AI summary by TwinMind

๐Ÿ‡บ๐Ÿ‡ธ DOES YOUR FLAG FAIL? Grey Grades State Flags!

CGP Grey

18m 53s

Flag Design Guidelines and Grading Criteria

  • Five core rules for flag design presented to students:
    • Keep it simple - child should be able to draw it
    • Make it distinct at a distance - not poster/wallpaper/patch
    • Three colors or fewer unless expert level
    • Include meaningful symbols representing citizens
    • Zero words ideal - flag is not a note or name tag
  • Grading system: S-tier (Super) to F-tier (Failed)
  • F-tier subdivided into its own S-F ranking due to many failures
  • Emphasis on "seal on blue" template as major design flaw

F-Tier Failures (Worst Performers)

Bottom F-Tier (F-F)

  • Kansas, Montana, Wisconsin: Basic seal-on-blue template
    • Montana: Terrible kerning on text
    • Wisconsin: Cheese-based flag would be better
  • Oregon: Different design on back (beaver) is much better, should ditch front
  • California: "California Republic" text, scared-looking bear
    • Republic lasted only 3 weeks
    • Teacher disappointed, sees potential for improvement
  • Dakota sisters: Both wrote names on flags
    • North Dakota: Better drawn seal, D-tier F-tier
    • South Dakota: Brighter blue, wrote name twice, F-tier twice
    • Suggestion: Use spiky design elements for north-south sister theme
  • Delaware: Full date written on bottom, F-F tier
  • Idaho: Wrote name twice, F-F tier
  • Illinois: Eagle design poor, backwards "sovereignty" text, date added, literally state seal on white background with "Illinois" written below, F-F tier
  • Minnesota: Declared worst flag in Union, extremely busy design with name

Mid F-Tier

  • Nebraska: Didn't write name prominently, F-D tier
  • Vermont: Best looking seal so far, F-C tier
  • Maine: Wrote name big but classy way, F-C tier
  • New Hampshire: Good ship design, has three painted flags within flag, F-B tier
  • Connecticut: Purple color (objectively worst color), grape motif, F-D tier
  • Michigan: "Circumspice" text, boring blue, F-D tier
  • Missouri: Multiple bears, 61 stars total (13 for original colonies, 24 for state entry twice), seal-ception design, tri-color base, D-tier
  • Massachusetts: Not blue, relatively simple, F-C tier
  • Kentucky: Wrote "Commonwealth" on flag, F-D tier
  • Pennsylvania: Good seal-on-blue execution, didn't write commonwealth name, F-B tier
  • Virginia: Nudity, murder, explicit violence depicted, but "badass", F-B tier
  • Wyoming: Beautiful design ruined by seal with name, "Forever West" concept, S-tier F
  • Iowa: Name plus instruction sentence, 12 words, very "'Murica", F-A tier
  • Indiana: Good torch of liberty design, similar colors to Alaska, more identifiable, F-A tier (after revealing name)
  • West Virginia: Deserves better than current design, F-D tier
  • Arkansas: Name written large but "kind of works", diamonds theme, F-A tier
  • Nevada: Boring design but "Battle Born" = best words ever on flag, historically accurate Civil War statehood
  • Louisiana: Pelican "vulning" (injuring) herself, only flag showing actual blood, F-B tier
  • Washington: Flag looks like money, George Washington's face inappropriate, F-C tier
  • Oklahoma: Buffalo skin shield of Osage nation, pipe and olive branch symbolism, addresses Native American heritage well, F-C tier
  • New Jersey: Unusual color choice but stands out, decent seal, F-B tier
  • New York: Teacher's biggest disappointment as native son, Empire State should aspire to empire-level design like UK's Union Jack, F-C tier
  • Florida: Copied Alabama's design but made it worse, added name, F-A tier for copying good design

Successful Designs (Higher Tiers)

S-Tier (Super)

  • New Mexico: Zia sun symbol, sacred to Zia people, bold colors matching landscape, "enchanting", doesn't need name
  • Maryland: "Hideous" but "so hideous it falls off bottom to land on top", wear with pride
  • Utah: Last-minute redesign with beehive symbol, meaningful symbolism (industry, state star, red rocks, white peaks, blue sky), teacher's personal favorite due to bees and hexagons

A-Tier

  • Alabama: Simple cross shape, identifiable at distance, vertical perfection, "so much more with so much less", fits international stage
  • Tennessee: Underrated, blue bar keeps it distinct when flying, three stars for three grand divisions of rectangular state, B-tier on screen but A-tier in air
  • Arizona: Red/yellow sunset representing state and Spanish settlers, copper star for "copper queen" and Wild West sheriffs
  • Texas: Already knows it's A-tier, strong state pride, citizens love and use flag like still Republic of Texas, bonus points for usage

B-Tier

  • Alaska: North star and Big Dipper (Ursa Major bear constellation), didn't write name, Best Bear Award winner, low contrast issues in dark winters, North star orientation problem, best in B-tier
  • Ohio: Cape-shaped rather than rectangular, very "'Murica", people don't notice the "O"
  • Hawaii: Ugly but magnificently so, eight stripes for eight islands, Union Jack historically confused (never British colony), rainbow flag concept

C-Tier

  • Mississippi: Transitioned from old flag, added hidden words, magnolia flower too complicated but symbolically represents "Miss Magnolia Mississippi"
  • Rhode Island: Wrote "hope" instead of name, sailing motif with anchors and colors works
  • Colorado: Simple and distinct design, giant "C" too obvious and counts as writing, most people don't notice Ohio's "O"

D-Tier

  • South Carolina: Disjointed design, palmetto looks like palm tree, Angel Oak would be better choice, didn't write name
  • North Carolina: Teacher biased toward adoptive state, provokes pride, looks too much like someone else's flag, has letters and words
  • Georgia: Almost works with seal in corner but doesn't, too similar to North Carolina, many words but no name

Special Awards and Recognition

  • Best Bear Award: Alaska (Big Dipper as Ursa Major constellation)
  • Most Bears: Missouri (bears holding seal with bear on it)
  • Most Stars: Missouri (61 total)
  • Most Words: South Dakota (17 words)
  • Best Words on Flag: Nevada ("Battle Born")
  • Word Count Rankings: Nebraska/Idaho tied at 12, Wyoming at 13, South Dakota at 17

Improvement Examples and Suggestions

  • Mississippi: Model of achievable improvement through redesign
  • Dakota sisters: Could create north-south sister-states theme with spiky elements
  • Carolina sisters: Could consider Carolinian combo design like Dakotas
  • Oregon: Should ditch front design, go all-in on beaver back design
  • Wisconsin: Cheese-based flag would actually be better
  • Nevada: Should put "Battle Born" in impact font
  • Wyoming: Remove seal to achieve epic "Forever West" design

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome