AI summary by TwinMind
Elizabeth Block | Beyond Vanity: The History and Power of Hairdressing | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
31m 56s
Introduction and Book Overview
- Host: Linda Davis, DEI organizational effectiveness program manager in engineering org within cloud
- Guest: Elizabeth L. Block, art historian, senior editor at Metropolitan Museum of Art Publications
- Book focus: "Beyond Vanity: The History and Power of Hairdressing" covering 1865-1900 period
- Research methodology: visual and material culture studies informed by cultural geography concepts
- Book examines race, racism impact on hair presentation and business practices
Author Background and Research Inspiration
- Block's PhD in art history, focus on late 19th century American painting
- Daily exposure to paintings by John Singer Sargent, Mary Cassatt, Eastman Johnson at museum
- Noticed gap in art historical studies: attention to painter technique/biography but not women's presentation
- Limited focus on what women wore, hair styling, self-presentation for expensive portrait opportunities
- Research period: post-Civil War 1865-1900, very rich period in American and hairdressing history
Research Approach and Scope
- First book "Dressing Up" focused on top 1% wealthiest women buying Paris fashion
- "Beyond Vanity" deliberately focuses on all classes of women
- Examines multi-ethnic people, practices, ways of life
- Studies lower and middle classes in this historical period
- Looks at black women, mixed race women, white women beauty standard circulation
Beauty Standards and Cultural Impact
- Dominant ideal: white woman with long luxurious, glossy, wavy/curly textured hair
- Long hair needed for fashionable updos with braids twirled around head
- Abundance required for crescent pins, jeweled ornaments (often family heirlooms)
- White European beauty standards transferred directly from Europe to United States
- Standards were transgressed and adopted by black and mixed race women
- Most black/mixed race women styled hair naturally despite market products focused on straightening
Women Entrepreneurs in Hair Industry
- Surprising number of women entrepreneurs in hairdressing business
- Many black and mixed race women creating products for their communities
- Products addressed textured hair needs but also sold to white women
- Cosmetics and hair history interconnected (hair straightening + complexion whitening products)
Case Study: Christiana Carto Banister
- Black and Native American descent, worked late 1860s until 1902
- Operated in Boston and Providence, Rhode Island
- Used hair salons/"hair rooms" for emancipation advocacy in 1860s
- Husband Edward Mitchell Banister: well-known black landscape painter
- Edward started as barber, transitioned to painting due to Christiana's hairdressing success
- Christiana's business financially supported Edward's artistic career
- Her spaces served as community gathering points for political advocacy
Gender Dynamics in Hair Services
- Hair world less gendered than previously thought
- Men participated in women's hair spaces for political advocacy
- Women visited male barber shops for hair trims (concerned about split ends)
- Literature references (Little Women): Joe getting haircut from male barber with wife present
- Famous hairdressers in period were often men, especially French hairdressers in New York
- Wealthy women (Caroline Astor, Alva Vanderbilt) booked appointments at 7-8am for evening events
- Similar to modern Met Gala preparation timing
Textured Hair Care and Enslaved Women's Experiences
- Limited time for enslaved women to care for own hair
- Enslaved women responsible for mistress's hair care during week
- Sunday personal time for own hair care in quarters
- Natural ingredients used: coconut oil, olive oil, castor oil, egg yolks for moisture
- Hair wraps/tenons worn to keep hair clean and dust-free
- Contrast between caring for white women's hair vs. limited time for own hair
Modern Connections and Continuing Issues
- Many ingredients/practices continue today: scalp health focus, pre-wash oils
- Salicylic acid found in 19th century products, still used for scalp health
- Short hair in 19th century symbolized illness/poor health (typhoid fever concerns)
- Crown Act legislation: passed in 24 states, fighting workplace/school hair discrimination
- Ongoing racism in hair presentation reception
- Recent cases: Texas students sent home for locs, braids, cornrows
Historical Methodology and Visual Culture
- Book uses visual and material culture methodology
- Examines advertisements from national periodicals (Godey's Ladies Book, Peterson's Magazine)
- Analyzes newspapers aimed at black and mixed race readers
- "Reading against the grain" approach to interpret historical sources
- Multiple advertisement strategies: different messages for white vs. community readerships
Call to Action and Future Vision
- Author's goal: hair studies becoming central to women's history like education and politics
- Hair as "common material with uncommon abilities to express individualism"
- Need to move beyond "busy work" tactics that harm individuals
- Opportunity for educational integration from grade school through college
- Focus should shift from silencing people through hair policies to elevating individuals
