AI summary by TwinMind
D-L Stewart: Scenes from a Black trans life | TED
TED
15m 19s
Introduction and Identity
- DL Stewart, faculty member at Colorado State University
- Identifies as both black and transgender
- Topic: How black trans lives matter through personal narratives and historical context
Scene 1: Body as Sovereign Country
- Personal reflection on body sovereignty
- Sovereign defined: superlative quality, supreme power, autonomy, independence
- Body defies societal boxes and binaries ("are you a boy or girl")
- Claims power to name, define, and be oneself
- Body as first site of resistance
- Black trans lives matter = claim to sovereignty
- Black trans people as vanguard who push movements forward, set trends, create new worlds
Historical Context: Juneteenth and Stonewall Intersection
- Black trans lives caught between Juneteenth emancipation and Stonewall emancipation
- Simultaneously seen but unseen
- Unseen by anti-blackness in queer/trans movements
- Unseen by transphobia in black movements
- Sovereignty blocked by systems designed to contain, define, erase black trans bodies
Scene 2: Medical Gatekeeping Experience
- Therapy session for document changes
- Therapist must declare patient "man enough" for legal recognition
- Doctor's assessment: gender presentation "more neutral really"
- Stewart dressed fully in men's clothing (buttons on right side, men's pants, Denzel Washington haircut)
- Therapist still sees "black woman" due to racialized gender perceptions
Historical Analysis: Black Bodies and Gender
- Black women's bodies made "genderless" in white imagination
- References to mammy, Sapphire, mandingo stereotypes
- White imagination powerful enough to turn fantasies into realities
- Black people "bred like horses, fed like turtles to alligators, branded like cattle"
- Gender didn't matter as long as body parts could generate profit
- Black body made "not white" therefore "not worthy of gender"
Black Femininity and Masculinity Under White Supremacy
- Black femininity denied under plantation system
- Black women seen as "beast or porn star" - neither proper gender
- "Angry black woman" cannot escape stereotypes (reference to First Lady)
- Black manhood "lays flaccid in white men's dominance"
- Parallels drawn between NFL Combine, prison intake, slave bill of sale
- Body measurements, speed testing, teeth/cavity inspection
- Made into "stud or farce" for profit and entertainment
- Black masculinity contained as athletes and comics, "not a threat"
Transgressive Nature of Blackness
- Blackness inherently transgressive = violation of social acceptability boundaries
- Once free from social acceptability, blackness challenges gender limitations
- Black people as "fugitives escaping gender surveillance"
- Right to exist, live free, proclaim beauty in what was made ugly
- Black lives and trans lives both defy convention
Scene 3: School Playground Segregation
- Childhood memory of recess
- Boys lined up on one side, girls on other
- Boys played in closed-off street
- Girls (including Stewart) walked across street to fenced park
- Stewart stood at fence watching boys play ball, be loud, rough, sweaty
- Accused of "thinking naughty thoughts"
Violence Against Black Trans People
- Black trans people "sissified and bull daggered"
- Seen as "boys in dresses and girls in suits"
- Black transgressive body caught in binary fantasies
- Black trans lives written off as "merely gay effeminate or lesbian butch"
- Majority of trans people murdered in this country are black trans women
- When manhood located "between one's legs" and defined in opposition to womanhood
- Trans masculinity made to "fade into nothingness"
- Black trans men become "illusions of manhood, women merely playing at being men"
Scene 4: Anticipating Transition Challenges
- Conversation with therapist about physical transition
- Moving from "social threat of angry black womanhood" to "physical threat of looming black manhood"
- Concerns about neighbors' reactions after 2+ years of recognition
- When will cops be called to "contain and erase" presence
- Anticipating "purse clutching, sidewalk crossing"
- What does it mean to "become a brute"
- Therapist stunned by awareness; Stewart responds "I can't afford not to"
Call to Action: Making Black Trans Lives Matter
- Not looking for "slave saviors" - "we have each other"
- Quote from Lilla Watson: "If you have come here to help me you are wasting your time but if you have come because you recognize your liberation is bound up in mine then let us work together"
- Personal ethic: being transformative, loudly, and mindfully
Three Ways to Support
- Transform thinking about blackness and gender
- Be loud - take risks to confront false assumptions, others' fears and biases
- Be mindful - pay attention and believe what black trans people say about their own lives
Personal Details
- Pronouns: they/them/their and he/him/his
- Getting pronouns right takes practice
- Being transformative, loud, and mindful matters because black trans lives matter
- "My life matters, my body is a sovereign country and my first site of resistance"
