AI summary by TwinMind
๐บ๐ธ DOES YOUR FLAG FAIL? Grey Grades State Flags!
CGP Grey
18m 53s
Flag Design Guidelines and Grading Criteria
- Five core rules for flag design presented to students:
- Keep it simple - child should be able to draw it
- Make it distinct at a distance - not poster/wallpaper/patch
- Three colors or fewer unless expert level
- Include meaningful symbols representing citizens
- Zero words ideal - flag is not a note or name tag
- Grading system: S-tier (Super) to F-tier (Failed)
- F-tier subdivided into its own S-F ranking due to many failures
- Emphasis on "seal on blue" template as major design flaw
F-Tier Failures (Worst Performers)
Bottom F-Tier (F-F)
- Kansas, Montana, Wisconsin: Basic seal-on-blue template
- Montana: Terrible kerning on text
- Wisconsin: Cheese-based flag would be better
- Oregon: Different design on back (beaver) is much better, should ditch front
- California: "California Republic" text, scared-looking bear
- Republic lasted only 3 weeks
- Teacher disappointed, sees potential for improvement
- Dakota sisters: Both wrote names on flags
- North Dakota: Better drawn seal, D-tier F-tier
- South Dakota: Brighter blue, wrote name twice, F-tier twice
- Suggestion: Use spiky design elements for north-south sister theme
- Delaware: Full date written on bottom, F-F tier
- Idaho: Wrote name twice, F-F tier
- Illinois: Eagle design poor, backwards "sovereignty" text, date added, literally state seal on white background with "Illinois" written below, F-F tier
- Minnesota: Declared worst flag in Union, extremely busy design with name
Mid F-Tier
- Nebraska: Didn't write name prominently, F-D tier
- Vermont: Best looking seal so far, F-C tier
- Maine: Wrote name big but classy way, F-C tier
- New Hampshire: Good ship design, has three painted flags within flag, F-B tier
- Connecticut: Purple color (objectively worst color), grape motif, F-D tier
- Michigan: "Circumspice" text, boring blue, F-D tier
- Missouri: Multiple bears, 61 stars total (13 for original colonies, 24 for state entry twice), seal-ception design, tri-color base, D-tier
- Massachusetts: Not blue, relatively simple, F-C tier
- Kentucky: Wrote "Commonwealth" on flag, F-D tier
- Pennsylvania: Good seal-on-blue execution, didn't write commonwealth name, F-B tier
- Virginia: Nudity, murder, explicit violence depicted, but "badass", F-B tier
- Wyoming: Beautiful design ruined by seal with name, "Forever West" concept, S-tier F
- Iowa: Name plus instruction sentence, 12 words, very "'Murica", F-A tier
- Indiana: Good torch of liberty design, similar colors to Alaska, more identifiable, F-A tier (after revealing name)
- West Virginia: Deserves better than current design, F-D tier
- Arkansas: Name written large but "kind of works", diamonds theme, F-A tier
- Nevada: Boring design but "Battle Born" = best words ever on flag, historically accurate Civil War statehood
- Louisiana: Pelican "vulning" (injuring) herself, only flag showing actual blood, F-B tier
- Washington: Flag looks like money, George Washington's face inappropriate, F-C tier
- Oklahoma: Buffalo skin shield of Osage nation, pipe and olive branch symbolism, addresses Native American heritage well, F-C tier
- New Jersey: Unusual color choice but stands out, decent seal, F-B tier
- New York: Teacher's biggest disappointment as native son, Empire State should aspire to empire-level design like UK's Union Jack, F-C tier
- Florida: Copied Alabama's design but made it worse, added name, F-A tier for copying good design
Successful Designs (Higher Tiers)
S-Tier (Super)
- New Mexico: Zia sun symbol, sacred to Zia people, bold colors matching landscape, "enchanting", doesn't need name
- Maryland: "Hideous" but "so hideous it falls off bottom to land on top", wear with pride
- Utah: Last-minute redesign with beehive symbol, meaningful symbolism (industry, state star, red rocks, white peaks, blue sky), teacher's personal favorite due to bees and hexagons
A-Tier
- Alabama: Simple cross shape, identifiable at distance, vertical perfection, "so much more with so much less", fits international stage
- Tennessee: Underrated, blue bar keeps it distinct when flying, three stars for three grand divisions of rectangular state, B-tier on screen but A-tier in air
- Arizona: Red/yellow sunset representing state and Spanish settlers, copper star for "copper queen" and Wild West sheriffs
- Texas: Already knows it's A-tier, strong state pride, citizens love and use flag like still Republic of Texas, bonus points for usage
B-Tier
- Alaska: North star and Big Dipper (Ursa Major bear constellation), didn't write name, Best Bear Award winner, low contrast issues in dark winters, North star orientation problem, best in B-tier
- Ohio: Cape-shaped rather than rectangular, very "'Murica", people don't notice the "O"
- Hawaii: Ugly but magnificently so, eight stripes for eight islands, Union Jack historically confused (never British colony), rainbow flag concept
C-Tier
- Mississippi: Transitioned from old flag, added hidden words, magnolia flower too complicated but symbolically represents "Miss Magnolia Mississippi"
- Rhode Island: Wrote "hope" instead of name, sailing motif with anchors and colors works
- Colorado: Simple and distinct design, giant "C" too obvious and counts as writing, most people don't notice Ohio's "O"
D-Tier
- South Carolina: Disjointed design, palmetto looks like palm tree, Angel Oak would be better choice, didn't write name
- North Carolina: Teacher biased toward adoptive state, provokes pride, looks too much like someone else's flag, has letters and words
- Georgia: Almost works with seal in corner but doesn't, too similar to North Carolina, many words but no name
Special Awards and Recognition
- Best Bear Award: Alaska (Big Dipper as Ursa Major constellation)
- Most Bears: Missouri (bears holding seal with bear on it)
- Most Stars: Missouri (61 total)
- Most Words: South Dakota (17 words)
- Best Words on Flag: Nevada ("Battle Born")
- Word Count Rankings: Nebraska/Idaho tied at 12, Wyoming at 13, South Dakota at 17
Improvement Examples and Suggestions
- Mississippi: Model of achievable improvement through redesign
- Dakota sisters: Could create north-south sister-states theme with spiky elements
- Carolina sisters: Could consider Carolinian combo design like Dakotas
- Oregon: Should ditch front design, go all-in on beaver back design
- Wisconsin: Cheese-based flag would actually be better
- Nevada: Should put "Battle Born" in impact font
- Wyoming: Remove seal to achieve epic "Forever West" design
