AI summary by TwinMind

Do Stock Splits ACTUALLY Boost Returns? What the Numbers Say

The Plain Bagel

14m 40s

Introduction and Motivation

  • Video sponsored by Daily Upside newsletter
  • Recent TikTok investment videos claiming stock splits = guaranteed returns
  • Upcoming splits: Google, Amazon, Shopify
  • Claims of doubling money by chasing stock splits
  • Author's skeptical analysis using Excel spreadsheet data

Stock Split Mechanics Overview

  • Stock splits = arbitrary accounting action
  • Company divides shares into smaller units, adjusts price accordingly
  • No real impact on investors or company value
  • Example: 2-for-1 split cuts price in half, doubles share count
  • Google's 24:1 split: $2500 → $125 per share (20 units vs 1)
  • "Cutting company pizza into more slices"

Historical Context and Research

  • Tesla's 5:1 split (August 2020) rallied significantly
  • Apple also performed well after 2020 split
  • 1996 study found 8 percentage points excess returns in year following split
  • Theoretical reasons for outperformance:
    • Improved investor access and liquidity
    • $100 stock vs $1000 stock accessibility
    • More precise trading amounts
    • Increased options trading accessibility

Modern Market Changes

  • Fractional shares available since 2020 (Robin Hood, other brokers)
  • Reduced importance of stock splits for accessibility
  • Marginal benefit likely smaller in current market
  • Focus on recent splits for relevant analysis

Research Methodology

  • Data source: Fidelity's online stock split calendar
  • Time period: January 1, 2020 to April 1, 2022
  • Price collection dates:
    • Day before split effective date
    • Day immediately after
    • 7 days after
    • 30 days after
    • 91 days after
    • 365 days after
  • Dual analysis: effective date vs announcement date
  • All prices adjusted for splits for comparison
  • Final sample: 55 stock split examples
  • 29 had complete 12-month data

Results: Effective Date Analysis

  • High standard deviation = returns "all over the place"
  • Average returns:
    • 1-day: 1.9%
    • 12-month: 12.7%
  • Excess returns vs S&P 500 (using VOO as proxy):
    • Short-term: some outperformance
    • 12-month: meaningful underperformance
    • S&P 500 nearly doubled portfolio's average 12-month return

Outlier Analysis

  • Two outliers contributed 1.7 percentage points to 1.9% return
  • Generics Biotech and Trisiana Life Sciences
  • Both micro-cap, highly volatile positions
  • Lost majority of share values post-split
  • Trisiana (TLSA) vs Tesla (TSLA) ticker similarity
  • Trisiana split occurred 1 month before Tesla's

Announcement Date Analysis

  • 12-month results: not promising
  • Median results more moderate than averages (outlier skewing)
  • 1-day outperformance when split announced
  • Challenge: must predict which stocks will announce splits
  • Difficult to build reliable trading strategy

Large-Cap Company Filter

  • Reanalyzed with market cap >$10 billion only
  • Sample size: 21 companies (12 with full historical data)
  • Effective date: more material 1-day excess return
  • Announcement date: mixed results
  • High standard deviations limit confidence
  • Very small sample size limitation

Analysis Limitations

  • Limited to 2-year period
  • Unique external factors could influence results
  • Small sample sizes
  • Should not put undue weight on analysis
  • Could dive deeper into 1-day return relationships

Conclusions

  • Stock splits not reliable source of outsized returns
  • 1-day boost possible, longer-term often underperformed S&P 500
  • Far cry from "once in a lifetime opportunity" claims
  • Google, Amazon, Shopify splits: no prediction of poor performance
  • Market irrationality possible (GameStop example)
  • Self-fulfilling prophecy if belief persists
  • Little evidence for long-term outperformance
  • Investment thesis should pass "high school assignment" test

Sponsor Segment: Daily Upside

  • Free business and finance newsletter
  • 6 days per week delivery
  • Clear, concise, witty market insights
  • Founded by journalists, scholars, finance professionals
  • 3 stories daily + bonus headlines
  • Example: Formula One racing rise in US
  • $2.1 billion revenue in 2021
  • Drive to Survive docuseries impact

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome