AI summary by TwinMind
Does Working Hard Really Make You a Good Person? | Azim Shariff | TED
TED
12m 28s
Research on Effort Moralization
- Study scenario: medical scribe Jeff with 3 years guaranteed contract, job automated by software
- Option 1: stay home, get paid while software does work
- Option 2: continue working for same money despite automation
- Research findings on Jeff's character perception:
- Jeff choosing to work seen as less competent but warmer, more moral, trustworthy
- Perceived as virtuous despite adding no extra value
- Widget maker study: two producers, same output/quality/time
- Harder working one seen as less competent but more moral
- Preferred as cooperation partner despite no extra value
Cross-Cultural Evidence
- Effort moralization replicated across cultures:
- South Korea (hardest working OECD country)
- France
- Tanzania Hadza hunter-gatherers agreed on generosity and hard work as good character traits
- Not limited to Protestant work ethic - appears universal human tendency
Individual Level Logic - Partner Choice Theory
- Evolutionary psychology concept: selecting best cooperation partners
- Someone willing to put effort into meaningless tasks signals reliability
- Personal example: Paul (colleague) - charismatic, $60 soap bars, morning runner
- Observed Paul struggling during run with "grotesque grimace"
- Effort signals trustworthiness as collaboration partner
- Heuristic: "people who work hard are good"
- Example: more likely to donate to marathon runner vs Sex and the City watcher for same cause
Societal Level Problems - Workism Culture
- Individual logic becomes problematic when scaled up
- Effort moralization creates perverse incentives
- Workism (Derek Thompson term): job as identity source and self-actualization pathway
- Partner choice becomes competitive - not just hard working but harder working than others
- Arms race example: office workers arriving earlier and earlier
- Culture punishes non-participation, maintains laborious job aspects
Real-World Consequences
- David Graber's "bullshit jobs" - pointless work that accomplishes nothing
- Capitalism should eliminate inefficiencies but doesn't due to workism overlay
- Jeff scenario represents real people sacrificing love/leisure for effort signaling
- Workaholism as badge of honor and moral reassurance
Personal Academic Example
- Professor sending emails at 1-3 AM
- Graduate student used scheduling app to reply at late hours, appearing industrious
- Student delayed actual work to signal effort
- Had to change lab culture from show of work to actual productivity
Psychological Bias Recognition
- Mental circuit connecting effort to morality is stubborn
- Can't always resist biases but can learn to notice them
- Important to account for biases in decision-making
Cobra Bounty Analogy
- British colonial India story (likely apocryphal)
- Bounty for cobra skins to reduce snake population
- Indians bred cobras to kill for bounty money
- When program ended, breeders released cobras - problem worsened
- Distance between desired outcome (fewer cobras) and metric (dead cobras)
Solution Framework
- Culture asks for wrong thing - effort input vs meaningful output
- Asking for effort creates world full of effort and hard labor
- Asking for meaningful production creates world full of meaning
- Meaningful production is more moral than mere effort
