AI summary by TwinMind

Does a Cheap 2018 Smartphone beat a 2016 Flagship?

Mrwhosetheboss

7m 1s

Phone Comparison Setup

  • Dilemma: $250 budget - buy cheap current year phone or flagship from 2+ years ago
  • Phones tested: Xiaomi Mi A2 ($250 brand new) vs Google Pixel ($250 refurb with warranty)
  • Pixel chosen for stock software performance longevity

Performance Analysis

  • Xiaomi Mi A2: Snapdragon 616 (newer, lower tier)
    • 8-core CPU vs Pixel's 4-core
    • Slightly faster CPU performance than Pixel
    • Significantly weaker graphics performance
  • Google Pixel: Snapdragon 821 (older, flagship tier)
    • 4GB RAM
    • Day one silky smooth performance maintained
    • Doubles graphics performance of Mi A2
    • Qualcomm reserves graphics performance for 8-series flagship chips
  • Gaming: Performance disparity noticeable on top games, but Mi A2 still capable

Display Quality Comparison

  • Mi A2: 6-inch LCD, 18:9 aspect ratio
    • Modern high screen-to-body ratio
    • Rounded corners
    • Larger screen real estate
  • Google Pixel: AMOLED display
    • Superior contrast and colors vs Mi A2's LCD
    • No rounded corners, lower screen-to-body ratio
    • Comparable resolution
  • General trend: 2018 mid-range gets better form factor, 2016 flagships get better display quality

Build Quality Assessment

  • Both phones: Solid aluminum construction
  • Mi A2: Slimmer, more ergonomically curved
  • Mi A2 feels nicer in hand despite being budget device
  • 2018 budget phones can include glass construction (Moto G6 example)
  • Negligible difference in build quality/materials between categories

Camera Comparison

  • Google Pixel:
    • Top-tier imaging software
    • More capable hardware, better sensor quality/pixel size
    • More refined photos
    • Steadier 4K video
    • Lens blur feature (requires slow phone raising, less intuitive)
  • Mi A2:
    • Dual camera advantage
    • Reliable DSLR-like bokeh effect
    • More consistent portrait mode vs Pixel's lens blur

Missing Features in Budget Phones

  • Budget phones sacrifice "extras" due to strict budget constraints
  • Features typically missing: fast charging, splash resistance, wireless charging
  • Note: Pixel lacks IP certification and wireless charging (exception to 2016 flagship rule)
  • Most 2016 flagships included these features

Software Updates

  • Mi A2: Android 8.1 bundled, 9.0 update coming soon
  • Google Pixel: Exception - gets updates due to being Google phone
  • Most 2016 flagships already outdated software-wise
  • Flagships get updates more often but can't compensate for 2-year head start
  • Average users likely won't notice Android version differences, especially with manufacturer skins

Refurbished Phone Considerations

  • Commonly overlooked complications with older refurb phones
  • Higher likelihood of failures
  • Battery degradation expected
  • Potential scuffs and marks
  • Additional hassle of dealing with used devices

Final Recommendation

  • Unless exceptional deal on older flagship, choose newer phone
  • Trade-offs with newer budget phone:
    • Lose: display quality, graphics performance, water resistance, wireless charging
    • Gain: equal or better performance in most other aspects, avoid used device hassles
  • 2018 $250 price point increasingly competitive
  • Phones like Mi A2 and Moto G6 hit sweet spot of value vs features

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome