AI summary by TwinMind
Does Apple’s Crash Detection Work? We Totaled Some Cars to Find Out. | WSJ
The Wall Street Journal
7m 5s
Test Setup and Location
- Field testing conducted in Monroe, Michigan at junkyards with derby drivers
- Producer Kenny's hometown, worked with world-class derby drivers
- Safety precautions: 4-point harness, helmet, certified EMT Nicole Branham on standby
- All non-drivers maintained safe distance during crashes
Technology Overview
- Apple introduced crash detection in iPhone 14 models and Apple Watch Series 8/Ultra
- Feature automatically connects users with Emergency Services when severe crash detected
- Google added similar feature to Pixel phones 3 years prior
- Apple: crash detection enabled out of box
- Google: must be manually enabled in Personal Safety app
Technical Specifications
- iPhone 14 models and Watch Series 8/Ultra equipped with:
- 3-axis gyroscope
- High G-force accelerometer sampling motion 3000+ times per second
- Detection criteria:
- Abrupt speed changes/stops
- Pressure changes when airbags deploy
- Sound level measurements via microphones
- Requires closed windows for optimal detection
Test Equipment Setup
- Michael Berry (3-time Figure Eight Derby champion) driving derby car with:
- Apple Watch Ultra on wrist
- iPhone 14 and Google Pixel strapped inside
- Ford Taurus (stationary target):
- iPhone 14 Pro Max mounted to dashboard vents
- Pixel 6 mounted to dashboard
First Crash Test Results
- Derby car traveling ~25 mph into Ford Taurus
- Apple Watch Ultra: triggered after 5-10 second delay, displayed emergency contact prompt
- 10-second countdown before auto-calling emergency services if not cancelled
- Google Pixel in derby car: no trigger
- Phones in stationary Taurus: no trigger
Second Crash Test Results
- Google Pixel in derby car: triggered, displayed "I'm okay" prompt
- Phones in stationary Taurus: still no trigger
- Identified issues with stationary vehicle testing
Third Test - Moving Vehicle
- Used Dodge van as target, drove around first to establish "driving" status
- Closed windows before crash to optimize airbag pressure detection
- Results:
- Michael's Apple Watch: detected crash
- Nearby iPhone: triggered due to proximity
- Phones in crashed Dodge with deployed airbags: no detection
Company Responses
- Apple spokesman explanation:
- Junkyard conditions insufficient signals for iPhone trigger
- Stationary cars not connected to Bluetooth/CarPlay
- Vehicles didn't travel sufficient distance to indicate driving
- Google spokesman explanation:
- Algorithm must first detect driving state
- Crash detection only works after driving detection established
- Can detect crashes even if vehicle becomes stationary
Key Findings
- Technology potentially life-saving when functioning properly
- 3 instances could have triggered emergency calls within 30 seconds
- Gray areas exist regarding:
- Severity threshold for crash detection
- System's ability to establish vehicle occupancy
- Apple acknowledges limitations in fine print without specifics
