AI summary by TwinMind
Does a Cheap 2018 Smartphone beat a 2016 Flagship?
Mrwhosetheboss
7m 1s
Phone Comparison Setup
- Dilemma: $250 budget - buy cheap current year phone or flagship from 2+ years ago
- Phones tested: Xiaomi Mi A2 ($250 brand new) vs Google Pixel ($250 refurb with warranty)
- Pixel chosen for stock software performance longevity
Performance Analysis
- Xiaomi Mi A2: Snapdragon 616 (newer, lower tier)
- 8-core CPU vs Pixel's 4-core
- Slightly faster CPU performance than Pixel
- Significantly weaker graphics performance
- Google Pixel: Snapdragon 821 (older, flagship tier)
- 4GB RAM
- Day one silky smooth performance maintained
- Doubles graphics performance of Mi A2
- Qualcomm reserves graphics performance for 8-series flagship chips
- Gaming: Performance disparity noticeable on top games, but Mi A2 still capable
Display Quality Comparison
- Mi A2: 6-inch LCD, 18:9 aspect ratio
- Modern high screen-to-body ratio
- Rounded corners
- Larger screen real estate
- Google Pixel: AMOLED display
- Superior contrast and colors vs Mi A2's LCD
- No rounded corners, lower screen-to-body ratio
- Comparable resolution
- General trend: 2018 mid-range gets better form factor, 2016 flagships get better display quality
Build Quality Assessment
- Both phones: Solid aluminum construction
- Mi A2: Slimmer, more ergonomically curved
- Mi A2 feels nicer in hand despite being budget device
- 2018 budget phones can include glass construction (Moto G6 example)
- Negligible difference in build quality/materials between categories
Camera Comparison
- Google Pixel:
- Top-tier imaging software
- More capable hardware, better sensor quality/pixel size
- More refined photos
- Steadier 4K video
- Lens blur feature (requires slow phone raising, less intuitive)
- Mi A2:
- Dual camera advantage
- Reliable DSLR-like bokeh effect
- More consistent portrait mode vs Pixel's lens blur
Missing Features in Budget Phones
- Budget phones sacrifice "extras" due to strict budget constraints
- Features typically missing: fast charging, splash resistance, wireless charging
- Note: Pixel lacks IP certification and wireless charging (exception to 2016 flagship rule)
- Most 2016 flagships included these features
Software Updates
- Mi A2: Android 8.1 bundled, 9.0 update coming soon
- Google Pixel: Exception - gets updates due to being Google phone
- Most 2016 flagships already outdated software-wise
- Flagships get updates more often but can't compensate for 2-year head start
- Average users likely won't notice Android version differences, especially with manufacturer skins
Refurbished Phone Considerations
- Commonly overlooked complications with older refurb phones
- Higher likelihood of failures
- Battery degradation expected
- Potential scuffs and marks
- Additional hassle of dealing with used devices
Final Recommendation
- Unless exceptional deal on older flagship, choose newer phone
- Trade-offs with newer budget phone:
- Lose: display quality, graphics performance, water resistance, wireless charging
- Gain: equal or better performance in most other aspects, avoid used device hassles
- 2018 $250 price point increasingly competitive
- Phones like Mi A2 and Moto G6 hit sweet spot of value vs features
