AI summary by TwinMind

Designer Babies - The Problem With China's CRISPR Experiment

Real Engineering

12m 18s

Dr. He Jiankui's Controversial Announcement

  • November 25, 2018: Dr. He Jiankui announced via YouTube birth of genetically engineered twins
  • Used CRISPR technology to edit human embryos - crossing widely considered off-limits threshold
  • Twins referred to as Lulu and Nana
  • 2015: Science and Nature journals stated human germ cell modification should be avoided
  • Scientific community had agreed not to experiment until consensus on application

CRISPR Technology Background

  • DNA structure: nitrogen/carbon-based rings forming 4 chemical codes (adenine, guanine, cytosine, thymine)
  • Read in groups of 3 (codons) contained within genes
  • Genes code for proteins forming biological machines/structures
  • DNA's self-copying ability allows tracing to first cells on earth

CRISPR-Cas9 Mechanism

  • Discovered accidentally by Japanese scientist Yoshizumi Asano in 1987
  • Function unknown for 17 years until identified as bacterial defense against viral DNA
  • Bacteria cut up invading viral DNA, store it, use as guide system for Cas9 enzyme
  • Cas9 uses stored DNA to make guide RNA
  • Two binding conditions: Cas9 must bind to target sequence and specific 3-code variation (PAM)
  • Most PAMs contain GG code
  • Guide RNA binds to alpha helical lobe of Cas9
  • Nuclease lobe binds to DNA flanking part matching guide RNA
  • DNA double helix unwinds through electrostatic interactions
  • Two domains of nuclease lobe cut DNA by ripping protons from water molecules

Gene Editing Applications

  • Last 5 years: learned to direct Cas9 with custom guide RNAs
  • Multiple approaches possible:
    • Deaminase enzyme modification for specific base mutations
    • Homology directed repair for new DNA insertion
    • Simple cutting/removal of undesirable DNA sections

Dr. He's Specific Experiment

  • Target: CCR5 gene section corresponding to Delta 32 mutation
  • Delta 32 confers protection against certain HIV strands
  • Induced mutation similar but not identical to Delta 32 in twins
  • Protocol optimization conducted in mice, monkey, and human cells
  • 31 human embryos used total
  • Embryos grown 5-8 days, 19 deemed normal
  • 2 embryos implanted in mother resulting in twins

Major Scientific Concerns

  • Inadequate specificity testing using parental genetics as reference
  • Parent genetic material subject to randomization during sperm/egg production
  • No two sperm/eggs identical
  • Methodology didn't account for larger genetic code deletions
  • Induced mutation doesn't exactly mirror natural Delta 32 mutation
  • No animal model testing conducted - twins are first test subjects
  • Standard practice requires animal testing for unexpected effects assessment

Medical Necessity Questions

  • No medical need for treatment
  • Biological father HIV positive but used IVF
  • No evidence HIV passes father to child via IVF
  • Procedure medically unnecessary

Mosaicism Risk

  • Claims of complete mutation induction in at least one twin
  • Would require checking DNA of every cell in blastocyst (days 5-9 post-fertilization)
  • Testing would destroy blastocyst - logistical impossibility
  • Only checked subset of blastocyst cells
  • Both twins might have mosaicism (deletion only in cell subset)
  • Different cells in body would have different DNA
  • Effects completely unstudied

Potential Cognitive Effects

  • CCR5 gene linked to learning ability
  • Connection between CCR5 gene product and dampened brain neural connection formation (mice models)
  • Theoretical possibility: induced deletion could positively affect learning ability
  • Too many unknowns for accurate predictions

Regulatory and Publishing Issues

  • Study didn't receive adequate ethics approval board review
  • Chinese law prohibits follow-up with twins
  • Dr. He went missing for almost 2 months
  • Planned peer-reviewed journal publication uncertain
  • Scientific community may never properly review work impact

Future Implications and WHO Response

  • Genetic engineering valuable tool for human well-being/productivity
  • Unaccounted venture may have chilling effect on proper technology development
  • World Health Organization establishing working group for clear guidelines
  • New era of medicine where human genetic modification increasingly real option
  • Need consensus on way forward

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome