AI summary by TwinMind
Dear Apple - The iPad needs help.
Mrwhosetheboss
11m 46s
Initial iPad Pro Experience & Hardware Impressions
- Purchased fully specced iPad Pro for over $3,000
- Goal: replace chunky 16-inch MacBook Pro with thin 5mm tablet
- Setup experience: everything worked seamlessly
- Account logins took seconds via Apple keychain & Face ID
- Face ID advantage over Mac (which lacks it)
- Hardware praised as "magic sheet of glass"
- Screen brightness impressive despite thinness
- Palm rejection technology works well
- Even bezels in all orientations
- Face ID works in any orientation
- Volume buttons remap based on orientation (left=down, right=up)
- Performance: as fast as maxed out MacBook Pro despite size difference
- Battery life: better than most laptops, though not as good as MacBook Pro
- Cellular data: £100 prepaid data plan for year's worth of usage
- Webcam quality: crisp, flattering with Center Stage feature (follows user around room)
- Gaming performance: excellent for mobile games with large, bright, clear display
Software & Compatibility Issues
- Day 2 problems when attempting serious work
- Mouse compatibility disaster:
- Logitech MX Master (works perfectly on Mac) performed terribly
- Scroll wheel extremely laggy and unresponsive
- Frequent disconnections
- Had to order Apple Magic Mouse for proper functionality
- Magic Mouse ergonomics poor: flat, sharp, requires finger arching
- Caused hand issues from "clawing" position during extended use
- Keyboard problems:
- Space bar randomly inserted double spaces
- Would stop typing entirely
- Zero issues with same accessories on Mac
- Third-party Bluetooth accessories extremely unreliable on iPad
Workflow Disruptions & User Experience Problems
- Screenshot functionality broken:
- Takes screenshots of all connected screens instead of current one
- Requires manual deletion and resizing of each corner
- Drag-and-drop fails 50% of time due to app silos
- Safari limitations:
- Can't rearrange favorites by dragging
- Must use convoluted side menu
- Favorites bar disappears when scrolling down
- Must scroll back up or move cursor to top to access favorites
- Mouse pointer replaced with imprecise "mouse blob" that snaps to elements
- Website compatibility issues
- Confusion between virtual and physical keyboards (sometimes provides neither)
- No progress bars for file transfers/opening
- Aggressive background process shutdown:
- Amazon purchases fail unless window kept open
- Background uploads silently cancel
- Inconsistent app behavior:
- Double/triple tap functions differ between web browser and Docs app
- Poor iPad formatting for many apps
- No official calculator app (requires third-party with permanent ads)
- Limited multitasking within apps (e.g., can't compose new email while viewing old one in Gmail)
- Desktop less flexible than Mac with poor space utilization tools
Root Cause Analysis & Apple's Dilemma
- All issues extremely fixable with software updates
- Apple created powerful new chip, thin design, upgraded Apple Pencil
- Problem: Apple also sells Mac
- iPad biggest threat to Mac sales, not Windows laptops
- Apple stuck making iPad "more Pro" yearly without addressing core limitations
- Forces users to still need MacBook despite iPad hardware capability
Hardware Limitations (Harder to Fix)
- Screen gets more fingerprints than Mac (designed for touch)
- Speakers shoot outward instead of forward (less crisp audio than Mac)
- With Magic Keyboard: extremely top-heavy, unstable on lap
- Apple Pencil Pro attachment via magnet inadequate for expensive accessory
Current Usage Strategy
- Kept iPad despite frustrations
- Travel computer: detach from keyboard for day trips
- International travel: pack keyboard for 95% laptop experience
- Excellent for watching movies on planes
- MacBook Pro remains permanently docked at desk for desktop use
- Waiting for Apple to address software limitations at WWDC
Sponsored Content: Surf Shark VPN
- Alternative ID feature creates fake personas for forms
- Generates complete details including usable email addresses
- Email forwarding to main account with ability to cut off anytime
- VPN benefits: fast, good app, affordable
- Code "boss": under $3/month with 4 extra months free
- Unlimited users, 30-day money back guarantee
