem-solving capability

Tool Philosophy

  • Not replacing coding ability
  • Reducing tedious tasks significantly
  • Alternative to documentation/Stack Overflow research
  • Similar success rate to Stack Overflow solutions
  • More convenient than copy-pasting from forums

Model Information

  • Uses multiple models simultaneously
  • Includes Claude, GPT-4, GPT-3.5, others
  • Cursor automatically selects appropriate model
  • Default configuration trusted over manual selection
  • Not just simple API wrappers

VS Code Extension Limitations

  • Explains why Cursor forked VS Code instead of creating extension
  • Example: TypeScript error display extension
  • Extension uses SVG icons as workaround for UI limitations
  • Cannot create interactive UI elements
  • Limited to side panels and existing VS Code parameters
  • Command+K integration impossible as extension

VS Code Fork Strategy

  • Maintaining large codebase fork is challenging
  • Necessary for meaningful UI improvements
  • Currently closed source
  • Opportunity for others to create extensible VS Code fork
  • Surprised no one has created more extensible version

Future Developments

  • Article coming: "Unintended Consequences of Open Source"
  • Covers 1% of VS Code code that is Cursor's
  • Discussion of open source monetization challenges
  • Code Frying Pan: open source VS Code fork project
  • Building better primitives for AI integration
  • Potential alternative to try

Final Assessment

  • Converted from skeptical to enthusiastic user
  • Significant productivity gains for onboarding and tedious tasks
  • UI innovations justify VS Code fork approach
  • Speed still inferior to SuperMaven for autocomplete
  • Overall user experience improvements outweigh drawbacks

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome