AI summary by TwinMind
Designer Babies - The Problem With China's CRISPR Experiment
Real Engineering
12m 18s
Dr. He Jiankui's Controversial Announcement
- November 25, 2018: Dr. He Jiankui announced via YouTube birth of genetically engineered twins
- Used CRISPR technology to edit human embryos - crossing widely considered off-limits threshold
- Twins referred to as Lulu and Nana
- 2015: Science and Nature journals stated human germ cell modification should be avoided
- Scientific community had agreed not to experiment until consensus on application
CRISPR Technology Background
- DNA structure: nitrogen/carbon-based rings forming 4 chemical codes (adenine, guanine, cytosine, thymine)
- Read in groups of 3 (codons) contained within genes
- Genes code for proteins forming biological machines/structures
- DNA's self-copying ability allows tracing to first cells on earth
CRISPR-Cas9 Mechanism
- Discovered accidentally by Japanese scientist Yoshizumi Asano in 1987
- Function unknown for 17 years until identified as bacterial defense against viral DNA
- Bacteria cut up invading viral DNA, store it, use as guide system for Cas9 enzyme
- Cas9 uses stored DNA to make guide RNA
- Two binding conditions: Cas9 must bind to target sequence and specific 3-code variation (PAM)
- Most PAMs contain GG code
- Guide RNA binds to alpha helical lobe of Cas9
- Nuclease lobe binds to DNA flanking part matching guide RNA
- DNA double helix unwinds through electrostatic interactions
- Two domains of nuclease lobe cut DNA by ripping protons from water molecules
Gene Editing Applications
- Last 5 years: learned to direct Cas9 with custom guide RNAs
- Multiple approaches possible:
- Deaminase enzyme modification for specific base mutations
- Homology directed repair for new DNA insertion
- Simple cutting/removal of undesirable DNA sections
Dr. He's Specific Experiment
- Target: CCR5 gene section corresponding to Delta 32 mutation
- Delta 32 confers protection against certain HIV strands
- Induced mutation similar but not identical to Delta 32 in twins
- Protocol optimization conducted in mice, monkey, and human cells
- 31 human embryos used total
- Embryos grown 5-8 days, 19 deemed normal
- 2 embryos implanted in mother resulting in twins
Major Scientific Concerns
- Inadequate specificity testing using parental genetics as reference
- Parent genetic material subject to randomization during sperm/egg production
- No two sperm/eggs identical
- Methodology didn't account for larger genetic code deletions
- Induced mutation doesn't exactly mirror natural Delta 32 mutation
- No animal model testing conducted - twins are first test subjects
- Standard practice requires animal testing for unexpected effects assessment
Medical Necessity Questions
- No medical need for treatment
- Biological father HIV positive but used IVF
- No evidence HIV passes father to child via IVF
- Procedure medically unnecessary
Mosaicism Risk
- Claims of complete mutation induction in at least one twin
- Would require checking DNA of every cell in blastocyst (days 5-9 post-fertilization)
- Testing would destroy blastocyst - logistical impossibility
- Only checked subset of blastocyst cells
- Both twins might have mosaicism (deletion only in cell subset)
- Different cells in body would have different DNA
- Effects completely unstudied
Potential Cognitive Effects
- CCR5 gene linked to learning ability
- Connection between CCR5 gene product and dampened brain neural connection formation (mice models)
- Theoretical possibility: induced deletion could positively affect learning ability
- Too many unknowns for accurate predictions
Regulatory and Publishing Issues
- Study didn't receive adequate ethics approval board review
- Chinese law prohibits follow-up with twins
- Dr. He went missing for almost 2 months
- Planned peer-reviewed journal publication uncertain
- Scientific community may never properly review work impact
Future Implications and WHO Response
- Genetic engineering valuable tool for human well-being/productivity
- Unaccounted venture may have chilling effect on proper technology development
- World Health Organization establishing working group for clear guidelines
- New era of medicine where human genetic modification increasingly real option
- Need consensus on way forward
