AI summary by TwinMind

Does the Universe have Higher Dimensions? Part 2

Sabine Hossenfelder

11m 9s

Background and Previous Work

  • Continues previous week's video on history of extra dimensions
  • Historical context: Adding 7 dimensions of space to normal 3 dimensions allows describing all fundamental forces geometrically
  • Promising idea for unified theory of physics

Early String Theory Development

  • Edward Witten (early 1980s) found intriguing that 7 additional dimensions = maximum for supergravity
  • Numerical coincidence led nowhere
  • Kaluza-Klein theory (geometric construction of fundamental forces) has unsolved problems:
    • Radii of extra dimensions unstable (could grow/shrink)
    • Incompatible with observation
    • Chirality problem: particles come in left-handed/right-handed versions behaving differently
    • Observational fact doesn't fit Kaluza-Klein idea
  • Witten worried about chirality in 1981 paper

String Theory Fundamentals

  • Fundamental entities are strings (not made of anything else)
  • Everything else made from these strings
  • Question: How many dimensions needed for strings to wiggle correctly?
  • First answer: 26 dimensions (25 space + 1 time)
  • With supersymmetry: 10 dimensions (9 space + 1 time)
  • String theory doesn't work properly in fewer dimensions

Extra Dimensions Problem

  • Same issue as Kaluza-Klein theory century ago: If extra dimensions exist, where are they?
  • String theorists' answer: Can't see them because curled up to small radii
  • Extra dimensions curled into complicated geometrical shapes called Calabi-Yau manifolds

Higher Harmonics and Predictions

  • Curling up creates higher harmonics in strings (same as Kaluza-Klein theory)
  • With enough energy, strings oscillate at frequencies matching extra dimension radii
  • String theory does make predictions: higher harmonics should exist
  • Problem: Need extremely high energies to create them
  • Small radii = high frequencies = high energies
  • String theory doesn't specify exact energy requirements
  • Extra dimensions must be small (haven't seen them yet)
  • Could be just out of reach - next bigger particle collider might create higher harmonics

Gravitational Force in Extra Dimensions

  • Newton's 1/r² law is geometrical
  • Gravitational force of point mass falls with 1/r² because sphere surface grows with r²
  • With additional dimensions (3 + n where n = positive integer):
    • Sphere surface increases with r^(2+n)
    • Gravitational force drops with 1/r^(2+n)
  • More dimensions = force drops much faster with distance
  • Geometric consideration remains valid in Einstein's general relativity

Curled Up Extra Dimensions Effect

  • Extra dimensions are curled up (otherwise we'd have noticed them)
  • Force lines can only spread out to distance comparable to extra dimension radius
  • After this, force lines continue in three large directions only
  • On distances much larger than extra dimension radius: returns to usual 1/r² law (which we observe)

Black Hole Creation Possibility

  • Normal 3D space: Cannot create black holes (gravity too weak)
  • With extra dimensions: Gravitational force falls faster going away from mass
  • Getting closer to mass = force gets much stronger than in 3D only
  • Makes black hole creation much easier
  • If extra dimensions large enough: could create black holes at Large Hadron Collider
  • In practice: LHC did not produce black holes
  • Means extra dimensions (if they exist) are really small
  • Size depends on number of extra dimensions: roughly below 1 micrometer

Space Travel Through Extra Dimensions

  • Brief answer: No, and would be pointless
  • Gravitational force can spread into extra dimensions
  • Matter (what we're made of) cannot go there
  • Matter bound to 3D slice called "brane" (b-r-a-n-e, not b-r-a-i-n)
  • Generalization of membrane
  • We are stuck on this 3D brane (our universe)
  • Even if not stuck: nothing in extra dimensions anyway
  • Can't travel faster there than in our universe

Common Misconceptions About Shortcuts

  • People think extra dimensions provide shortcuts due to illustrations
  • Idea: Universe like bent sheet, go perpendicular to arrive at distant point faster
  • Reality: Don't need extra dimensions for that
  • These are called wormholes - can exist in ordinary general relativity with 3D space
  • Embedding space in illustrations doesn't actually exist in general relativity
  • Explains confusion about universe expansion ("expands into what?" - doesn't expand into anything, just expands)

Scientific Plausibility Ranking for Sci-Fi Travel

  • 3rd place: Hyperdrives
    • Nice idea but makes no sense scientifically
  • 2nd place: Wormholes
    • Exist mathematically
    • No one knows how to create them
  • 1st place: Warp drives
    • Mathematics works out
    • In principle possible to create
    • Must stay below speed of light limit
  • Faster-than-light travel: Still don't know how

Sponsor Content

  • Video sponsored by Audible
  • Audible features: audiobooks, podcasts, plus catalog, guided fitness programs
  • Currently listening to Lawrence Krauss's "The Physics of Climate Change" (read by Krauss)
  • Audible membership: 1 audiobook per month free + full plus catalog access
  • Sign up: audible.com/sabine or text "sabine" to 500-500
  • App features: free, simple, works on smartphones/tablets, download for offline listening

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome