AI summary by TwinMind
De-industrialization was Hong Kong’s Biggest Mistake
Asianometry
18m 27s
Background and Historical Context
- Previous video about Hong Kong's electronics manufacturing loss received criticism
- Common response: manufacturing moved to Shenzhen, Hong Kong better at services
- Thesis: deindustrialization was Hong Kong's biggest economic mistake
Post-War Manufacturing Boom (1950s-1960s)
- After Chinese Civil War, Shanghai industrialists relocated to Hong Kong with refugees
- Brought capital, manufacturing expertise, fled Communist Party
- Established factories in high-rise buildings due to land constraints
- Products: plastic flowers, clothes, radio assemblies
- Leveraged 1 million poor Chinese migrants as labor force
- Perfect timing: US and West began outsourcing manufacturing to Asia (1950s)
- By early 1960s: Hong Kong = single biggest manufacturer in developing world
- Low-skilled jobs provided wealth-building opportunities
Competitive Pressures and Technological Limitations
- Competition emerged from South Korea, Taiwan
- Rising labor costs as worker salaries improved
- Each generation demanded better lifestyle
- Hong Kong manufacturing lacked technological expertise
- Could not produce native technologies or critical components
- Electronics OEMs spent 60% of cost budget on integrated circuits imported from Japan
- Result: uncompetitive industry
- 1981: manufacturers requested government help for technological upgrading
- Taiwan, Singapore, South Korea: governments investing millions in technology acquisition
- Hong Kong manufacturers falling behind
British Colonial Economic Structure
- Hong Kong remained British colony - significant constraint
- Colonial administration never intended more than trading post role
- Fiscal compromise: no import/export taxes
- Government revenue from land leases (holds superior title to all land)
- Created incentives for ever-rising land prices, trading focus
- By 1949: biggest companies were banks, land developers, trading houses
- Former industrialists like Lee Ka-shing closed factories, became landlords (more profitable)
- Companies opposed government intervention for manufacturing
- Government retained non-interventionist stance
Transition to Service Economy
- Manufacturing relocated mostly to China
- Massive loss of lower/middle income jobs
- Doubled down on finance and trading
- Became value-added intermediary for West-China trade
- Hong Kong advantages: British heritage, English language, pro-business laws
- Service industry contribution to GDP:
- 1980: 68%
- 2000: 86.5%
- 2019: 93.4%
- Second biggest sector: construction
- Economy produces little beyond people's efforts
Declining Intermediary Role
- Chief executives (Tung Chee-hwa, Donald Tsang) didn't reverse deindustrialization
- Pushed view: Hong Kong benefits from free capital/trade flow between China-West
- Problem: more China opens, less Hong Kong service model produces value
- Pearl River region now top logistics/transport center
- Shanghai taking Hong Kong's service functions
- Mainland cities reformed financial restrictions, allowing foreign capital
- Hong Kong's share of China's trade with world:
- 1997: 60%
- 2007: 28%
- 2020: 10%
Financial Services Growth and Competition
- Only growing sector: financial services
- Finance, insurance, real estate GDP contribution:
- 2000: 18%
- 2019: nearly 30%
- Now city's only growth engine
- China lifting foreign ownership restrictions (2020)
- Foreign banks can completely own Chinese subsidiaries
- Same for securities, fund management firms
- Foreign companies offer financial products directly to Chinese consumers
- BlackRock example: started wholly owned mutual funds in China (2021)
- Chinese investment market full of scams, need better returns
- Other Chinese cities becoming financial centers
Housing Crisis and Economic Constraints
- Property prices obscene, far outpacing wage growth
- Most young Hong Kongers will never own homes
- Government acknowledges inability to address housing
- Hong Kong dollar pegged to USD since 1983 - no interest rate control
- City incredibly dense, remaining land locked up by big four land monopolies:
- Sino HongKai Properties
- CK Hutchison Holdings
- 1990s housing reform failed, rolled back after 1997 Asian Financial Crisis
- Housing reform means over-leveraged individuals take losses
- Public housing spending as % of GDP unchanged since 2005
Current Policy Vision and Employment Reality
- Government vision: labor flexibility in high-tech industries
- Grow wealth through investing in wealth-building assets
- Problem: where are high-paying jobs coming from?
- Finance, insurance, real estate provide <10% of city's jobs
- 85% of adult population (3.1 million) work for large service companies
- Domestic landscape stagnant, dominated by land developer conglomerates
- Anti-competitive established markets prevent new entrants
- Massive wage inequality: bankers/big tech make lot, everyone else considerably less
- Many service workers over-educated for jobs, few career upgrade prospects
Government's New Industry Development
- Until 2016: invested in "four key industries" (financial services, tourism, trading/logistics, professional services)
- Recent attitude change: need new career pathways for youth
- Emerging industries identified:
- Cultural and creative (games, software)
- Medical services (medical tourism)
- Education services (profit/non-profit institutions)
- Testing and certification (ISO certification for Pearl River companies)
- Innovation and technology (most important growth engine)
Investment Paradox and Stock Market Performance
- Policies encouraging stock ownership succeeded
- Hong Kong Stock Exchange go-to market for Chinese companies (DiDi, Alibaba)
- Problem: stocks way to stay rich, not get rich
- 2015 survey: average retail investor 47 years old, makes substantially more than average household income
- Hong Kong stock performance lagging:
- Hong Kong 2550 index: 8.2% annual return (past 10 years)
- Hang Seng index: 3.56% total return (past 5 years)
- S&P 500: 16.6% annual return
- Many listed companies operate in Hong Kong
- Paradox: shareholder-friendly actions burden residents (layoffs, non-standard employment)
Privatization Examples and Consequences
MTR Privatization (2000)
- Partially privatized Hong Kong MTR (railway company)
- Famous for being land developer to help railway costs
- After privatization: stopped receiving free land grants
- Became more profitable landlord than railway developer
- Land development profits declined:
- 2007: HK$8.3 billion
- 2016: HK$530 million
- Expanded to advertising, telecom services
- More focused on monetizing existing networks than extending them
The Link REIT
- Government sold car parking/retail facilities of public housing to REIT
- Ostensibly to raise funds for housing authority
- IPO'd to markets, subscribed by retail investors
- Tenants criticized: sold too cheap, would hurt shop owners
- Both criticisms proved true
- Link valued up to 5x IPO price
- Raised rents on tenants, driving many into economic hardship
Conclusion and Alternative Path
- Deindustrialization and service focus generated wealth for many
- Hong Kong GDP never higher
- Shenzhen manufacturing workers now afford better homes
- Dirty, difficult, dangerous manufacturing jobs undesirable
- Hong Kong still great for privileged bunch
- Alternative: could have had services plus sophisticated manufacturing
- Electronics industry could have ascended technology ladder
- Hong Kong TSMC not out of question given Western ties
- Opportunity to transfer considerable technologies/expertise
- Instead: let manufacturing go
- Now doesn't produce things people want
- Turned public goods and people into investable assets/cash flow streams
- Considerable cost to majority poor with no way out
- Lesson: importance of economic diversification
