AI summary by TwinMind
Do Stock Splits ACTUALLY Boost Returns? What the Numbers Say
The Plain Bagel
14m 40s
Introduction and Motivation
- Video sponsored by Daily Upside newsletter
- Recent TikTok investment videos claiming stock splits = guaranteed returns
- Upcoming splits: Google, Amazon, Shopify
- Claims of doubling money by chasing stock splits
- Author's skeptical analysis using Excel spreadsheet data
Stock Split Mechanics Overview
- Stock splits = arbitrary accounting action
- Company divides shares into smaller units, adjusts price accordingly
- No real impact on investors or company value
- Example: 2-for-1 split cuts price in half, doubles share count
- Google's 24:1 split: $2500 → $125 per share (20 units vs 1)
- "Cutting company pizza into more slices"
Historical Context and Research
- Tesla's 5:1 split (August 2020) rallied significantly
- Apple also performed well after 2020 split
- 1996 study found 8 percentage points excess returns in year following split
- Theoretical reasons for outperformance:
- Improved investor access and liquidity
- $100 stock vs $1000 stock accessibility
- More precise trading amounts
- Increased options trading accessibility
Modern Market Changes
- Fractional shares available since 2020 (Robin Hood, other brokers)
- Reduced importance of stock splits for accessibility
- Marginal benefit likely smaller in current market
- Focus on recent splits for relevant analysis
Research Methodology
- Data source: Fidelity's online stock split calendar
- Time period: January 1, 2020 to April 1, 2022
- Price collection dates:
- Day before split effective date
- Day immediately after
- 7 days after
- 30 days after
- 91 days after
- 365 days after
- Dual analysis: effective date vs announcement date
- All prices adjusted for splits for comparison
- Final sample: 55 stock split examples
- 29 had complete 12-month data
Results: Effective Date Analysis
- High standard deviation = returns "all over the place"
- Average returns:
- 1-day: 1.9%
- 12-month: 12.7%
- Excess returns vs S&P 500 (using VOO as proxy):
- Short-term: some outperformance
- 12-month: meaningful underperformance
- S&P 500 nearly doubled portfolio's average 12-month return
Outlier Analysis
- Two outliers contributed 1.7 percentage points to 1.9% return
- Generics Biotech and Trisiana Life Sciences
- Both micro-cap, highly volatile positions
- Lost majority of share values post-split
- Trisiana (TLSA) vs Tesla (TSLA) ticker similarity
- Trisiana split occurred 1 month before Tesla's
Announcement Date Analysis
- 12-month results: not promising
- Median results more moderate than averages (outlier skewing)
- 1-day outperformance when split announced
- Challenge: must predict which stocks will announce splits
- Difficult to build reliable trading strategy
Large-Cap Company Filter
- Reanalyzed with market cap >$10 billion only
- Sample size: 21 companies (12 with full historical data)
- Effective date: more material 1-day excess return
- Announcement date: mixed results
- High standard deviations limit confidence
- Very small sample size limitation
Analysis Limitations
- Limited to 2-year period
- Unique external factors could influence results
- Small sample sizes
- Should not put undue weight on analysis
- Could dive deeper into 1-day return relationships
Conclusions
- Stock splits not reliable source of outsized returns
- 1-day boost possible, longer-term often underperformed S&P 500
- Far cry from "once in a lifetime opportunity" claims
- Google, Amazon, Shopify splits: no prediction of poor performance
- Market irrationality possible (GameStop example)
- Self-fulfilling prophecy if belief persists
- Little evidence for long-term outperformance
- Investment thesis should pass "high school assignment" test
Sponsor Segment: Daily Upside
- Free business and finance newsletter
- 6 days per week delivery
- Clear, concise, witty market insights
- Founded by journalists, scholars, finance professionals
- 3 stories daily + bonus headlines
- Example: Formula One racing rise in US
- $2.1 billion revenue in 2021
- Drive to Survive docuseries impact
