AI summary by TwinMind
Do Companies That Go "Woke" Actually Go Broke?
How Money Works
13m 54s
Introduction to "Go Woke, Go Broke" Theory
- Companies going woke may actually go broke - potential billion dollar investment opportunity
- Major hedge funds ignoring this trend
- No perceived consequences for appealing to far-left wing
- Bud Light March Madness advertisement example
- Reference to Pepsi's controversial Kendall Jenner ad that drew criticism from Martin Luther King Jr's daughter Bernice
Definition and Impact of Corporate Wokeness
- Trend of companies aligning communications, products, advertising with Progressive/liberal values
- Companies perform worse financially after branding changes
- Brand managers alienating customer base with contradictory messaging
- Common customer backlash and product boycotts over ideological issues
Bud Light Case Study - Financial Impact
- Anheuser-Busch partnership with Dylan Mulvaney on Instagram/TikTok posts
- Conservative backlash and boycotts
- CEO earnings call attempt to clarify: "one influencer, one post, not a campaign"
- Progressive customers also boycotted after company distanced itself
- Brand lost customers from both political sides
- Sales slump: 23% in May compared to previous year
- Cost: $60 million in 31 days
- Lost market share to Miller Lite, Coors Light, Modelo Especial
- Modelo Especial overtook Bud Light as America's best-selling beer same month
Three Reasons Companies Make These Mistakes
Reason 1: Failure to Adapt Marketing to New Platforms
- User-generated social media platforms allow unpredictable audience engagement
- Online advertising (Google AdSense, Facebook ads) significantly cheaper than legacy channels (TV, radio, newspapers)
- Influencer marketing leverages built-in audience trust
- Dylan Mulvaney had 11.5 million followers across Instagram/TikTok
- Market segmentation strategy normally works for different demographics
- Apple example: advertises iPhone cameras/App Store to young creatives vs. data security to professionals
- Procter & Gamble's Gillette "Best a Man Can Be" campaign (2019) showcased toxic masculinity, received negative response from target male audience
- Viral nature makes audience control difficult
- Bud Light stock drop: 15% (within normal trading volatility)
Reason 2: It Works for Decision Makers (Not Companies)
- Companies change entire business offerings, not just advertising
- Alter product offerings and hiring practices
- Disney example: progressive messaging in films/TV, declining viewership in Marvel/Lucasfilm franchises
- Disney employees: 180,000+
- Hollywood progressive culture makes securing talent easier
- Ideological hiring as excuse for cheaper talent
- Ocean Gate case study: CEO Stockton Rush hired "young free-thinking engineers," avoided "50 year old white guys" with submarine experience
- Similar patterns in FTX, Theranos, WeWork
- Disney stock: down 60% from 2021 high, but up from when "went woke"
- Analysts cite streaming service problems, leadership changes, declining viewership
Reason 3: When Done Right, It Increases Performance
- Results in higher sales, brand loyalty, staff retention
- Chartered Institute of Marketing report: companies with strong social alignment outperform neutral companies
- Rolling Stone article and ESG survey support this finding
Successful Examples of Corporate Positioning
- Keurig Dr Pepper: acquired Dr Pepper Snapple 2018 for $18.7 billion, now 3rd largest beverage company in America
- Annual gross profits: $7.3 billion in 2022 (5% increase, outperformed industry standard)
- United Airlines: planned 50% of pilot trainees to be women/people of color, Q4 2022 profits $843 million (beat investor expectations)
- Chick-fil-A: conservative values, still outperforming in competitive fast food market
- Carhartt also mentioned as successful example
Investment Strategy Implications
- Markets can stay irrational longer than investors can stay solvent
- Confirmation bias important consideration
- Handful of angry customers typically outweighed by positive press
- Most failed examples had serious underlying issues beyond social messaging
- Corporate messaging trend not going anywhere
- Good investing focuses on long-term trends
