AI summary by TwinMind

Dr. Aomawa Shields | A Memoir of Finding My Place in the Universe | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

48m 25s

Introduction and Background

  • Jennifer Fick (Google cryptography/security engineer) hosts Dr. Aomawa Shields
  • Dr. Shields: UC Irvine astronomy/astrobiology professor, author, mother, mentor, classically trained actor
  • Work shown at Sundance Film Festival
  • Honors: TED fellow, NSF career award, NASA habitable worlds/exoplanets research grant
  • Discussion focuses on her book about life on other planets

Core Research Question and Methodology

  • Primary question: "Are we alone in the universe?"
  • Uses computer climate modeling adapted from Earth weather/climate prediction models
  • Modifiable parameters:
    • Type of star planet orbits
    • Orbital shape and tilt
    • Planet's axis tilt
    • Atmospheric composition
  • Goal: identify planets most likely to host habitable conditions across widest range of factors
  • Work bridges observational astronomy gaps with computational modeling

Scale of the Universe and Probability of Life

  • 10^22 stars in observable universe
  • Analogy: equivalent to dry grains of sand on all beaches worldwide
  • ~Every star has planets
  • 20-25% of planets in habitable zones ("Goldilocks zone")
  • 5,500 exoplanets discovered so far
  • Few dozen potentially in habitable zones
  • Reference to "Contact" movie quote: "If it's just us, it would be an awful waste of space"

Exoplanet Habitability Criteria

  • Primary requirement: liquid water (common denominator for all Earth life)
  • Planet size: 1-1.5x Earth size likely rocky with solid surface
  • Temperature range: warm enough for liquid water, not too hot for evaporation
  • Focus on earth-sized planets where "something could stand and oceans could flow"

Life as We Know It vs. Life as We Don't Know It

  • Life as we know it: uses liquid water as solvent for metabolic processes
  • Earth has astronomical diversity within this framework (microbes to elephants)
  • Life as we don't know it: alternative biochemistry
    • Different solvents (liquid ethane/methane like Saturn's moon Titan)
    • Different backbone elements (silicon instead of carbon)
  • Astrobiology is interdisciplinary: astronomers, biologists, geologists, oceanographers, glaciologists
  • Field is 60-70 years old vs. astronomy's ancient origins

Climate Change and Earth's Habitability

  • Same models used for exoplanets originally proved anthropogenic climate change
  • Models show human-made CO2 impact through 2100s
  • Natural cyclical CO2 changes exist, but current trend shows steep slope increase
  • Global average surface temperature increasing by couple degrees minimum
  • Shields taught energy/environment course as astronomer, learning alongside students
  • Fossil fuel reserves are limited beyond climate impact
  • Both/and approach: address Earth's climate change AND search for life elsewhere
  • Understanding Earth's CO2 impact helps apply knowledge to other planets
    • Some distant planets could benefit from more CO2 (too cold)
    • Earth has too much CO2

Distance and Detection Challenges

  • Closest potentially habitable planet: Proxima Centauri b
  • Distance: 4 light years = ~40 trillion miles
  • Current space propulsion inadequate for significant light speed fractions
  • Reliance on telescopes and instrumentation improvements
  • James Webb Space Telescope exceeding expectations
    • Originally not expected to study earth-sized planets effectively
    • Now confirmed presence of earth-sized planet
    • Moving toward atmospheric analysis capabilities

Observational Techniques and Limitations

Transit Technique

  • Detects planets by measuring star brightness dips when planet passes in front
  • Periodic dips indicate orbiting object
  • Dip ratio determines planet size

Doppler/Radial Velocity Technique

  • Measures gravitational effects on star's orbit
  • Star and planet orbit common center of mass
  • Star's "wobble" indicates planet mass
  • Combined with transit data gives density (mass/volume)
  • Density indicates composition: rocky vs. gaseous vs. water-rich vs. iron-rich

Current Limitations

  • Can determine atmospheric composition of larger Jupiter/Neptune-sized planets
  • Cannot yet analyze earth-sized planet atmospheres
  • Limited surface composition data

