AI summary by TwinMind

Did the Big Bang happen?

Sabine Hossenfelder

16m 58s

Universe Expansion and Big Bang Theory

  • Edwin Hubble discovered universe expansion - nearby galaxies moving away from us
  • Einstein's general relativity explains expansion - space responds to matter/energy by expanding
  • As time passes, matter/energy become more thinly diluted on average
    • Inside galaxies: matter clumps, space doesn't expand
    • Video focuses on average over entire universe
  • Reverse extrapolation: if universe expands today, matter was squeezed together in past
    • Higher density = higher temperature in early universe
    • Matter was dense and hot initially

Early Universe Conditions

  • At extreme temperatures: atoms couldn't keep electrons
  • Earlier phase: no individual atomic nuclei, just plasma of elementary particles
    • Quarks, gluons, photons - "alphabet soup of physics"
  • Before that: unknown territory
    • Never tested matter at energy densities higher than Large Hadron Collider can produce

Big Bang Singularity Problem

  • Ignoring limitations, continuing Einstein's equations backward in time
  • Find energy density of matter must once have been infinitely large
  • This singularity occurs ~13.7 billion years ago = Big Bang
  • Big Bang didn't happen at particular place - happened everywhere
  • Most physicists (including speaker) think singularity is mathematical artifact, not reality
    • Einstein's theory stops working, need better theory
    • Analogy: water drop pinching off tap has singular surface curvature only if described as smooth fluid
    • Taking atomic structure into account removes singularity
  • Should use theory including quantum properties of space
  • Unfortunately, don't have such theory for calculation
  • Reliable conclusion: extrapolating Einstein's equations gives Big Bang singularity
  • Think this isn't physically correct - don't know how universe began

Why Physicists Propose Alternative Theories

  • Physicists can't accept "we don't know" as answer
  • Change extrapolation by using different equations
  • Can do "pretty much anything you want" with different equations
  • Problem: shouldn't just make up equations arbitrarily

Stone Throwing Analogy - Scientific Method

  • Throwing stone: given initial position/velocity, calculate where it lands using Newton's laws
  • Initial state + evolution law = prediction
  • Can work backward: from final state, deduce initial conditions
  • Can test equations multiple ways:
    • Throw many stones with different initial conditions
    • Take video, check position at any moment agrees with equations
  • In cosmology: only have one universe
    • Can't test equations by changing initial conditions
    • Can't take snapshots (would need to wait 13 billion years)
    • Only have observations of final state

Cosmological Testing Problem

  • Can take any equation, calculate what happened earlier
  • For each equation, some earlier state will agree with observed final state
  • Seems like can only test combination of initial state + equation, not separately
  • Can't determine what either is individually

Two Reasons Situation Isn't Completely Bad

First Reason: Confirmed Equations

  • Equations for entire universe confirmed by other observations using standard scientific methods
  • Einstein's general relativity confirmed by many experiments:
    • Redshift in gravitational field
    • Perihelion precession of Mercury
  • Take well-confirmed equations, apply to entire universe
  • Doesn't entirely solve problem - cosmology uses additional assumptions:
    • Cosmological principle
    • Dark matter and dark energy assumptions

Second Reason: Simplicity Criterion

  • Einstein's equations + initial values provide simple explanation for current observations
  • "Simple" means quantitative simplicity - need few numbers to specify
  • Different equation would require more difficult initial state, more numbers
  • Theory wouldn't explain as much
  • Equations like machine: input assumptions about beginning, output prediction for today
  • Good explanation if:
    • Prediction agrees with observations
    • Initial state was simple (simpler = better)
  • Only need observations from today, don't need to wait billion years

Standard Cosmological Model (Lambda-CDM)

  • Simplest explanation found: Lambda-CDM based on Einstein's equations
  • Explains multiple observations:
    • Cosmic microwave background
    • Galactic filaments
    • Both came from same initial distribution of matter
  • Different equation would still have some initial state, but wouldn't be simple
  • Simplicity requirement super important - without it, can't do science at all
  • Example: Earth created 6000 years ago with dinosaur bones in place
    • Not wrong, but not simple, so not scientific explanation
    • Evolution and geology are simple explanations

Alternative Origin Theories Problems

  • Physicists change equations going back in time
  • Equations similar to Einstein's at present, differ early in universe
  • Need different initial state, might not find Big Bang
  • Can always do this - for any evolution law, some initial state gives right prediction
  • Problem: makes simple explanation more complicated
  • These theories not scientifically justifiable
  • Don't improve explanatory power of standard model
  • All complicated ideas unnecessary to explain observations

Worse Problem - Future Observations

  • Might think better observations will show current model no longer simplest
  • But if earlier universe phase was more complicated than simple initial state used today
  • Couldn't use scientific method to decide if correct
  • Scientific method doesn't cover this case - science fails
  • Better observations can improve current models slightly
  • Eventually hit problem: more complicated explanations always possible, never scientifically justified

Examples of Alternative Theories

Poplawski's Torsion Theory

  • Changes general relativity by adding torsion terms to equations
  • Removes Big Bang singularity, replaces with bounce
  • Universe came from bottleneck similar to black hole without singularity
  • Can do this mathematically, but many other things possible too
  • "There's math for broccoli" - why not make universe out of broccoli?

Other Examples

  • Penrose's cyclic cosmology
  • Ekpyrotic universe: starts with collision of higher-dimensional membranes
  • Five-dimensional black hole origin
  • Universe began with gas of strings
  • No boundary proposal (Hartle-Hawking): universe began with only space, no time
  • Geometrogenesis: universe began as highly connected network, lost connections, condensed into current space

Infinite Possibilities Problem

  • So many different ideas because physicists' current method allows infinitely many stories
  • Physicists make predictions for observables
  • Since hypotheses already unnecessarily complicated, can make them fit any possible observation
  • Even ruling out some leaves infinitely many others to make up
  • Doesn't mean ideas are wrong - means can't tell if right or wrong
  • Tim Palmer suggests calling them "a-scientific"

Conclusion - Limits of Science

  • Facing limits of science itself regarding universe origin
  • Question we'll never be able to answer
  • Like question "why women pluck eyebrows then paint them back on"
  • Headlines about universe origin should be read as "creation myths written in language of mathematics"
  • Not wrong, but not scientific either
  • Big Bang is simplest explanation we know, probably wrong
  • That's all science can tell us

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome