AI summary by TwinMind
Elizabeth Green | Building a Better News Organization | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
1h 2m 3s
Introduction and Background
- Elizabeth Green, co-founder/CEO of Chalkbeat and co-founder of American Journalism Project
- Chalkbeat: non-profit news organization covering education decisions/debates impacting children/families
- 8 bureaus nationwide, 60 places on waiting list to become bureaus
- Daily local school coverage plus expansion into voting/election administration
- American Journalism Project: funding mechanism for next generation local news enterprises in large/mid-sized metropolitan markets
COVID-19 Impact on Education
- Massive disruption to education system with many children not physically in school
- Key learnings: people need social environments to learn, most require physical settings
- Education provides vital services beyond instruction: childcare for economy, feeds children/families
- Long-term impacts unknown due to lagging data in education sector
- Early indicators show exacerbating existing disparities
- Boys of color (Black and Latino) most affected with major attendance gaps in virtual vs in-person school
- Educator workforce challenges with troubling early indicators about retention/attraction
- Historically, educator workforce challenges disproportionately affect students of color
Broader Challenges and Context
- COVID intersecting with racial reckoning, Black Lives Matter movement and backlash
- Concerning data on disruptive behavior patterns in schools affecting all children
- Rising gun violence in American communities adding to stress
- Emotional challenges for both adults and children during this period
- Children excluded from social learning opportunities for extended periods
Potential Silver Linings and Opportunities
- Over $100 billion allocated in additional federal dollars to schools as part of recovery package
- Opportunity for long-lasting investments that could change public education functioning
- Challenging to execute due to incredible decisions resting on superintendents, school boards, principals
- Educational decisions, public health decisions, expenditure decisions all required simultaneously
- Underscores commitment to journalism providing vital information to decision-makers
Elizabeth Green's Journey into Journalism
- Started in journalism right out of college at U.S. News and World Report
- Introduced to journalism by high school teacher who encouraged crossing social bubbles
- Transformative conversations with diverse students revealed educational inequities
- Minority at school as white student with college-bound trajectory
- Journalism enabled encounters outside bubble and helped community reckon with challenges
- Saw journalism's unique power to enable encounters and spark change
- Love of learning about people's experiences through long interviews
- Journalism can break through loneliness/alienation with authentic encounters
Journalism's Mission and Challenges
- Not all journalism accomplishes positive connection - can do inflammatory damage
- Different kinds of journalism exist with varying approaches
- Contrast between high school utopian experience and commercial journalism reality
- Mission-driven journalism vs profit-driven journalism tension
Chalkbeat's Business Model and Non-Profit Approach
- Commercial journalism model often in tension with mission
- When mission is profit, can exclude meaningful local journalism
- Enforces less local, more global/national coverage that's alienating
- Takes people away from truth toward financial opportunity
- Journalism as classic public good: everyone benefits whether they pay or not
- Must find ways to collectively subsidize outside market context
- Historical local newspaper bundle model: classified ads, weather, movie listings, sports subsidized "vegetables" (school coverage, city council, planning decisions)
- Internet as "ultimate unbundler" disrupted newspaper monopoly on print attention
- Commercial information pieces splintered into single-topic products (Weather.com, Craigslist, Fandango)
- Newspaper advertising revenue was $50 billion annually, has more than halved
- Subsidy mechanism for "vegetables of media diet" no longer exists
New Funding Model
- Three types of money: commercial, government, philanthropy
- Chalkbeat utilizes philanthropy first, open to government support with independence protection
- Tertiary commercial revenue to subsidize, not primary focus
- Digital native unbundled approach: topical expertise distributed through multiple channels
- Single topic focus (education) with multiple geographic areas served
- Acknowledges people consume news through various surfaces: phones, TV, chat platforms, newsletters
- Getting "vegetables into as many streams as possible"
Google's Role and Civic Responsibility
- Google also advertising company, similar model to news industry
- Advertising dollars shifting due to technological change, not individual company responsibility
- Google, Facebook, Twitter now monopolizing attention in parallel ways
- Responsibility to be part of subsidy solution for civic news
- Historical publishers like Graham family (Washington Post) made civic commitments as part of business
- Invitation for attention/advertising companies to make similar commitments adapted to current environment
- Win-win of brand trust by investing in truth and social responsibility
American Journalism Project and Funding Needs
- Missing $1-3 billion annually in resources for local news "vegetables"
- Need to dramatically increase resources for public good journalism
- Creating new social sector transitioning from commercial to social funding
- First ever venture philanthropy firm dedicated to local news
- Making consequential investments in future local news non-profit institutions
- Models include topic-focused multi-regional (Chalkbeat) and multi-topic regional (Berkeley Side expanding to Oakland)
Success Metrics and Impact Measurement
- Journalism field historically had almost no metrics except awards (Pulitzer, front page)
- Internet enabled knowing too much about readership while knowing nothing about impact
- Theory of change: inform decision-making and debate
- Success not just about clicks/readership numbers but quality of readers
- If three key decision-makers read article and make change, more valuable than high general readership
- Look for combination of readership numbers and evidence of changed decision-making/debate
- Rich area where non-journalistic skills can help journalists improve measurement
Combating Misinformation
- "Garbage in, garbage out" principle
- Two ways to address: regulate misinformation and plant alternatives
- Can't solve uninformed citizens problem without providing accurate information
- Need more actionable local news about community realities
- Closer authentic encounters reduce hopelessness and division
- Education essential for civic literacy and navigating information landscape
- Give young people civic experiences to build civic literacy
Career Advice and Skills Needed
- Exciting area with potential for big impact
- Business model problem as much as journalism problem
- All kinds of skills needed: accounting, technical skills, not just reporting
- Best way to become reporter is to try reporting
- Journalism jobs declined more than coal mining jobs in last 15 years
- Need $1-3 billion to create new jobs in sector
- Institute for Non-Profit News organizations good places to look
- Chalkbeat ~75 people, always looking for diverse skills
Education System Challenges
- Cultural reasons for U.S. education challenges vs other countries
- Attitude toward learning differs from countries like Japan
- Legacy of white supremacy deeply embedded in education system
- Historically illegal for Black people to read or attend adequately resourced schools
- Cultural threads need changing alongside concrete policy investments
- Research shows more money does help schools
- Need coordination across uncoordinated education system pieces
- Many concrete programs work while cultural change takes longer