Computational Modeling Advantages

  • Can test unlimited surface compositions: ice, ocean, granite, vegetation, calcite, sand
  • Can model various atmospheric compositions and scenarios
  • Example predictions:
    • Ocean-covered planet too close to star → steam atmosphere → runaway greenhouse like Venus
    • Robust planets habitable across multiple atmospheric scenarios
  • Models identify priority targets for telescope follow-up

Biosignatures and Detection Methods

  • Biosignatures: biologically generated environmental impacts observable from space
  • Gas combinations that only life could produce
  • Surface detection: sunlight reflecting off liquids (but could be non-water liquids)
  • Atmospheric analysis for life indicators

Computational Challenges and Future Directions

Current Model Types

  • 1D models: fast but oversimplified, good for initial graduate student training
  • 3D Global Climate Models: weeks to reach thermal equilibrium per simulation
  • Multiple parameter variations require weeks upon weeks
  • Some studies create hypothetical planets around different stars

Statistical and AI Integration

  • Movement toward statistical frameworks for climate modeling
  • Potential AI method applications
  • Shields' concerns: maintaining scientific rigor and robustness
  • Human analysis essential for distinguishing physical effects from model artifacts
  • No substitute for human examination of climate data

Personal Journey and Career Path

  • Left first PhD program, returned 11 years later ("solar cycle")
  • First attempt: studying irregular and spiral galaxies
  • Exoplanet field in infancy when first started (first exoplanet found year before)
  • Second PhD attempt motivated by genuine love for field vs. expected path
  • Different life outcomes: wouldn't have met husband or had same daughter
  • Catalyst for leaving: discouragement both external and internal
  • Believes things worked out as supposed to

Academic Power Structures and Inclusion

Advisor-Student Power Dynamics

  • Shields recognizes tremendous influence as advisor
  • Experienced discouragement as student: told to "consider other career options"
  • Now understands she's not powerful enough to dictate someone's future
  • Focuses on questions about passion and work ethic vs. career suitability
  • Avoids discouraging statements about field appropriateness

Retention vs. Recruitment

  • Not just about getting underrepresented students into programs
  • Critical importance of keeping them there
  • Students from marginalized communities carry additional burdens:
    • Family histories of racism and oppression
    • Legacy challenges beyond academic workload
  • Professor sensitivity to unseen struggles
  • Asking "How are you really doing?" vs. focusing only on academic performance

Rising Star Girls Program

  • Middle school girls of color astronomy program
  • Encourages bringing family backgrounds and breakfast table conversations
  • Personal connection to universe essential before tackling "heavy math"
  • Personal informs professional approach

Integration of Personal and Professional

  • Personal feelings impact scientific ability daily
  • To-do lists must adapt to personal state (e.g., three hours sleep)
  • Humans aren't machines - feelings affect work quality
  • Essential for both student success and professional achievement

Diversity and Scientific Progress

  • Moon landing achieved with limited participation - only small fraction allowed at table
  • Imagining potential if everyone included in scientific endeavors
  • Affirmative action ensures everyone has place at table
  • Eliminating affirmative action presumes equality already achieved (not yet case)
  • If everyone included in answering "are we alone" question by 2050, goal potentially achievable
  • Universal inclusion would accelerate scientific discovery

Future Observatory Missions

  • LUVOIR (Large UV Optical IR Surveyor)
  • HabEx (Habitable Exoplanet Observatory)
  • Astro 2020 decadal survey recommendations
  • ~6-meter mirror space telescopes needed
  • Required light-gathering power for exoplanet atmospheric analysis
  • Coronagraphy needed: block star light (100 million to 10^10 times brighter than planet)
  • Missions still in concept phase
  • Would provide bio-signature detection capabilities

Personal Authenticity and Self-Discovery

Gradual Change Process

  • Doesn't require radical overnight changes
  • Small incremental steps over time
  • Examples: playing dusty guitar for 5 minutes, buying magazine on loved topic
  • Ways to signal universe you're open to authentic self
  • Dreams don't disappear when ignored - they eventually demand attention
  • Physical/emotional effects of denying authentic self: gut feelings, soul sadness

Practical Steps

  • Acknowledge suppressed parts of self
  • Bring authentic interests into life weekly if not daily
  • Small manageable steps signal openness to universe
  • Universe responds with opportunities when you become open
  • Miracles happen through openness rather than forced effort

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome