AI summary by TwinMind
Cursor Is Beating VS Code (...by forking it)
Theo - t3․gg
18m 0s
Disclosure and Background
- Speaker is investor in Cursor AI code editor
- Previously churned from product twice, preferred SuperMaven (also invested in)
- SuperMaven is faster co-pilot alternative in VS Code
- Video not sponsored by Cursor, no input from company
- Decided to give Cursor honest evaluation
Sponsor Segment
- Frontend Masters course promotion
- $400/year for 200+ courses from industry veterans
- $100 off promotion until Wednesday ($300 total)
- Course mentioned: Primagen's Git course
Initial Conversion Experience
- Working with premium vs non-premium viewership data analysis
- Cursor autocompleted mathematical calculations correctly
- Premium watch hours: 36% viewership, 30% revenue
- Non-premium watch hours: 63% viewership, 70% ad revenue
- AI correctly performed math operations through autocomplete
- Command+Shift+K feature allowed natural language edits
- Breakthrough moment: realizing AI could handle math and specific integrations
Cost Analysis Demo
- Comparing Worker KV vs R2 storage solutions
- Variables: average image value, cost per image for each service
- Changed image size from original to 4MB
- Cursor automatically updated all dependent calculations correctly
- No incorrect numbers encountered so far
- Occasional mistakes: referencing wrong source numbers, but usually visible
Cloudflare Workers Integration
- Created new project: cursor-cf-demo
- Major pain point: CORS handling
- Cursor generated complete CORS solution code
- Handles OPTIONS requests manually
- Appends headers to every response
- Eliminated need to research Cloudflare-specific CORS implementation
- Significant time savings on "busy work" tasks
Performance Comparison
- Autocomplete not as fast as SuperMaven
- Misses SuperMaven's speed but appreciates other features
- Unique UI capabilities vs code extensions can't replicate
Advanced Features Demo
- Tab autocomplete across multiple file locations
- Changed "files" tab references, AI suggested related changes
- Smart contextual suggestions that move around editor
- Not always consistent but frequently helpful
- Multi-select editing integration
Code Quality Concerns
- Easy to commit code without fully understanding it
- Credits Primagen for highlighting this issue
- Problem with AI code generation tools generally
- Preference for seeing/approving every line in editor
- Uses
git add -pto manually review each change - Comparison to Rails/Laravel code generation concerns
Database Query Generation
- Working with paginated image retrieval
- Attempted server-side pagination check - partially failed
- Successful simpler query: get single image with tags
- Uses Drizzle ORM (less popular but AI handles correctly)
- Smart about using existing schema definitions
- Generates proper joins, error handling, return logic
Laravel/PHP Success Story
- File upload issues in Laravel project
- Chat suggestions didn't work
- Simple command: "file uploads aren't working please fix"
- AI fixed issue on first try
- Demonstrates practical problem-solving capability
Tool Philosophy
- Not replacing coding ability
- Reducing tedious tasks significantly
- Alternative to documentation/Stack Overflow research
- Similar success rate to Stack Overflow solutions
- More convenient than copy-pasting from forums
Model Information
- Uses multiple models simultaneously
- Includes Claude, GPT-4, GPT-3.5, others
- Cursor automatically selects appropriate model
- Default configuration trusted over manual selection
- Not just simple API wrappers
VS Code Extension Limitations
- Explains why Cursor forked VS Code instead of creating extension
- Example: TypeScript error display extension
- Extension uses SVG icons as workaround for UI limitations
- Cannot create interactive UI elements
- Limited to side panels and existing VS Code parameters
- Command+K integration impossible as extension
VS Code Fork Strategy
- Maintaining large codebase fork is challenging
- Necessary for meaningful UI improvements
- Currently closed source
- Opportunity for others to create extensible VS Code fork
- Surprised no one has created more extensible version
Future Developments
- Article coming: "Unintended Consequences of Open Source"
- Covers 1% of VS Code code that is Cursor's
- Discussion of open source monetization challenges
- Code Frying Pan: open source VS Code fork project
- Building better primitives for AI integration
- Potential alternative to try
Final Assessment
- Converted from skeptical to enthusiastic user
- Significant productivity gains for onboarding and tedious tasks
- UI innovations justify VS Code fork approach
- Speed still inferior to SuperMaven for autocomplete
- Overall user experience improvements outweigh drawbacks
